| It's a very well-rounded show with unique topics, a nice artstyle, funny characters (albeit slightly cliche), realistic progression and even some slightly more mature tones and topics. I don't see how it's worthy of an abysmal 6.77 rating when shows like ID:Invaded, "super long light novel title about a girl in a vrmmo who uses a shield", Darwin's Game, etc are also airing this season and they're much more generic than this, yet they have higher ratings. It doesn't really make any sense. edit: after episode 10 I agree with the 6.77 rating, this show sucks, my girl admitted her feelings and the story made it amount to nothing |
coreynjMar 24, 2020 12:48 AM
  |
| Nothing new. Most slice of life series are low rated, because main user base (especially these days) = are normies that are searching for action and edginess. Honestly, I wonder how series like Non Non Biyori managed to get so high rating (of course, NNB is phenomenal, but still, it's a mystery for me). Ratings mean nothing. |
HidenNinpoMar 6, 2020 12:03 PM
| I mean, I haven't even watched this show and I can tell its better than Darwin's Game... If anything its because its (from what I can tell) a cute girls doing cute things anime, and even if its a good show people decide its bad, trashy or lazy before they've even given it a chance. |
| If you got nothing with cute stuff and astronomy/geology, not even hate it but just not interested in it.. then maybe this show could be bad and boring for you. |
024Mar 8, 2020 6:25 AM
 |
Seijatachiiii said: Well it's starting to have hints of actual romantic progression, so maybe the score will boost soon.I mean, I haven't even watched this show and I can tell its better than Darwin's Game... If anything its because its (from what I can tell) a cute girls doing cute things anime, and even if its a good show people decide its bad, trashy or lazy before they've even given it a chance. |
|
| Because purely moe anime about cute girls doing cute things is pretty niche,plus the astrology element which isn't a premise that sounds too thrilling.They're not exactly my thing so i understand why people mostly don't feel too strongly about these type of shows if they don't have anything else extra memorable going on for them.At least with shows like ID invaded and Darwin's game even if they're terrible you're bound to still get more entertainment value out of that compared to a middle of the road,by the numbers moe anime. |
SummerynMar 6, 2020 12:56 PM
 |
| I'm starting to agree with the scoring now, this ep 9 was WAY TOO RUSHED. I would've kept the score at a 7 but now I can't, but before ep 9 I would have agreed that the show is underrated. |
| I almost eat up anything Doga Kobo animates but this one is just plain boring to be brutally honest. The pacing is all over the place and the scenes that are supposed to be funny are not funny. I might bump up the score to a 7 depending on the ending but for now it's a strong 6 for me. While Bofuri is indeed generic, it made me drop off my chair several times, it's just stupid and it works. Darwin's Game is a pretty long running series at this point so I can see why the anime is scored so high despite it being a botch job at certain parts, but I gotta admit the action was nailed nicely so far. ID:Invaded is where I totally don't agree, it's the hidden gem of this season. |
| Because is generic and boring, just that, |
| I like to post in manga forum when I feel it is worth it, so people will think. "Shit, is her again" or something. People asked me where I read certain thing but the rules say no telling where did you read so maybe I am too boring for not saying? Or salty because you didn't check my profile that says don't ask because I hate people to ghost me after that. I love learning languages so maybe I did not read the manga in English. |
| Well, idk why you're comparing it with edgy and serious stuff (Darwin's Game and ID: Invaded) and the score of Bofuri is higher simply because it's much more popular than this... Also CGDCT fans rarely care about scores and as far as I know they (and also me) enjoying it. This show reminds me of Yama no Susume which was another good adventure-ish SoL |
| Nothing happened. And it was really boring. I do watch cdcgct a lot, but this one was one of the least shows i like. The yuribait was weak and the topic isn't all that interesting. Perhaps, because i'm not into stars and rocks that i found this anime boring. The comedies are flat too... so i kinda thought that this show was a meh for me. Also, i don't think 4 koma manga adaptations are good. If anything they're bad to mediocre at best. |
  Wandering Witch is the best light novel ever! |
| The cute girls aren't as cute as others. The cute things they do isn't nearly as much depth or as colorful as it should be. And the colors are overall bland? I seriously have a hard time actually caring about any of the characters. That is a bad thing. Seriously, this is an Astronomy and Earth Science anime, MAKE ME CARE ABOUT THOSE SUBJECTS! When showing the view through the telescope, SHOW THE DAMN PLANETS. Nichijou did more with the visuals for it than this anime has. Hell YOUTUBE VIDEOS do a better job. And I am someone who cares a shit ton about the subjects. For someone who DNGAF about space discovery or earth science then it would be even more boring for them. Episode 9 was also annoying AF for me. When you check out of caring about their issues it is hard to feel anything else but annoyance about them when they have issues. 4 KOMA can work, see Azumanga Daioh, Lucky Star, and K-on This one just did it badly |
