Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina (light novel)
Available on Manga Store
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 16, 2020 11:06 PM
#201
Opticflash said: I don't think it's that people think she should be responsible with great power. I think it's because they can't actually reason at all. They'll see a protagonist with a personality trait they don't like and then claim the anime is terrible because the character didn't fit their ideal, morally "perfect" superhero vision of what a main protagonist should be. Ask them to analyze a movie like Joker and these dumb dumbs will say it's a shit movie because Joker is a bad guy while ignoring the vastly complex presentation of the character and the themes and morals depicted. I personally wouldn't say that the attitude you are describing stems from inherent irrationality or stupidity, but rather from a lack of moral flexibility. A lot of people are unwilling to discard their moral axioms in order to try to better understand another person's viewpoint. I don't blame them for that, since I've been that type of person in the past, plus being dogmatic is the easy road to take and I take the easy road in different ways myself; however, it does make it difficult to enjoy a morally nuanced anime like this one. |
Every day you can read a book or watch some anime is a good day! |
Oct 16, 2020 11:07 PM
#202
Elaina didn't have to do anything, but way she haven't reporter the flower field at least to other towns? What if the flowers reach her parent house in future or all the word at some point? Though the town should had more protection if they know that flowers are poisonous. Someone could have bring them inside unnoticed. Why they didn't pay some witch for killing the monster flower? It's just I think that they could do so many but they do nothing to protect themselves ; p. I believe that manga chapter for this story have much more sense. Besides that I'm wondering if the girl from ep. 2 and girl from second half of ep. 3 are sisters. Also if she really killed herself, it was her choice. I would at least try to run from there. Still I hope Elaina run in to good stories also. I don't see a point in traveling the word only to witness deaths or pain if she takes no action to stop them or maybe she will write them dawn for other people as a warning what may happen at least? |
Namu12Oct 16, 2020 11:12 PM
Oct 16, 2020 11:24 PM
#203
hazarddex said: she knew the story behind the flowers and she knew the plants were dangerous, but she did it anyways. ??? She was TOLD by the guard about the flowers. Are we watching the same anime? hazarddex said: i find it more funny people try to deflect criticism of a character. ??? When did I try to deflect criticism of her character? Sure, I'll criticize Arthur as a morally corrupt character. Does (Arthur - bad/psychopathic character) == (Joker - bad movie)? Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post and baiting. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 2:42 PM
Oct 16, 2020 11:31 PM
#204
Opticflash said: hazarddex said: she knew the story behind the flowers and she knew the plants were dangerous, but she did it anyways. ??? She was TOLD by the guard about the flowers. Are we watching the same anime? hazarddex said: i find it more funny people try to deflect criticism of a character. ??? When did I try to deflect criticism of her character? Sure, I'll criticize Arthur as a morally corrupt character. Does (Arthur - bad/psychopathic character) == (Joker - bad movie)? in the LN she knew the entire story and how it ended and still did it. imagine trying to compare a 1 dimensional character that doesn't really contribute anything to the story besides acting as the "view point." compared to the joker who had a compelling shirty life leading him downs route to do bad things later on. smh real tied of people trying to compare this to kino no tabi and mushishi they are literally noting alike other then going to places. which spice and wolf also does, but i wouldn't call kino no tabi spice and wolf. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 2:43 PM
"among monsters and humans, there are only two types. Those who undergo suffering and spread it to others. And those who undergo suffering and avoid giving it to others." -Alice “Beauty is no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty.” David Hume “Evil is created when someone gives up on someone else. It appears when everyone gives up on someone as a lost cause and removes their path to salvation. Once they are cut off from everyone else, they become evil.” -Othinus |
Oct 16, 2020 11:35 PM
#205
Elaina is indeed a WITCH. |
I love K-On, and so should you. |
Oct 16, 2020 11:36 PM
#206
Ranger_Reisoda said: What she could have done?It's very common for anime protagonist to be righteous and jump into action even if they are completely uninvolved, so it's strange to see such a passive reaction to tragic situations. However, it is refreshing to see. We might want the characters to do the right thing and get a happy ending, but that isn't always possible or realistic. I don't think Elaina's behaviour was cruel in Nino's story. In the scene where she was pointing her wand at the fat guy it seemed like she wanted to intervene, but becoming a murderer obviously wouldn't benefit Elaina or solve the problem. Its not like Elaina had a place for Nino to go either. She encouraged bowl hair cut guy to try make her happy which is about all she could've done. Elaina not wanting to know what happened to her is not from a lack of concern imo, it could be more like sadness or guilt for not being able to help. Or maybe she didnt want to confront something emotionally difficult and would rather not think about it. You can speculate on it but even then her going back would probably not do any good. As for the story with the zombie plant people, I think Elaina probably could've done something about that. Since she would be one of the few people unaffected by it. What exactly she could've done though, idk. She could burn the whole field but that would definitely be very macabre because there are still living people in amongst it, even if they are brainwashed. I cant see Elaina putting the brother out of his misery either, even if that would be the most ethical thing to do; Elaina is still a young girl. It was a pretty abrupt cliffhanger too, maybe leaving out the zombies heading towards the city would've been better. Option 1: Burn the field. People inside the field are already beyond saving Option 2: Call down snow . Plants generally die or become dormant at small temperatures way before humans can be affected by it. Option 3: Call an army of locust to consume the field Option 4: Use plant killing substances. As a witch and a book worm she probably know of a lot of them. Option 5: Make a huge wall around the garden Option 6: modify the plant so that it does not feed on human mana anymore Option 7: move the field somewhere without humans Option 8: levitate the flowers and squash them And that is from the top of my head... also the plants consume mana which is kind like lifeforce in this universe not magic. They are affected by magic. |
