| Is it just me or do haters come here just to put 1/5 and 1/10 and bitch about how they hate this anime 24/7? I mean really, this is just like how a grown-ass adult goes to a cartoon forum section just to say how childish the cartoon is. I am not a fan of ecchi anime, but I see this anime is dong exactly what the target audience asked for so I give it 7/10 as of now. |
 |
| because its cool to watch ecchi with brain, lately, you need to become professor to watch animes, so you can analyze every second of it into essays. |
| 期待しているよ、私のサリアだって、嘘ばっかり! でもねアンジュ、あんたがいなくなれば、私の方が強いってわかれば, それができるなら、何もいらない! |
Mathwizard said: Is it just me or do haters come here just to put 1/5 and 1/10 and bitch about how they hate this anime 24/7? I mean really, this is just like how a grown-ass adult goes to a cartoon forum section just to say how childish the cartoon is. I am not a fan of ecchi anime, but I see this anime is dong exactly what the target audience asked for so I give it 7/10 as of now. Not necessarily. I have nothing against ecchi, I like some certain series a lot. Like Seikon no Qwaser, which is really fan service heavy too. Even some relatively bad ones, like Hyakka Ryouran, which is one of my personal favorites. But this is shit. I can not bring up anything in it's defense. The animation is bad, the character designs are bad, the plot is bad. It's so bad, even the uncensored version can't compensate. Overusing nudity and borderline hentai scenes are not enough to make a good ecchi. |
  |
| I don' t have anything against ecchi, but this anime would be bad even without it... Story is plain, characters seems plain etc... I only like soundtrack and OP+ED, animation was kinda OK... |
 |
Mathwizard said: Is it just me or do haters come here just to put 1/5 and 1/10 and bitch about how they hate this anime 24/7?. This is normal and expected tbh Im Westen nichts Neues |
 |
| Even though Im enjoying the show. The show does have some errr ALOT of stuff to work on. I like the ecchi scene in the show. The MC is alright but the girls are still generic archtypes. It also has template story. The Sound and Animations are meh at best. |
| I don't care for ecchi, personally (I actually hate the harem genre more), but I watch it since it's typically combined with the romance genre, so it's just there and I'm all "Whatever". But I do get tired of seeing the same old thing over and over again every season when it comes to character archetypes and the fanservice gimmicks. It's almost like there's no originality, or it's not being encouraged to freshen up the genre when it comes to playing with their characters or switching up the hijinks. I love the romance genre, yet I get tired of seeing the same things over and over again, so I don't know how harem/ecchi lovers can enjoy the same copy-paste schlock every season without desiring something new. |
  |
| You don't have to hate ecchi in order to dislike *some* ecchi anime. Series such as this tend to be about the worst the genre has to offer. I'd love to see more shows along the lines of To Love Ru, Monster Musume, Prison School, Sora no Otoshimono, Kore wa Zombie Desu ka etcetera, but these kinds of battle harems like Hundred, Asterisk, Absolute Duo, Infinite Stratos and many others are just... not very good... and they're all way too similar to each other. And Masou Gakuen HxH so far at least doesn't seem to be a whole lot different either (granted that's just after one episode but still) |
  |
| Action ecchi series are the absolute bottom of the bin trash, slice-of-life ones are always much better, at least they know what they're doing, just for you to have a nice fap. In action ones they try to build up a complex world with a 'unique' magic system for no purpose when all you're there for is to jack off. |
 |
| It's because they like anime with deep development of characters and stories. which girls with tits everywhere doesn't have. |
 |
| the "why don't they just make it a porno" whingers are worse, because they'll actually watch and complain every week. |
HaXXspetten said: You don't have to hate ecchi in order to dislike *some* ecchi anime. Series such as this tend to be about the worst the genre has to offer. I'd love to see more shows along the lines of To Love Ru, Monster Musume, Prison School, Sora no Otoshimono, Kore wa Zombie Desu ka etcetera, but these kinds of battle harems like Hundred, Asterisk, Absolute Duo, Infinite Stratos and many others are just... not very good... and they're all way too similar to each other. And Masou Gakuen HxH so far at least doesn't seem to be a whole lot different either (granted that's just after one episode but still) I would say this show is more in line with DxD that has actual story progression, conflicts and character development. And like you said, it is just the first episode, and wanting everything being put on a table after first episode is not really a good idea |
| |