 |
| I mean, it's the "cute girls doing cute things" type of show, and everybody knows that this kind of shows are always rated low on mal. That's why ratings mean nothing. Personally i'm enjoying it a lot, even tho there are some pace problems, especially in episode 9, which is too rushed imo. Oh and ID:Invaded is probably the best of this season, while Darwins is plain stupid and Bofuri is generic af. |
 |
| It isn’t outstanding compare to other shows of the same genre. For a 4-koma CGDCT series, it is actually pretty lackluster. Not even the astronomy part is that good... Sora no Manimani is a much a better series about an astronomy club than this, and a better series overall. At the end of the day, I’ve seen way better CGDCT shows than this... It doesn't help that nowadays we have an over-saturation problem with these type series. So you gotta be more than mediocre-average to stand out from the rest. |
 We ultimately fear what spawns from within us ~Shinsekai yori Music is freedom. ~Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso |
Joshiki said: I mean, it's the "cute girls doing cute things" type of show, and everybody knows that this kind of shows are always rated low on mal. Not always, just normally. (Exceptions prove the rule.) It's still possible for studios other than KyoAni to put out hit CGDCT. https://myanimelist.net/anime/34798/Yuru_Camp%E2%96%B3 https://myanimelist.net/anime/36990/Non_Non_Biyori_Movie__Vacation Smaller but still well-received: https://myanimelist.net/anime/35241/Konohana_Kitan https://myanimelist.net/anime/37614/Hitoribocchi_no_Marumaru_Seikatsu https://myanimelist.net/anime/39071/Machikado_Mazoku (I'm not counting drama-focused hits like Yorimoi) |
nDroae said: Don't forget about the highest rated one on MALJoshiki said: I mean, it's the "cute girls doing cute things" type of show, and everybody knows that this kind of shows are always rated low on mal. Not always, just normally. (Exceptions prove the rule.) It's still possible for studios other than KyoAni to put out hit CGDCT. https://myanimelist.net/anime/34798/Yuru_Camp%E2%96%B3 https://myanimelist.net/anime/36990/Non_Non_Biyori_Movie__Vacation Smaller but still well-received: https://myanimelist.net/anime/35241/Konohana_Kitan https://myanimelist.net/anime/37614/Hitoribocchi_no_Marumaru_Seikatsu https://myanimelist.net/anime/39071/Machikado_Mazoku (I'm not counting drama-focused hits like Yorimoi) https://myanimelist.net/anime/10165/Nichijou |
|
| I enjoy it to an extent, but it is a pretty basic genre piece in an arguably overdone genre. It doesn't make its main subjects of astronomy and earth sciences very appealing, and that all takes up a lot of runtime. Bofuri certainly stands out in its genre more than this. |
| First of all, it is generic CGDCT. Literally nothing hew. Second of all, synopsis has false advertisement. It makes you think it will be some sort of romance story between boy and a girl, but it turn out the boy was reverse trap and generic CGDCT ensues. Also it makes you think that the twist in this CGDCT will be mainly astronomy but it turn out girls have rock fetish, which takes majority of the screen time. And the third, the cast is a travesty. Characters (except maybe two main girls) are one dimensional, irrelevant and were not introduced in any proper way, but still take major bit of screen time. People are like "who the hell are you and why should I care about you?". |
PiromyslMar 8, 2020 8:44 AM
 |
coreynj said: nDroae said: Don't forget about the highest rated one on MALNot always, just normally. (Exceptions prove the rule.) It's still possible for studios other than KyoAni to put out hit CGDCT. https://myanimelist.net/anime/34798/Yuru_Camp%E2%96%B3 https://myanimelist.net/anime/36990/Non_Non_Biyori_Movie__Vacation Smaller but still well-received: https://myanimelist.net/anime/35241/Konohana_Kitan https://myanimelist.net/anime/37614/Hitoribocchi_no_Marumaru_Seikatsu https://myanimelist.net/anime/39071/Machikado_Mazoku (I'm not counting drama-focused hits like Yorimoi) https://myanimelist.net/anime/10165/Nichijou I never saw nichijou as a typical cgdct show tbh.I see it as more of it's own thing,much more comedy oriented than anything that appeals on moe. |
|
Maneki-Mew said: It's nothing special, but I kinda enjoy it for inbetween. The real question is, why is Yuru Camp for example rated so damn high? I don't think it was so different from the others. Yeah, in terms of content, this anime has much more things happening than Yuru Camp. So the "generic cgdct" argument doesn't really explain the score difference. |
| Truth is absolute but human perception of truth is always relative. |
kyouon said: Maneki-Mew said: It's nothing special, but I kinda enjoy it for inbetween. The real question is, why is Yuru Camp for example rated so damn high? I don't think it was so different from the others. Yeah, in terms of content, this anime has much more things happening than Yuru Camp. So the "generic cgdct" argument doesn't really explain the score difference. Yuru Camp had amazing visuals, funny, bubbly characters with actual personality and the show was entirely about it's subject (camping), so people who are interested in this subject would especially have a blast watching it. Here astronomy/geology is just barely relevant twist, which barely keeps it above shows such as Slow Start, which had no such twist and were literally just a show without any plot and were completely forgettable and generic CGDCT which fell into an abyss of irrelevancy after it finished airing. |