Oct 16, 2020 11:37 PM
#207
gaussian_ said: Opticflash said: I don't think it's that people think she should be responsible with great power. I think it's because they can't actually reason at all. They'll see a protagonist with a personality trait they don't like and then claim the anime is terrible because the character didn't fit their ideal, morally "perfect" superhero vision of what a main protagonist should be. Ask them to analyze a movie like Joker and these dumb dumbs will say it's a shit movie because Joker is a bad guy while ignoring the vastly complex presentation of the character and the themes and morals depicted. I personally wouldn't say that the attitude you are describing stems from inherent irrationality or stupidity, but rather from a lack of moral flexibility. A lot of people are unwilling to discard their moral axioms in order to try to better understand another person's viewpoint. I don't blame them for that, since I've been that type of person in the past, plus being dogmatic is the easy road to take and I take the easy road in different ways myself; however, it does make it difficult to enjoy a morally nuanced anime like this one. I would buy that if it were not for the fact that there is a litany of visual and written works that depict characters with questionable moral values (by Western standards) that people pay almost no attention to; Joker being one of them. Even in manga/anime there are works like Code Geass/Death Note, etc. In many video games there are an overwhelming number of questionable elements, but hey if it's all in the name of "fun", who cares about them? I agree with your sentiment in general, but if people thought more critically about what they are viewing, there shouldn't be any heated discussions like this. |
Oct 16, 2020 11:49 PM
#208
Did she basically poison/kill an entire town or did I miss something? It seems like the burned flowers turned into a poisonous gas turning everyone that was in that square into flower zombies who are now bringing arm fulls of flowers to town. I'm sure there's some spell she could've done to get rid of them. She could have warned the town about the flower zombies at the very least. If she's going to journey through the world causing problems and not bothering to be part of the solution, she should just go home. Not helping Nino is understandable. That land has a culture of slavery and it looks like they're not going to change. If she wasn't willing to go all the way and take responsibility for Nino, i.e. take her with her or "get rid" of the village elder, then she needed to leave the situation alone. I actually like that she's not self righteously pushing her ideals on to others. |
dragynfaerieOct 17, 2020 12:05 AM
Oct 16, 2020 11:49 PM
#209
WTF, i thought this anime was something to relax with, but after this im going to drop that shit. I hope this MC get killed in the future |
Oct 16, 2020 11:52 PM
#210
Well, I was really expecting that Elaina will do atleast something about Nina's situation but yeah instead she chose not to meddle with it. This really shows how her character is just a 'wanderer' or a 'traveler' and not some type of hero that will try to save everything that comes to her path. I liked the episode, even though it had that really dark tone it. Here's to hoping that the future ones would have a more positive tone than this one. |
krukroooOct 17, 2020 7:21 PM
Oct 16, 2020 11:54 PM
#211
I'll say it again: Elaina is indeed a fcking WITCH. |
I love K-On, and so should you. |
Oct 16, 2020 11:56 PM
#212
dragynfaerie said: Did she basically poison/kill an entire town or did I miss something? It seems like the burned flowers turned into a poisonous gas turning everyone that was in that square into flower zombies who are now bringing arm fulls of flowers to town. I'm sure there's some spell she could've done to get rid of them. Yes she did. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 2:45 PM
"among monsters and humans, there are only two types. Those who undergo suffering and spread it to others. And those who undergo suffering and avoid giving it to others." -Alice “Beauty is no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty.” David Hume “Evil is created when someone gives up on someone else. It appears when everyone gives up on someone as a lost cause and removes their path to salvation. Once they are cut off from everyone else, they become evil.” -Othinus |
Oct 16, 2020 11:56 PM
#213
Oct 16, 2020 11:57 PM
#214
gaussian_ said: It seems that a lot of the people in this thread have internalized Uncle Ben's advice "With great power come great responsibility." I don't think it's that people think she should be responsible with great power. I think it's because they can't actually reason at all. They'll see a protagonist with a personality trait they don't like and then claim the anime is terrible because the character didn't fit their ideal, morally "perfect" superhero vision of what a main protagonist should be. Ask them to analyze a movie like Joker and these dumb dumbs will say it's a shit movie because Joker is a bad guy while ignoring the vastly complex presentation of the character and the themes and morals depicted. Many people here are used to the idealized girls that abound so much in the typicals mangas/novels of romance and harem, "perfect girls" that respond to the taste of the self-insert, surely they cannot conceive of a girl who does not fit with their "dreamly pixie waifu" ideal. |
Oct 17, 2020 12:13 AM
#215
