DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS A LIGHT NOVEL ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS VOLUME. ---------------------------------------- Volume 5 will be released in 25 October. SPOILER (Rumor) 2nd Year Voll 5 - Horikita's class was given to choose between, getting 100 class points at the expense of 1 students, or don't sacrifice someone. Since Kushida kept saying "Yes", they decided to sacrifice 1 students. - Ayanokouji want to sacrifice Kushida, but Horikita was against it. - Horikita actually wanted to sacrifice Airi, but she hesitated and didn't do anything. - Ayanokouji then want to sacrifice Airi. - Ike and Airi are compared. Ike's OAA was slightly ahead of Airi, and many students were against Ike's expulsion. On the other hand, only Ayanokouji's group (especially Haruka) were against Airi's expulsion / DO. - Kushida's true personality is exposed, she reveals many secrets. But Horikita stopped her. - Ayanokouji said only Sakura was the most logical to sacrifice. Haruka argues with Ayanokouji, Ayanokouji asks Airi to make a sacrifice. Then Airi persuaded Haruka, and Haruka finally chose Airi. - Hirata agrees. - Airi showed her changed appearance and said goodbye~ woahhh Airiiii  - No expelled / DO in Ichinose class, while other classes each have one expelled (another: No expelled in other class, Horikita's class wins big) - Horikita/Ayanokouji is now class B, Ryuen is class C, Sakayanagi is class A, and Ichinose is class D. - The relationship in Horikita's class has partially collapsed - Ayanokouji's group disbanded - Ayanokouji recognizes Horikita - Chabashira and Ayanokouji's relationship improved ... *just rumours. Not confirmed |
anime-primeOct 24, 2022 2:35 AM
Syureria said: Bro Do you have the mtl for this volume..i.e year 2 volume 5 ??THIS IS A LIGHT NOVEL ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS VOLUME. ---------------------------------------- Volume 5 will be released in 25 October. SPOILER (Rumor) 2nd Year Voll 5 - Horikita's class was given to choose between, getting 100 class points at the expense of 1 students, or don't sacrifice someone. Since Kushida kept saying "Yes", they decided to sacrifice 1 students. - Ayanokouji want to sacrifice Kushida, but Horikita was against it. - Horikita actually wanted to sacrifice Airi, but she hesitated and didn't do anything. - Ayanokouji then want to sacrifice Airi. - Ike and Airi are compared. Ike's OAA was slightly ahead of Airi, and many students were against Ike's expulsion. On the other hand, only Ayanokouji's group (especially Haruka) were against Airi's expulsion / DO. - Kushida's true personality is exposed, she reveals many secrets. But Horikita stopped her. - Ayanokouji said only Sakura was the most logical to sacrifice. Haruka argues with Ayanokouji, Ayanokouji asks Airi to make a sacrifice. Then Airi persuaded Haruka, and Haruka finally chose Airi. - Hirata agrees. - Airi showed her changed appearance and said goodbye~ woahhh Airiiii - No expelled / DO in Ichinose class, while other classes each have one expelled (another: No expelled in other class, Horikita's class wins big) - Horikita/Ayanokouji is now class B, Ryuen is class C, Sakayanagi is class A, and Ichinose is class D. - The relationship in Horikita's class has partially collapsed - Ayanokouji's group disbanded - Ayanokouji recognizes Horikita - Chabashira and Ayanokouji's relationship improved ... *just rumours. Not confirmed |
SakKiyo said: I have HTL, but where's your country / language, if you comes from indo, just send me a PM :")Bro Do you have the mtl for this volume..i.e year 2 volume 5 ?? |
| Finished reading. It was very good. It is tentatively my favourite volume of year 2 arc so far. It did a lot of things I wanted, particularly Kushida and Ayanokouji getting exposed to the entire class, KiyoKei relationship going public, Ayanokouji Group getting dismantled, among other things. Kanzaki is a legend. I can't wait for the fallout next volume. Perhaps Nagumo will face off against Ayanokouji in the sports festival. I hope Kinu can top Manabu vs Ayanokouji. |