cheesewithwhine said: Just like with any other genre, there are good and bad shows in ecchi. It just so happens that this one isn't very good. The difference between ecchi and hentai is that a good ecchi show should have something other than sex to offer its viewers. Masou Gakuen doesn't seem to be offering much in terms of originality, character design, or even general art quality. good ecchi shows like Highschool DxD, Prison school, Saekano each have something to offer beyond nudity. If you don't, you might as well watch hentai. This show is like DxD in a sense that it has something to offer beyond nudity tho. |
| |
Mathwizard said: Well I think DxD kind of sucks too so that wouldn't really say much either imo :sHaXXspetten said: You don't have to hate ecchi in order to dislike *some* ecchi anime. Series such as this tend to be about the worst the genre has to offer. I'd love to see more shows along the lines of To Love Ru, Monster Musume, Prison School, Sora no Otoshimono, Kore wa Zombie Desu ka etcetera, but these kinds of battle harems like Hundred, Asterisk, Absolute Duo, Infinite Stratos and many others are just... not very good... and they're all way too similar to each other. And Masou Gakuen HxH so far at least doesn't seem to be a whole lot different either (granted that's just after one episode but still) I would say this show is more in line with DxD that has actual story progression, conflicts and character development. And like you said, it is just the first episode, and wanting everything being put on a table after first episode is not really a good idea But in any case "wanting everything being put on a table after first episode" is of course rather ignorant, but you have to admit that most ecchi anime are in fact rather predictable and rarely change very much over time. If you don't like the first episode of an ecchi anime, you probably won't like the rest either. If you do like the first episode, then you'll probably be okay with the rest too. Exceptions do occur of course but you get my point |
| |
| um Just wanna ask, is this just another generic harem anime where usually the MC won't end up with anyone, or it's a harem anime but the MC will end up with someone |
HaXXspetten said: Mathwizard said: Well I think DxD kind of sucks too so that wouldn't really say much either imo :sI would say this show is more in line with DxD that has actual story progression, conflicts and character development. And like you said, it is just the first episode, and wanting everything being put on a table after first episode is not really a good idea But in any case "wanting everything being put on a table after first episode" is of course rather ignorant, but you have to admit that most ecchi anime are in fact rather predictable and rarely change very much over time. If you don't like the first episode of an ecchi anime, you probably won't like the rest either. If you do like the first episode, then you'll probably be okay with the rest too. Exceptions do occur of course but you get my point Having read the 1st vol, I wouldnt call MG HxH predictable tho I will give you that. |
| |
| just be thankful that japanese animators and watchers don't give a fuck abou Myanimelist. since we live in a climate of SJW's which have not infected japan. |
| I honestly don't know either what they expect, but thanks to them I know that I shouldn't give a crap about MAL ratings when it comes to ecchi shows. |
| I feel like the ecchi genre is always bashed just for the tag alone so the hate is to be expected every time there is an ecchi show to be announced. That being said though, there are good ecchi shows and bad ecchi shows. I can't judge whether or not this is good or bad because I have never read the source material to this series and there is only one episode to go off of. Yes the concepts are generic as well as the setup of the typical ecchi elements but who knows, it may be something worth investing in. In terms of similar shows, I guess we are dealing with an action type ecchi like Hundred was except...just gonna say it...Hundred was awful all around. If anything, this series is more like Shinmai Maou no Testament given the fact that the MC pretty much has to do some ecchi things in order for the female characters to do something. So basically it feels like this is going to be borderline hentai but actually entertaining...at least for my ecchi standards. Now, I am hoping that this series balances out ecchi and story and not try to do one well and completely botch the other. DxD does a good job of balancing out the story and the ecchi where as Shinmai has good ecchi with a horribly written story. But all we can do is just watch to see where it goes. And hey, at least we don't have to wait for the uncensored cuts of this. |
| Don't believe the hype. |