Namu12 said: Elaina didn't have to do anything, but way she haven't reporter the flower field at least to other towns? What if the flowers reach her parent house in future or all the word at some point? Though the town should had more protection if they know that flowers are poisonous. Someone could have bring them inside unnoticed. Why they didn't pay some witch for killing the monster flower? It's just I think that they could do so many but they do nothing to protect themselves ; p. I believe that manga chapter for this story have much more sense. Besides that I'm wondering if the girl from ep. 2 and girl from second half of ep. 3 are sisters. Also if she really killed herself, it was her choice. I would at least try to run from there. Still I hope Elaina run in to good stories also. I don't see a point in traveling the word only to witness deaths or pain if she takes no action to stop them or maybe she will write them dawn for other people as a warning what may happen at least? You saved me the time to write my opinion...........a agree with almost everything......(except nino's choice to kill herself.........)....... People in this thread are thinking that Elaina is some kind of realistic protag. or something..............WELL NO SHE IS NOT...............Yesterday i completed inuyashiki..................Her character is similar to shishigami(on a much lesser magnitude)...........she might care about those who she knows........but she is indifferent to strangers........SHE IS NOT CRUEL, SHE JUST DOES NOT CARE(shishigami was the same).......and that is a really bitchy thing to do........but you cannot blame her as she is not harming anyone(she did not attack the village chief in spite of taking the stance).....BUT SHE IS NOT SAVING ANYONE EITHER..........though the people blaming her are not in the wrong either, and the major reason is that she is A QUALIFIED WITCH MUCH STRONGER THAN NORMAL HUMANS.......as someone standing above, she has a responsibility to protect them......but it is not a CONDITION.......it is her choice to help or ignore............IF YOU TAKE THE EXAMPLE OF THAT SOLDIER........Elaina could have saved him....(and it was her duty to help him as he was not able to save himself and was not strong enough).....but she chooses not to........ |
Oct 17, 2020 12:18 AM
#216
Oct 17, 2020 12:26 AM
#217
Oh, and one more thing, just because the MC is a shitty person, that doesnt mean she is "realistic", you all are just too ""cult"" (translation: dumb people who think they're intelligent for liking something "different") to see this |
Oct 17, 2020 1:01 AM
#218
This episode looked just as amazing as the last two, however, the subject mater was a little too realistic and uncomfortable. It was clear that the Village Chief was likely abusing Nino, and if he wasn't yet he intended too ("i bought her as she'll grow into a real beauty"). So Nino can either become an unwilling wife or a Village Chief's plaything, not the happiest ending, as Elaina herself commented when she was pondering Nino's life, she said she didn't know what happened to Nino & didn't want to know. This episode reminded me of Mushishi where you get beautiful settings mixed alongside uncomfortable situations, where people do strange things for many reasons. That's real life, but I was hoping for a slightly lighter atmosphere for the show. You can see from these two stories that Elaina knows when to walk away (that's not quite right, she makes a calculated choice whether to involve herself or not and these people are all strangers, is it her place to intervene in their lives, these morally ambiguous decisions are hard to fathom without knowing Elaina's full mindset, I'm not sure why she didn't save the soldier, but I assume she had a reason) and doesn't try and rescue every single person in distress she meets, as many anime MC try to do. "Who is the beauty blooming like the brightest flower, it's me". I wonder if Elaina will ever fall in love, she reminds me of that Greek tale of the guy who fell in love with his own reflection. |
23feanorOct 17, 2020 1:09 AM
Oct 17, 2020 2:16 AM
#219
Mixed feelings about this episode, in all honesty. Elaina being full of herself in the previous two episodes was kind of entertaining but I don't know if I feel the same anymore. I understand that she doesn't want to take part in all these conflicts and I respect that but lending a little hand at times can't be too bad, no? I don't know if it's because of the justice in me acting up lol but I definitely can't say I was totally on board with how things progressed this episode. Judging from the comments above, I'm guessing this dark tone will be more predominant going forward and here's to hoping I'll be able to appreciate it more from next episode onwards. Didn't experience this muddy feeling as much as during my watch of Lerche's Kino no Tabi though, I wonder why. |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni |
Oct 17, 2020 2:19 AM
#220
I feel like Nino was being molested by Emil's father. I kept on repeating that scene.. when she came out that door. :( She was tidying her outfit. |
Oct 17, 2020 2:26 AM
#221
Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 |
Oct 17, 2020 2:30 AM
#222
mavericko said: Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? |
Oct 17, 2020 2:51 AM
#223
I was little surprised that she did not save anyone. I did not expect this But thats good thing. It would be boring if she plays the hero, save everyone and have happy ending like every other anime |
Oct 17, 2020 2:52 AM
#224
alberto662 said: mavericko said: Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? Lmao ^ this exactly. This show is bad. Anyone who says otherwise has 1: not seen the good shit or 2: is ignorant af Yes, Elaina is a unique character BUT the execution of her character is bad writing to say the least. Hell, who even wrote these last 2 episodes? The first episode was amazing but these last 2 are absolute mediocrity. The writer has a good idea and story set up w/ its worldbuilding and all but the execution thereof is nowhere near the same quality. If the author wanted to rightfully portray Elaina as the type of character to distance herself from adversities, he could have done so better. Elaina comes off as too 2-D, the execution of the story itself is just not handled in a way that evokes sense and a flowing, quality experience. Overall it's just jarring. I feel I get what the author is trying to do but by god does it not translate well. |
Oct 17, 2020 2:54 AM
#225
alberto662 said: mavericko said: Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? I still ask myself what she should have done and what "helping her" should look like. Should she abandon that girl anywhere else then? Should she take care of her herself? Should she attack that guy and then is chased down by authorities herself maybe? In reality things don't go that easy. Imagine you are in a host family in a foreign country and you are seeing that their is some kind of violence in the family. Do you play the superhero-card immediately? Even if it's not an european country, but you know some with no welfare system and where you get yourself in huge problems by doing so? |
removed-userOct 17, 2020 2:57 AM
Oct 17, 2020 2:59 AM
#226