|
Piromysl said: kyouon said: Yeah, in terms of content, this anime has much more things happening than Yuru Camp. So the "generic cgdct" argument doesn't really explain the score difference. Yuru Camp had amazing visuals, funny, bubbly characters with actual personality and the show was entirely about it's subject (camping), so people who are interested in this subject would especially have a blast watching it. Here astronomy/geology is just barely relevant twist, which barely keeps it above shows such as Slow Start, which had no such twist and were literally just a show without any plot and were completely forgettable and generic CGDCT which fell into an abyss of irrelevancy after it finished airing. Spot on man. I am not really into camping and even I had an amazing blast watching Yuru Camp. (hyped for S2) I remember Slow Start..it had a few good parts but that's about it, otherwise it's super forgettable. It was still better than Koisuru Asteroid though.. Also, you can't just name a series Koisuru Asteroid and have more than half of it not deal with the actual subject lol. |
coreynj said: nDroae said: Don't forget about the highest rated one on MALNot always, just normally. (Exceptions prove the rule.) It's still possible for studios other than KyoAni to put out hit CGDCT. https://myanimelist.net/anime/10165/Nichijou Weeeeeeeeeeeeeell first off, I do agree with Missaliensan. I didn't mention the hit show Asobi Asobase (currently rated 8.21) because its focus is likewise on comedy, often at the expense of cuteness. Same deal with Joshikousei no Mudazukai (7.75) though I think it's more CGDCT than Asobi Asobase was. Also: 1) Nichijou is from nine years ago, and I think it qualifies as a classic. I said "it's still possible" meaning I wanted to limit my examples to recent releases, not favorably remembered classics like Azumanga Daioh (another which might be considered more comedy than CGDCT, though to less of an extreme), K-On, and Lucky Star. 2) Like those last two, Nichijou is a KyoAni show. I mentioned KyoAni above because feel like it's cheating to say "People will rate X genre high" and point to a show of X genre made by KyoAni. 3) This is rated higher https://myanimelist.net/anime/3297/Aria_The_Origination though Aria's CGDCT credentials are also sometimes questioned. Maneki-Mew said: The real question is, why is Yuru Camp for example rated so damn high? I don't think it was so different from the others. Haha. I've been watching this show twice every Friday (once alone and once in an online simulwatch), it's not great but I do prefer it over Yuru Camp's boring swaths of silence with text conversations and unfunny texting-based gags. I don't know how little of the show was actually like that, but that was the main negative impression it left. That said, I hated Nichijou and didn't much care for Lucky Star and Aria (only seen Aria's first season), also not a fan of Bocchi and wasn't really into Machikado Mazoku, so... should I even be an admin in the CGDCT club? Maybe not. ;P |
| I'll be honest. The first two episodes was pretty good after that it gotten so stale so quickly. I mean in High School I used to be curious in Earth Science and Space but that's it. If this came out in HIgh School I would love the shit out of this. |
| Although Koisuru Asteroid isn't anything special and does suffer from pacing issues, I agree that the current score of <6.8 is really low, even for a CGDCT show. I guess we'll see how it does once the season ends and the score is recalculated without the early droppers. |
| "Our everyday lives may, in fact, be a series of miracles." - Nichijou |
| Kinda a CGDCT connoisseur here, and just dropped this at episode 8 because I couldn't invest myself into watching this week's episode 9 anymore. I'll copypaste what I wrote in my list's comment section: It's rare for me to drop a CGDCT show at late episodes but this one is quite boring. Girls are so stuck up with senpai-kohai stuff and the show's focusing too much on its main theme, astronomy and geology, which I think most normal people (including me) aren't interested very much. Anyway, this is one of the weakest CGDCT shows I've watched and it felt more and more like a chore to watch this per week so I dropped it without much hate. 6.78 is a pretty fair score if you ask me. But MAL scores rarely make sense because I do agree this is better than Bofuri and ID:Invaded, shows which I dropped earlier at episode 2 and 3 respectively. But Darwin's Game, err... No comment. |
 |
| I think it's a fair score. The show imo isn't that great in terms of slice of life/school setting. I thought it was going to be about all the girls doing club things together but then halfway through the 2 seniors split to study (now graduated) and we hardly see Suzu and when we do she's not on screen for long. |
| Took to episode 11 to actually get going on the main premise. This anime is paced really badly. It is worse for me because I actually know what they are talking about and have been annoyed at how little they actually explore space stuff outside of 2 episodes. |