Mathwizard said: HaXXspetten said: Well I think DxD kind of sucks too so that wouldn't really say much either imo :s But in any case "wanting everything being put on a table after first episode" is of course rather ignorant, but you have to admit that most ecchi anime are in fact rather predictable and rarely change very much over time. If you don't like the first episode of an ecchi anime, you probably won't like the rest either. If you do like the first episode, then you'll probably be okay with the rest too. Exceptions do occur of course but you get my point Having read the 1st vol, I wouldnt call MG HxH predictable tho I will give you that. I don't know. I also read(loose sense of the word but I did)but he didn't give me any vibes of being cool, neither did the story in volume 1 gave me much to look forward to other than fanservice. At least Sister Testament and DXD had decent animation to look at, which for at the moment(only 1 episode at the moment)is a lot more than what I can say about this show. No matter how much fanservice you throw at me, if the show is bad, no amount of fanservice can save it. |
| I play video games. You should play a video game because you read my signature. |
| I don't hate ecchi anime but most of them are trash, exactly like this show, ecchi anime have to offer something new, I mean, if I'm here to see boobs then hentai would be a better choice, High School of the dead is one of the best ecchi anime I've ever watched, it was exciting and interesting with a decent plot. |
 |
Gator said: I honestly don't know either what they expect, but thanks to them I know that I shouldn't give a crap about MAL ratings when it comes to ecchi shows. THE TRUTH HAS BEEN SPOKEN MY FRIENDS |
 |
| Just because its giving the target audience what they want doesn't mean its any less shitty. Ecchi anime with nothing going for it except PLOT is just bad, should just watch hentai then. |
| they are the reason i exist in Anime Discussion lol.... ain't letting these motherfuckers have their way ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) |
 |
Mamster-P said: they are the reason i exist in Anime Discussion lol.... ain't letting these motherfuckers have their way ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) You are the hero we need ;) |
 |
MrHavok said: Mamster-P said: they are the reason i exist in Anime Discussion lol.... ain't letting these motherfuckers have their way ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) You are the hero we need ;) well thank you i will continue to keep being annoying af to those who dare to bash the great ecchi moments of anime |
|
HaXXspetten said: I'd love to see more shows along the lines of To Love Ru, Monster Musume, Prison School, Sora no Otoshimono, Kore wa Zombie Desu ka... I, too, can vouch for these, in case anyone with an ecchi mind is curious if they're worth the watch, although Zombie doesn't sit in my recollection as a strong fanservice series. It was more about the MC's struggle to keep his supporting cast in a "good state", if you will; particularly best girl Eucliwood. The conflicts are heavy and the atmosphere is just... melancholy. HaXXspetten said: ...battle harems like Hundred, Asterisk, Absolute Duo, Infinite Stratos and many others are just... not very good... and they're all way too similar to each other. You omitted a certain competitor of Asterisk and I'm hoping it was intentional (but I forgive you if it wasn't lol): Cavalry was an excellent representation of "battle harem-ish/romance done right". I'd love to see more of that show. |
ChromeEagle said: Well yeah, hence why I didn't mention it. But it's not much of a harem anyway due to the actual single girl romance aspectHaXXspetten said: ...battle harems like Hundred, Asterisk, Absolute Duo, Infinite Stratos and many others are just... not very good... and they're all way too similar to each other. You omitted a certain competitor of Asterisk and I'm hoping it was intentional (but I forgive you if it wasn't lol): Cavalry was an excellent representation of "battle harem-ish/romance done right". I'd love to see more of that show. |
| |
HaXXspetten said: But it's not much of a harem anyway due to the actual single girl romance aspect Shizuku would like to have a word with you.  |
| Get used to it. If you truly enjoy something, you shouldn't let the opinion of others ruin the experience. Been watching these kind of stuff for years and to be honest, everything is subjective. Some ecchi fans might think it's a bad series. On the contrary, I'm having fun watching it, so I'd say it's a good series since it does what its supposed to do: entertain the audience. (Me, in this case.) |
ChromeEagle said: I know, but there's clearly just one established relationship, the other girls are mostly there to cater to different audiences*HaXXspetten said: But it's not much of a harem anyway due to the actual single girl romance aspect Shizuku would like to have a word with you. |
| |
| I mostly like Ecchi anime because they mostly have badass female characters and a strong MC and NOT SOME SHITTY BETA because I hate those type a lot and the only one I know that has a terrible Beta is Girls Bravo. |
 |
Satan-sama said: Definitely watch Prison School if you haven't.I don't hate ecchi anime but most of them are trash, exactly like this show, ecchi anime have to offer something new, I mean, if I'm here to see boobs then hentai would be a better choice, High School of the dead is one of the best ecchi anime I've ever watched, it was exciting and interesting with a decent plot. |
 |