snakezenn said: Im not talking about saving the city, just that individual guard. Again you either did not read or did not understand what I was saying about trying to help the guard which in my opinion she is obligated to as her actions caused his specific situation to escalate. I am not expecting world shattering abilities, I am expecting human decency. Again, what was she supposed to do to save that guard, exactly? All you people who keep stating that seem to gloss over the fact that the whole situation was apparently hopeless and there was nothing Elaina could do. It's the whole point of the scene. hazarddex said: i really wish people would stop trying to compare this to kino no tabi. Kino got involved in a ton of the stories. please remember Kino killed a king and destabilized an entire country because said king pissed her off. And that's somehow "heroic" or "good"? I personally prefer a character who understands when you can and cannot get involved over one who does whatever pleases her and still gets called a hero. alberto662 said: oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? I still have to hear from ppl like you any kind of suggestion about what she could do to help that didn't involve just putting out the village chief and leaving the girl to her own means. Or are you trying to say that she should somehow drop her entire journey to abduct the girl and become her makeshift family, somehow? Do you take home every homeless person you find in the streets, too? Or rather, would you call anybody "selfish", "bitch", or "sociopathic" for not doing so? |
ZaratorOct 17, 2020 3:05 AM
Oct 17, 2020 3:06 AM
#227
To understand Elaina's actions in this episode you need to remember the three promises she made to her mother before starting her journey in the first episode. The promises were: 1) To run away when it looks like she's encountering something dangerous. 2) To not think she's a special human - she's just like everyone else and she shouldn't forget that. 3) To surely come home some day and show them (her parents) an energetic smile. In the first situation, when she was listening to the guy who was being eaten by the plants, she looked like she wanted to help but then took a step back after noticing something. She probably realized that he beyond help at that point, and to keep her first promise, she decided to leave instead of staying to do something about the threat of the flower field, which in the end we saw was going to attack the town. In the second part, when the Village chief was scolding Nino for breaking the vase, she obviously wanted to help Nino to the point that she was considering attacking the chief with magic. But probably to keep in line with her second promise, she decided against it and fixed the vase instead to solve the problem and spare Nino a scolding/beating. The village chief noticed that she was about to attack him and promptly let the situation go. We don't know what the slavery laws are like in that world and it may very well be legal to own a slave. She might've thought she was not above the hierarchy and it was not her place. As for why she didn't take Nino away, again, it was not her place and she was probably counting on the boy to take care of Nino. When she remembered the end of the story, she thought about what might've happened to Nino, but decided she didn't want to know because choosing to do something would go against her promises. Do I think she could've done something? Yes. Do I think she's a cold and heartless girl? No. She obviously wanted to help in both situations, but she makes her choices based on keeping the promises she made to her mother, and that would allow her to continue her journey. Then comes the question of, will she be able to keep her last promise of someday going home and giving her parents that brilliant smile at her journey's end after experiencing everything she has? Well, that's what the rest of the series is for. (I'm anime only for now.) |
Oct 17, 2020 3:12 AM
#228
This little [REDACTED] has the nerve to not feel obligated when she is the one who literally suggested for the Master's Son to open the bottle of happiness in front of the slave, and then realized later that she made a crucial mistake after remembering the other happiness story. And from the light novel she saw that the slave looked even sadder then from before and it showed in the anime as well. She then takes off brushing off the situation as something to sad to go back to when she literally intervened and pushed the mess even further. |
Oct 17, 2020 3:14 AM
#229
_Maneki-Neko_ said: alberto662 said: mavericko said: Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? I still ask myself what she should have done and what "helping her" should look like. Should she abandon that girl anywhere else then? Should she take care of her herself? Should she attack that guy and then is chased down by authorities herself maybe? In reality things don't go that easy. Imagine you are in a host family in a foreign country and you are seeing that their is some kind of violence in the family. Do you play the superhero-card immediately? Even if it's not an european country, but you know some with no welfare system and where you get yourself in huge problems by doing so? if i was a fucking powerfull witch that could take her and run in less than 5 sec |
Oct 17, 2020 3:22 AM
#230
The friction people are having here is *not* that elaina is pathologically unable to feel empathy. It's that the show frames this as not really a big deal, confusing viewers who actually know that slavery is maybe kinda bad. No one complains when Hellsing's alucard does something horrible because the show acknowledges that it's horrible and frames it accordingly. No one complains that Jormungand's koko sells weapons to child soldiers and war criminals because the show very clearly acknowledges that this is monstrous. Tons of great stories about utter bastards exist. But here, the choice of shots make it very clear that elaina knows nino is being sexually abused. The scene with the wand also makes it completely clear that elaina has the power to take complete control over the situation if she wanted to. This makes her "none of my business" reaction quite jarring. This is fine as a storytelling device, and it definitely packs a punch. It's okay as a story if elaina is a bastard. But the way this scenario is framed... it's as if the show doesn't realize the magnitude of the cruelty elaina is exhibiting. It's framed as if she's ignoring a much smaller crime, and THAT is sloppy writing. |
Oct 17, 2020 3:22 AM
#231
