Which Version of Opening Theme Do You Like?
| Which Version of Opening Do You Like? -Bootleg- (Miou ver. CV Ayahi Takagaki) -Alternative- (Nino ver. CV Saori Hayami) |
tsubasaloverMay 2, 2017 8:40 PM
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
| Mio's voice is really sweet but Nino's can express by far a lot more emotion. |
Haloween Candy:        |
| Mio's voice, it leaves more impact to me than Saori Hayami's ver. this type of singing just doesn't suit her to be honest |
| I think I like Bootleg more as it is the version I'm more used to, but in truth, I have to agree with this: KuuhakuDesu said: Mio's seiyuu has a stronger and louder voice. You can tell Hayamin's kinda struggling to keep up with the instrumental. It's sad, I like Hayami Saori and her voice but she can't do this very well. Allegro suits her better, I find. I'll go with Bootleg. |
jyuushiMay 2, 2017 8:08 PM
 |
jyuushimatsu said: I agree on this. I still couldn't decide which version I like more, though, because I like ED more than OP to begin with.Allegro suits her better |
tsubasaloverMay 2, 2017 8:47 PM
I ♥ Two Syaorans from Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE and TRC!!! |
tsubasalover said: jyuushimatsu said: I agree on this. I still couldn't decide which version I like more. though, because I like ED more than OP to begin with.Allegro suits her better, I find. Ahh, well I like the OP more, maybe because I've been listening to it way more. (had it on loop some days haha) But both the OP and ED are really good. Can't wait for more songs! |
|
| I have a feeling the Alternate version is going to change down the line as she becomes a better singer. She has passion but no true control. Once that happens it probably won't be a contest. Hopefully they told Saori Hayami to sing that way and improve with the character. But yeah, I like both. |
| As a fan of Ayahi Takagaki and her singing I prefer Miou's version of cause. Although I think tprodussers one more time chosen the wrong style for her. |
 |
BtheBeast said: I have a feeling the Alternate version is going to change down the line as she becomes a better singer. She has passion but no true control. Once that happens it probably won't be a contest. Hopefully they told Saori Hayami to sing that way and improve with the character. But yeah, I like both. Ooh, that seems like a possibility, hopefully you're right about that! |
|
BtheBeast said: I have a feeling the Alternate version is going to change down the line as she becomes a better singer. She has passion but no true control. Once that happens it probably won't be a contest. Hopefully they told Saori Hayami to sing that way and improve with the character. True. I think that the production or whoever made Saori Hayami sing like she's not in control, just as how Nino does as she is struggling to improve her singing. Having read the manga prior to the anime adaptation, I was pretty much moved by the way Saori Hayami sang since I could really feel the vibe and character Nino gave off when she sings in the manga. Reaaallyyy Nino-like. More than I could even imagine, like, woaaaahhh! It made me fangirl sooooo hard!! I do hope also that as Nino develops in terms of singing and in character, they would try to make Saori Hayami sing again in a better manner. The current version (Nino ver.) is just fine the way it is too, though, imo. |
 |
| miou's version too. nino's song doesn't feel right. |
 |
| I agree with the people here who say that Hayami sang like that on purpose, because if you listen to the parts where it sounds like she's short breathed, Hayami clearly could have sang it less choppily if she wanted to. It's just Nino's style, and it sounds much more interesting than Miou's version imo, cause Miou's version is just too perfect while Nino's version just has much more emotion in it. If I were to choose to whose concert to go to, I'd choose Nino. I'll go with bootleg though, because bootleg really is more pleasurable to listen to if you just want to listen to music casually. |
 |
Takeoff31 said: The first time I listen to Miou ver. I don't like it, I think it doesn't fit with rock style the anime is supposed to be like Because she is singing in the very methodical pop style but i'm getting used to it well. But I like Nino ver. instantly because that is what i'm expected. Both version are really good though, I don't get the comment about Nino's VA singing skill LMAO How do you expect she would sound like? singing it in pop style like Miou? I know Nino's VA is really good singer that Akagami no Shirayuki OP single c/w the best ballad from VA I've ever listen too voice wise and skill wise. KuuhakuDesu said: Mio's seiyuu has a stronger and louder voice. You can tell Hayamin's kinda struggling to keep up with the instrumental. Listen to Nino's ver in HD quality, nothing wrong with Nino ver, she is singing like young rock maiden, rough, straight, blunt and not sticking to the sound is the way showing her free will and identity, Miou has nice sound her singing style is methodical, the way it sticks to the sound to fit her voice show her experience. Both version actually sound really similar if you don't pay attention, I won't call Mio has stronger and louder voice but she has higher pitch, meanwhile Nino VA is normally really good in low tone but her rock style actually on the point. So, the only different I see is singing style also i can't imagine Mio's VA singing something like spiral. Hmm, I think your perspective does make sense. |
|
| I honestly prefer Nino's voice, but I feel that this song does not draw the strength that it really does possess. |
| I have played both of their version - full version. I have to say, I prefer Nino's ver. (Hayami's ver). Hayami's version sounds rather choppy and sometimes I feel her voice is struggling as if she lacks technique in her singing, but I like that she sings something that is out of her safe zone; it is not usual for Hayami to sing in a rock style. Her version sounds more expressive as if she's singing with her passion. I would surely go for her concert if there is one, and don't mind listening anytime I want to. well, I have listened to her live concert songs btw Mio's version however isn't really that strong or loud; her version also lacks expression which gives very little impact to me. What I have for her version is a 'meh' impression. I may be biased about it anyway since I like Hayami's singing so much xD |
  |
| Woah, Alternative is in the lead now. Guess it must be from those who don't like the more 'plain' voice or are just biased towards Hayami Saori. |
|
Dokuro-chan_ said: It's seems I'm the only one who think that Nino's voice is horrible. False and bad to listen. I always take the volume off when she sings roars. But this is just my opinion. I personally don't enjoy it either (tbh it often makes me cringe, though I'm guessing that was partly done on purpose). I usually really like Hayami, but I don't think her voice/singing fits this kind of song. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fukumenkei Noise Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 27, 2017 |
93 |
by imkentyholic
»»
Feb 7, 1:03 PM |
|
Poll: » Fukumenkei Noise Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 9, 2017 |
57 |
by ChukyBird
»»
Dec 27, 2023 9:14 PM |
|
Poll: » Who should win Nino's heart?bittersweetlove - Jun 4, 2017 |
39 |
by Jhenjhenmarine
»»
Oct 12, 2023 6:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Fukumenkei Noise Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Apr 11, 2017 |
164 |
by Sarakitteh
»»
May 31, 2023 9:14 PM |
|
Poll: » Fukumenkei Noise Episode 11 DiscussionStark700 - Jun 20, 2017 |
49 |
by Hayley2877
»»
Mar 22, 2023 1:16 PM |