| Finally, I can find the one who thinks something like me! I watch many Harem , Fan service or even School-Battle harem Anime; All of them are given average score of 5-7 no matter how great it was. Since it's very easy to give a rating - Just click Add to list>Watched and give a bad Rating. You don't even need to see a real thing, You can easily pretend you've watched! I've not even mentioned you can just write review without "Really Watching" that anime! And those Fanservice/Harem Anime Haters can come here, Give a bad rating and/or review. Find a Harem or Fanservice anime with good ratings and majority positive review, I dare you. Those hater may just be jealous of MC or just think EVERY anime have to had Intense Plot, Serious Atmosphere ,Dramas and mysteries - The great anime(or literary any media) is the one that you enjoyed while watching, It does not need to be perfect at everything. But if there's a lover, There's going to have a haters ,too. Even how great it was. |
| This anime is good even without the ecchi. I watching for the story/action/charactes. But the ecchi scenes make it even better |
| It's because ecchi doesn't add anything to entertainment unless you're there to masturbate and watch anime at the same time. And it's hard to watch ecchi; people come into my room every now and then and they come in at the elicit parts making a huge misunderstanding. |
| This crap must stop....Please next season I pray for a ecchi harem like DxD, Highschool of the dead...u know one the actually has something more then there "Plot" going for it not juts the borderline hentai scenes. |
| "You can't spell slaughter without laughter". |
Looks_Easy said: It's because ecchi doesn't add anything to entertainment unless you're there to masturbate and watch anime at the same time. And it's hard to watch ecchi; people come into my room every now and then and they come in at the elicit parts making a huge misunderstanding. When I was drawing my signature (yes I drew that and yes it's a body pillow I have one of all the main Fairy Tail boyz) my dad walked in the room and I just looked at him and smiled nervously, and he just smiled and said "Ah, my daughter, the artist". THAT SAID, I HAVE AN ECCHI BANNER CAN I JOIN IN THIS CONVO? LET ECCHI REIGN! BRING ME MORE NAKED MEN FANSERVICE! ♥ |
Looks_Easy said: It's because ecchi doesn't add anything to entertainment unless you're there to masturbate and watch anime at the same time. And it's hard to watch ecchi; people come into my room every now and then and they come in at the elicit parts making a huge misunderstanding. Well isn't that the most subjective thing ever. And yes, I know it's called an opinion, I have my own too: Ecchi adds a dimension of entertainment appreciated by people who realize that it's just fan service that doesn't detract from the show unless it's a main theme and is implemented badly. In this show's case, it's not implemented badly and is used more as a gimmick than anything else which is a perfectly valid thing. |
| I think ecchi is a blessing upon us all, but this show is just quite bad lol. It's not entertaining like Keijo, not action-packed and intelligent like Kill la Kill, not as provocative as Highschool DxD... it just has nothing going for it, even as an ecchi :/ |
 |
| I'm not a big fan of ecchi but I'm not overly critical of it either. The couple of ecchi animes I've ever watched (this one included) was because my boyfriend raves about it and it gets me curious. lol. This show was entertaining though, even for me. It's certainly not the best but it's not the worst either to deserve a rating like a 1 (no show deserves a 1 IMO but that's just me). I think those that give 1/10 ratings not only for ecchi anime but for any anime of any genre are just too damn serious and overly critical than what is necessary for something that's supposed to bring joy/entertainment... which really, is a shame. But oh well~ |
 . . . . . ✘ . . . . .DO NOT touch my rice. . . . . . I'm Asian. . . . . . |
| I honestly do not know why ecchi exists ... I would watch DxD without ecchi, with great pleasure, HOTD too, but there are animes that the story is so weak that they are worth only because of ecchi, and that I do not understand, it is impossible to make a hentai with a good and long story? We all know that has a lot of hentai that even short has a better story that many ecchi animes. Man ... if I could accept that there are people who likes soft-porn, everything would be easier ... |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Masou Gakuen HxH Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 30, 2016 |
66 |
by Carnatzubionic
»»
Oct 5, 6:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Masou Gakuen HxH Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 9, 2016 |
69 |
by Rias-Chu
»»
Aug 2, 3:47 PM |
|
Poll: » Masou Gakuen HxH Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jul 19, 2016 |
72 |
by little_raven
»»
Jun 14, 9:56 AM |
|
Poll: » Masou Gakuen HxH Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 6, 2016 |
57 |
by spicarie
»»
Jun 13, 8:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Masou Gakuen HxH Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Sep 20, 2016 |
124 |
by Celestial-Honami
»»
May 1, 1:56 PM |