HulkAgiota said: WTF, i thought this anime was something to relax with, but after this im going to drop that shit. I hope this MC get killed in the future I laughed my ass off when I read this. Good one, friendo. Also, this person said it best, twice: juuzousuzuya002 said: I'll say it again: Elaina is indeed a fcking WITCH. Elaina is a smug narcissistic bastard, so what? She didn't want to deal with a headache after trying to solve the zombie flower issue (by burning the flowers or whatever...), so what? She didn't kill the ugly bastard for how he treats Nino, again... SO WHAT |
Oct 17, 2020 3:27 AM
#232
_MushiRock11_ said: Elaina being full of herself in the previous two episodes was kind of entertaining but I don't know if I feel the same anymore. I understand that she doesn't want to take part in all these conflicts and I respect that but lending a little hand at times can't be too bad, no? I think Elaina's attitude towards helping others would be along the lines of if you want my help first you have to be willing to help yourself. There's 3 things she chooses not to help with in this episode. First, the general problem of the plant monster endangering the city. If the city, represented here by the older guard requested her assistance as a witch (for appropriate compensation) I'm sure she would have been willing to help. But they make no request, and also are making no efforts, as far as we can see, to solve the problem themselves, so she doesn't get involved. Second, the younger guard entrapped by the plant at the end. She speaks to him for a bit, seemingly considering helping him. But he appears to be happy with his fate & isn't looking to escape and so she again doesn't intervene. If he'd been trying to escape, she almost certainly would have helped. And lastly there's Nino. If she'd asked for help escaping the village chief, Elaina would almost certainly have obliged. But she doesn't, make any such request, she has seemingly resigned herself to her fate. This is thematically tied up by the story at the end of the episode with its line "Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right". Yes, Elaina could have intervened in each case but is it really up to her to decide what other people want for them if they don't ask for her help themselves? Personally, I find her a very relatable character as I expect I'd have reacted similarly in all these situations. I'm not particularly inclined to get myself involved in difficult situations, and especially not if my help isn't being requested in the first place. Of course the slavery one is difficult to place a modern Earth attitude towards because of course if I discovered somebody forcing a young girl to work as their slave I'd report them to the police, but it is implied that slavery is perfectly legal in this world, or at least the country as the village chief has no hesitation in saying that he has a slave.So, helping out in this case, would actually make Elaina to be legally in the wrong, even if you deem it to be morally correct. If the person involved isn't even asking to be helped in that situation, how many people would really still get themselves involved and bring trouble upon themselves. I'll be honest and admit that I doubt I would. I'll bet that a large number of the people in this thread complaining about Elaina wouldn't either, whether they admit it or not. Of course some people would still jump in and try to fight against what they see as injustice, regardless of the cost to themselves. But we have hundreds of anime about these people, it's quite nice, I believe, to get one about somebody who behaves more like the majority of real people are likely to. |
Oct 17, 2020 3:27 AM
#233
alberto662 said: _Maneki-Neko_ said: alberto662 said: mavericko said: Yall consume to much countless MC isekai trying to save the world, And when a new thing comes like this, dropped. Lol wtf. How many isekai do you want to consume? This is such a breath of fresh air. I gave this 7/10 for the first 2 episode. But after this episode 3 seeing the new approve of the MC, Jumped to 9/10 oh yes, thinking that not helping someone that it is being kept captive, raped and it it going to kill herself is wanting a "isekai MC trying to save the world"? I still ask myself what she should have done and what "helping her" should look like. Should she abandon that girl anywhere else then? Should she take care of her herself? Should she attack that guy and then is chased down by authorities herself maybe? In reality things don't go that easy. Imagine you are in a host family in a foreign country and you are seeing that their is some kind of violence in the family. Do you play the superhero-card immediately? Even if it's not an european country, but you know some with no welfare system and where you get yourself in huge problems by doing so? if i was a fucking powerfull witch that could take her and run in less than 5 sec And then? She's chased by authorities maybe or other stuff like that. You guys always make it sound like so simple, but she's a far more realistic mc and not someone like Deku with helper syndrome. I mean the series actually shows he got a helper syndrome, but most people know what they can or can't do within their given possibilities and resources and she didn't want to bring herself in troubles in first place. You can easily say "I would do this and that!", when you are sitting on your couch and wallow in wishfulfillment fantasies, where people imagine themselves as much more moral etc than they are in real life. And that's okay, if you aren't. I don't go around and save everyone I come around either. Otherwise I must donate my whole money every month to all kind of organizations and take in 20 kids and 20 shelter animals, but I don't. I got two cats from a shelter and that's really enough for me to handle. And actually there is still a lot of slavery today. Everytime you buy clothes or chocolate etc you actually enforce slavery in the modern world, but you won't stay away from everything like that either and live like a monk. |
removed-userOct 17, 2020 3:32 AM
Oct 17, 2020 3:48 AM
#234