|
| I think you should checked the source itself lol. I think doga kobo is alreally put some great effort for this mediocre source . BTW Yonkoma anime adapatation is somewhat really hard for being "above average" level expect the source itself are already decent such as azumanga daioh, nozaki, k-on, etc etc Usually the rating willl be increased when this anime ends. Many people including me only gave rating score if a series is completely done. |
 |
| I like cute girls shows and therefore this one too, but honestly as many have said, it's nothing special. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| 6 is a fair score to me, but I'm aware a 6.77 by MAL average score standards means a 4 or something, which is indeed too low. For some reason a lot of people act like 7 is an average score, as if this was a school system or something. |
| Who are you and why do you show your hostility towards a complete stranger whom you've not once spoken with before. Are you seriously asking to get blocked? Well, if that's what your intent is; to tempt me into throwing hands with someone as lowly and insignificant as you, then i may grant your wish provided you articulate yourself a bit better when trying to spite a person of my wavelength. |
| Imma be real with you chief, it's a pretty low tier Doga Kobo series. |
What a beautiful Duwang |
| 6-7 seems pretty fair for it. Case is similar to manga, It was bland... |
| The show is shit. Should be rated 5 at most I'm not big fan of Darwin's game but it is still much more fun to watch than a boring slice of life anime |
Seijatachiiii said: I mean, I haven't even watched this show and I can tell its better than Darwin's Game... If anything its because its (from what I can tell) a cute girls doing cute things anime, and even if its a good show people decide its bad, trashy or lazy before they've even given it a chance. Koisuru Asteroid girls looks average and normal. They also dress normally. It is normal girls doing normal things. Thats one of the reason I don't like it. The blond girl from Darwin's Game looks much better and sexier than any of the girls in Koisuru Asteroid. Also, Koisuru Asteroid has no interesting plot and it just boring slice of life. At least Darwin's Game has some action, edginess, perverted girl etc that keeps you entertained. Not big fan of Darwin's game, but almost anything is better than Koisuru Asteroid |
| Probably because it's kind of shitty. |
  |
| I thought the first four episodes were very boring. There’s not much to say about any of the characters and nothing interesting has happened. |
RebelPandaMar 26, 2020 6:11 PM
 |
Zeroes said: What were you people expecting from this show? Honestly I don't know why I'm even bothering checking forums on MAL, so much negativity, entitled opinions, acting like there are better shows than this therefore this one is trash etc. No one is forcing you to watch it if it feels boring/bland to you, watch something else or do something else. Show like this one is always about whether you are entertained, enjoy/care about the characters or not, there's no complicated plot and heavy drama that if executed poorly could ruin it all. I, for example not care about many popular and highly praised shows in that genre, especially Kyoani shows ( K-on, Lucky star, Nichijou), to me they are boring and forgetable, but a lot of people love them, and that's fine, doesn't mean they're bad. To be honest, i don't think about anime in terms of good/bad at all, from my expereience it's kind of pointless and shallow. But here on MAL people act like every anime is in some wierd rat-race, cheering for their favourities to get on top, with all the scoring dramas and bad mouthing. If you don't care about the quality of an anime at all then why would you check to see what people have to say about it? Was it to perhaps say how you are holier than everyone who has an opinion different from yours? |
|
| For a slice of life CGDCT show it’s actually not that badly rated. MAL users tend to be shonen normies who like things like BNHA, SnK, KNY, etc over these types of shows. For some reason, people who don’t like these shows continue to watch them and give low scores. |
 |
thepath said: The show is shit. Should be rated 5 at most I'm not big fan of Darwin's game but it is still much more fun to watch than a boring slice of life anime Did you just compare a battle royals action anime to a slice of life CGDCT unironically? |
|
| Too much asteroid, needed more of the "in love" part. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Koisuru Asteroid Episode 11 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 20, 2020 |
36 |
by tails2k
»»
Feb 25, 4:28 PM |
|
Poll: » Koisuru Asteroid Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Aversa - Jan 17, 2020 |
64 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Jan 23, 12:46 PM |
|
Poll: » Koisuru Asteroid Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 10, 2020 |
68 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Jan 23, 12:31 PM |
|
Poll: » Koisuru Asteroid Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jan 3, 2020 |
140 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Jan 23, 12:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Koisuru Asteroid Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 27, 2020 |
89 |
by JKam57
»»
Nov 10, 2024 2:26 AM |