Mountebank6 said: The friction people are having here is *not* that elaina is pathologically unable to feel empathy. It's that the show frames this as not really a big deal, confusing viewers who actually know that slavery is maybe kinda bad. No one complains when Hellsing's alucard does something horrible because the show acknowledges that it's horrible and frames it accordingly. No one complains that Jormungand's koko sells weapons to child soldiers and war criminals because the show very clearly acknowledges that this is monstrous. Tons of great stories about utter bastards exist. But here, the choice of shots make it very clear that elaina knows nino is being sexually abused. The scene with the wand also makes it completely clear that elaina has the power to take complete control over the situation if she wanted to. This makes her "none of my business" reaction quite jarring. This is fine as a storytelling device, and it definitely packs a punch. It's okay as a story if elaina is a bastard. But the way this scenario is framed... it's as if the show doesn't realize the magnitude of the cruelty elaina is exhibiting. It's framed as if she's ignoring a much smaller crime, and THAT is sloppy writing. holy shit, you find the right words for what i wanted to say, i 100% agree with everything you say, it seems like the show thinks that her not helping a sexual slave was the right choice |
Oct 17, 2020 3:56 AM
#235
God, I love this show so far and I definitely have to check the light novels. A main character who doesn't get a justice boner and realizes that she can't change the system while also being a spoiled brat is really refreshing compared to so many boring and bland protagonists. Yeah, Elaina is not good, neither is she evil or completely neutral. I like it. At first I thought she was the main reason the bad things in these episodes happened, but after thinking about it she couldn't have changed anything and without her appearance nothing would've changed either. The sister was already dead and the guard brother was all over her. He would've looked for her sooner or later or someone else would've gone to the flower field at some point, + the brother already decided to be with his sister no matter what. He was ready to die for her and would've done it one way or another. Other guards would've looked for him, checking the flower field too maybe. The muss would happen anyway. Nino couldn't be saved. Yeah, it was sad. Someone wrote that in the novel Elaina looked into Nino's eyes and saw that she's already dead. That's really interesting and Elaina should've mentioned that in the end after she flew away to make her decision more understandable. The son was a complete idiot who loved his abusive idiot-father. There was no way for Nino to be happy, and after seeing the happiness other people could have - which would've happened anyway - she would've killed herself sooner or later, even if Elaina didn't appear. Other people here also mentioned the fact that slavery seems to be a thing in this world: Why would she save one slave and not all of them? Nino isn't the only person who is threatened like shit and driven to suicide. The show would change completely to a slave riot caused by Elaina's rebelling against the system, that isn't what this show is lol It's more obvious with the guard who doesn't want to part from his dead sister, but it can also be seen with Nino: These people are already dead and they are not willing to fight against their fate anymore. Elaina can't change that. I also read the manga just now, I think everything was a bit better executed there. Elaina actually showed remorse. She sneaked to the oven and get the scarf from the dead sister but found the guard instead, she had that "What the hell have I done, this is my fault" look on her face. She was also willing to attack the guard at first. She wanted to at least give the scarf back to this guy. And what is most important: Elaina said she wanted to go to the flower garden tomorrow to convince the girl to leave the flowers and come back. She says that there might be a way to remove that magic poison and that she would "repay her debt" by trying to help. The guard was also madly in love and obsessed with his sister, no way he could get any help. He locked his sister up, people spread rumors about them having an inincestuous relationship. The sister was the cause of the flowers becoming evil or something like that |
YuiAzu_Is_Can1Oct 17, 2020 4:15 AM
Oct 17, 2020 4:14 AM
#236
Man this episode gave me a different perspective on the anime and how Elaina is actually a pretty unique character. She isn't ur generic isekai fantasy MC. She isn't a perfect, kind-hearted character and is narcissistic. If u have not paid enough attention, u wouldn't realize that her actions were actually smart in this episode, let me explain: 1) She didn't feel any guilt that the orange hair dude she handed flower at died. Woah, she's aaaaaaa u might say, but no In her POV, It'll be pointless to cry or to feel guilt for something that u indirectly caused without knowing that u have caused it to happen. There really is no point dude. Would u rather mourn and keep that guilt within u which could affect ur mental state and ur journey all in all(which is the main point of her travelling, and not be some hero or some shit) or would u just blink an eye, write it all down ur diary and call it a day? 2) Yes she knew that the old fker was one of the *creepy anime old man as we know it* and yet she didn't decide to take an action? Why u may ask? As we already know, the old fker is the mayor of the village and what do u think would happen if she decides to kill(maybe too much yea) or do something severe to him without a legitimate reason to do so? Wouldn't she be the one in trouble here? What if the mayor was actually good in keeping order within the village despite him being dogshit. Wouldn't that directly affect the village all in all? 3) She remembers how the story in the book she have read ended and sees it mirroring to what Nino might do to herself. There was really no turning back at this point tbh, If nino wanted to suicide, what could she possibly have done to help. Even if she tried to inform the guy that likes Nino (forgot the name) or tried to cheer Nino up or smth, it really is something where there isn't a point of return. Nino have seen so many happy memories she could possibly never have and do u think a simple cheer up or some shit could make her change her mind not to suicide? Just upped my score just a by a bit from 8/10 to 9/10 |
laaalaOct 17, 2020 4:18 AM
Oct 17, 2020 4:17 AM
#237
Moral of the episode and the message it wanted to deliver: > Meddling forced kindness is not always good and sometimes hurts the recipient Some people in this discussion: > "Oh no, Elaina didn't do a thing to evil shit in front of her! She's not the ideal hero of justice we expected her to be (and forced our imagination upon) therefore she's a bitch!" What a way to miss the whole point, it's even hilarious. You know the author has created a good story with gray moral zone if people with such moral high ground who usually self-insert into the story and can't differentiate between reality and fiction are butthurt. Such people can drop this show all they want and can stick up to their shounen protagonists while fapping to justice for all I care. I enjoyed this episode a lot along with its dark tonal shift, not to mention I got the message it wanted to deliver. 5/5 episode. Sometimes, you can't help but just love different opinions, right? This post's also aimed at that negative blog-like thread that was locked by mods. |
Oct 17, 2020 4:28 AM
#238
Good or bad, the debate over Elaina's moral attitude has managed to trigger the second longest episode discussion thread of this season so far (after Tonikaku Kawaii ep 1). If they wanted to create controversy, they certainly succeeded. For what it's worth, I liked it, and I'm looking forward to seeing how this evolves. |
Oct 17, 2020 5:15 AM
#239
Anyway, I like the change of perspective in this episode, from happy moments to dark moments. To be honest, I was kind of expecting dark stuff to be shown in this anime sooner or later considering I got some dark vibes from the PV. This episode also goes to show that Elaina is human after all and not an unrealistic perfect character. Mod Edit: Removed Off-topic talk. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 1:16 PM
Oct 17, 2020 6:17 AM
#240
Still can't believe that Elaina basically ruined the whole town.Man and i thought that this anime was about happy lovey adventuring girl's journey. |
Oct 17, 2020 6:28 AM
#241
The_Wicker_Man said: I think Elaina's attitude towards helping others would be along the lines of if you want my help first you have to be willing to help yourself. There's 3 things she chooses not to help with in this episode. First, the general problem of the plant monster endangering the city. If the city, represented here by the older guard requested her assistance as a witch (for appropriate compensation) I'm sure she would have been willing to help. But they make no request, and also are making no efforts, as far as we can see, to solve the problem themselves, so she doesn't get involved. Second, the younger guard entrapped by the plant at the end. She speaks to him for a bit, seemingly considering helping him. But he appears to be happy with his fate & isn't looking to escape and so she again doesn't intervene. If he'd been trying to escape, she almost certainly would have helped. And lastly there's Nino. If she'd asked for help escaping the village chief, Elaina would almost certainly have obliged. But she doesn't, make any such request, she has seemingly resigned herself to her fate. This is thematically tied up by the story at the end of the episode with its line "Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right". Yes, Elaina could have intervened in each case but is it really up to her to decide what other people want for them if they don't ask for her help themselves? Personally, I find her a very relatable character as I expect I'd have reacted similarly in all these situations. I'm not particularly inclined to get myself involved in difficult situations, and especially not if my help isn't being requested in the first place. Of course the slavery one is difficult to place a modern Earth attitude towards because of course if I discovered somebody forcing a young girl to work as their slave I'd report them to the police, but it is implied that slavery is perfectly legal in this world, or at least the country as the village chief has no hesitation in saying that he has a slave.So, helping out in this case, would actually make Elaina to be legally in the wrong, even if you deem it to be morally correct. If the person involved isn't even asking to be helped in that situation, how many people would really still get themselves involved and bring trouble upon themselves. I'll be honest and admit that I doubt I would. I'll bet that a large number of the people in this thread complaining about Elaina wouldn't either, whether they admit it or not. Of course some people would still jump in and try to fight against what they see as injustice, regardless of the cost to themselves. But we have hundreds of anime about these people, it's quite nice, I believe, to get one about somebody who behaves more like the majority of real people are likely to. I get your point about not doing anything in her shoes too, because I'm most likely to do that as well. I totally understand her reasonings and I respect it but a part of me just can't stomach it, that's all. Maybe that'll change with a few more dark episodes but for the time being, it was a fair episode at best for me. |
#Anime4Life be my Life Motto! #PrayForKyoAni |
Oct 17, 2020 6:55 AM
#242
Mountebank6 said: But here, the choice of shots make it very clear that elaina knows nino is being sexually abused. The scene with the wand also makes it completely clear that elaina has the power to take complete control over the situation if she wanted to. This makes her "none of my business" reaction quite jarring. This is fine as a storytelling device, and it definitely packs a punch. It's okay as a story if elaina is a bastard. But the way this scenario is framed... it's as if the show doesn't realize the magnitude of the cruelty elaina is exhibiting. It's framed as if she's ignoring a much smaller crime, and THAT is sloppy writing. Are you really telling us that you think it'd have been better, and/or would have made more sense in the story, if Elaina flat-out shot at the village chief? What do you think would that have accomplished? What would've been of the girl and the chief's son, if that guy had died? Seriously, some of you guys really sound ridiculous. You're complaining about Elaina being "cold" or "heartless" and then you're straight-up suggesting murder as an alternative. And yes I'm saying "murder" because any scenario in which the village chief stayed alive and well would not have solved the issue, as the girl would've returned to her slave condition as soon as Elaina left (perhaps even worse, as the chief may have taken it out on her if Elaina tried to scold or threaten him). |
Oct 17, 2020 7:00 AM
#243
Aversa said: Flesh eating plants a naive kid and an old pervert. I guess this is the dark side of their world, since the story so far has been pretty rose coloured it's a clear sign that not everything is as it seems. The question is should she have helped them or not i kind of like the idea that she isn't a overly righteous person since that's something we see way to often in anime. She seems more of a realist tho she is a bit of a narcissist. ehh, I don't think its neither realist nor narcissist. more like don't get too involved with other people or else your travel ends there. that's very much the exact same words she told to the girl in ep2. discarding her own words now will make her a hypocrite. she only interferes when its absolutely necessary and nothing more. for better or worse. Hanfos said: Nilvius said: Hanfos said: but my main problem is that i see no reason why this show was even created The MC is completely useless, sadistic and narcissistic ur right maybe its just a type of anime which doesnt fit me this anime ep was just as dark like real life every day ppl get hurt and other ppl which have the power to help stay around and record it with their phone she doing the same but write it instead in her dairy at the end of the day i watch anime to get taken in another world and not to watch real life in anime style "just because I can doesn't mean I should." not my problem, give me a reason to care, why should I effort and what are my rewards and I can say so much more. because otherwise kindness just for the sake of kindness is just another form of cruelty. not to mention vanity and vexation of the spirit. just like life. Mod Edit: Merged duplicated posts; please use the edit button. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 1:33 PM
>I had no brain when I was 12 >Then everyone must had no brain when they were 12 >I experimented 100 samples and proved that they had no brain when they were 12 >Therefore children cannot consent This is what science has done to humanity. |
Oct 17, 2020 7:11 AM
#244
The grayest episode I have ever watched, but I am satisfied with it. This gives you an idea of what the world is like Just wondering if Elaina will maintain this attitude or not in the future |
Oct 17, 2020 7:18 AM
#245
Seeing all these triggered people over Elaina is very weird. I loved yesterday's episode, and saw nothing wrong with it, but apparently a lot of people hate this anime now... Their loss. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ |
Oct 17, 2020 7:19 AM
#246
DarkYuzuko said: Seeing all these triggered people over Elaina is very weird. I loved yesterday's episode, and saw nothing wrong with it, but apparently a lot of people hate this anime now... Their loss. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ I know right? and no, I'm going full Eleina with regards to these normies. just like it's the slave girl's loss that she didn't asked Eleina's help (or at least tried). Mod Edit: Removed baiting. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 1:39 PM
>I had no brain when I was 12 >Then everyone must had no brain when they were 12 >I experimented 100 samples and proved that they had no brain when they were 12 >Therefore children cannot consent This is what science has done to humanity. |
Oct 17, 2020 7:23 AM
#247
DarkYuzuko said: Seeing all these triggered people over Elaina is very weird. I loved yesterday's episode, and saw nothing wrong with it, but apparently a lot of people hate this anime now... Their loss. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ first of all meany people dont hate the series for elaina being a piece of shit, which she is, i hated this episode because the stories had so little run time that they didnt impact at all, im more disappointed at people who think that she was somehow right in not even trying to help a child kept captive and sexually abused |
Oct 17, 2020 7:33 AM
#248
Elaina didn't do anything out of character or wrong: - In 1st part, she promised her mother she will run away if she encounters any danger - As for 2nd part, like Kino in Kino's Jouney, Elaina is more of observer and commentator, even if she did save Nino...then what? What would she do with her? Like she said, even good intentions produce bad results. |
Oct 17, 2020 7:36 AM
#249
alberto662 said: first of all meany people dont hate the series for elaina being a piece of shit, which she is, i hated this episode because the stories had so little run time that they didnt impact at all, im more disappointed at people who think that she was somehow right in not even trying to help a child kept captive and sexually abused I don't think she's a bad person. I said this yesterday, but, if any normal person was put in her place, I don't think they would have done anything different from what she did! I really like how she's neither good, nor evil. She feels more human (even though she's a witch, lol). The episodes were sad, but I'm honestly looking forward to this adventure with Elaina, and I hope more people get to enjoy the anime and I hope they get interested in reading the novel afterwards! I do respect your opinion though, and I hope you find better anime that suit your interests! kamil88 said: Elaina didn't do anything out of character or wrong: - In 1st part, she promised her mother she will run away if she encounters any danger - As for 2nd part, like Kino in Kino's Jouney, Elaina is more of observer and commentator, even if she did save Nino...then what? What would she do with her? Like she said, even good intentions produce bad results. Exactly! That's what I thought this show was about! I was not expecting a hero or a villain, but a witch on an adventure to observe things and write a journal of her journey! Mod Edit: Merged duplicated posts; please use the edit button. |
Koito91Oct 17, 2020 1:43 PM
Oct 17, 2020 7:39 AM
#250
DarkYuzuko said: kamil88 said: Elaina didn't do anything out of character or wrong: - In 1st part, she promised her mother she will run away if she encounters any danger - As for 2nd part, like Kino in Kino's Jouney, Elaina is more of observer and commentator, even if she did save Nino...then what? What would she do with her? Like she said, even good intentions produce bad results. Exactly! That's what I thought this show was about! I was not expecting a hero or a villain, but a witch on an adventure to observe things and write a journal of her journey! yes and fuck them kids, fuck that kid drowning i came to this beach to read my book in peace,kid being bullied? fuck him, i came to the school to learn not to help people to not getting beaten down. Person getting kiddnapped in a college party, fuck off i came here to drink not to be a hero and save people |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Majo no Tabitabi Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Oct 23, 2020 |
357 |
by Selltar
»»
10 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Majo no Tabitabi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Dec 18, 2020 |
248 |
by Fabienne
»»
Nov 25, 2:44 AM |
|
Poll: » Majo no Tabitabi Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Nov 27, 2020 |
407 |
by Fabienne
»»
Nov 23, 8:29 AM |
|
Poll: » Majo no Tabitabi Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Nov 6, 2020 |
178 |
by Fabienne
»»
Nov 21, 2:22 AM |
|
» about why elaina doesnt help peopleasalkur - Dec 25, 2023 |
36 |
by AokiHan
»»
Nov 19, 6:38 AM |