| Just finished reading Volume 5. This volume really drain my emotion. Its good Kushida getting exposed, even though horikita defendef her from getting expulsion. Its sad to see Airi (My favorite) getting expelled. Cant wait to see what will happens after this incident in the next volume. |
 |
| Is everyone reading the slightly edited mtl? Or is there a properly translated v5 somewhere? |
 |
Syureria said: THIS IS A LIGHT NOVEL ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS VOLUME. ---------------------------------------- Volume 5 will be released in 25 October. SPOILER (Rumor) 2nd Year Voll 5 - Horikita's class was given to choose between, getting 100 class points at the expense of 1 students, or don't sacrifice someone. Since Kushida kept saying "Yes", they decided to sacrifice 1 students. - Ayanokouji want to sacrifice Kushida, but Horikita was against it. - Horikita actually wanted to sacrifice Airi, but she hesitated and didn't do anything. - Ayanokouji then want to sacrifice Airi. - Ike and Airi are compared. Ike's OAA was slightly ahead of Airi, and many students were against Ike's expulsion. On the other hand, only Ayanokouji's group (especially Haruka) were against Airi's expulsion / DO. - Kushida's true personality is exposed, she reveals many secrets. But Horikita stopped her. - Ayanokouji said only Sakura was the most logical to sacrifice. Haruka argues with Ayanokouji, Ayanokouji asks Airi to make a sacrifice. Then Airi persuaded Haruka, and Haruka finally chose Airi. - Hirata agrees. - Airi showed her changed appearance and said goodbye~ woahhh Airiiii - No expelled / DO in Ichinose class, while other classes each have one expelled (another: No expelled in other class, Horikita's class wins big) - Horikita/Ayanokouji is now class B, Ryuen is class C, Sakayanagi is class A, and Ichinose is class D. - The relationship in Horikita's class has partially collapsed - Ayanokouji's group disbanded - Ayanokouji recognizes Horikita - Chabashira and Ayanokouji's relationship improved ... *just rumours. Not confirmed Wow, all of them are correct. And this is even before the official release of the volume which is in (25/10) and not mentioned in the trial version too. Where did you get these spoilers bro? I'm surprised! |
 |
MH93 said: from Rahasia......Where did you get these spoilers bro? I'm surprised! |
Syureria said: from Rahasia...... Do you have the link? |
|
MH93 said: Nope, no link... Old stuff :")Do you have the link? |
Syureria said: Nope, no link... Old stuff :") Dude you talk with riddles. What is "Rahasia", anyway? If you don't want to talk about it, no problem. |
|
MH93 said: it's an discord server name i send u link, check...Dude you talk with riddles. What is "Rahasia", anyway? If you don't want to talk about it, no problem. |
SyureriaJan 30, 2022 4:39 AM
| just finished it, i quite liked V5 cuz it was exposing kiyokei relationship, kushida's identity and making kanzaki one of my favourite characters in this LN but the thing that annoyed me was that illustration where horikita sat on her chair and thinking of whether she expels kushida or not? i was like please ST*U STOP BEING SO NAIVE OM*G... anyway, am i the only one who thinks that she's useless. the only good move she made for me was when she inverted questions for ryuen's class and that's all |
 |
| this gets better every volume, though there is something i didnt get, ayanokoji wanted to expel kushida but horikita protected her and spoke about her potential, but like will kushida even help the class after all that happened? |
 |
Kirubanandan said: no idea, probably once every 4 months releasing 1 vol COTE year 2 volume 6 release date? |
| Bro... Poor Sakura :( she was one of the prettiest girls in Ayanokouji's class, so sad she has to be sacrifice |
| honestly i wass pissed that kushida bit*h didnt expelled and horikta still saying about POTENTIAL!!!! god damn it ..it's 15th vol and they are still taking about potential at this point i just wanted her to go out of school but now we cant do anything all we can hope is that kushida better become useful to her class |
 |
Syureria said: send me same bro.....MH93 said: it's an discord server name i send u link, check...Dude you talk with riddles. What is "Rahasia", anyway? If you don't want to talk about it, no problem. |
|
| Sakura is gone, good riddance. Also horikita and kushida enemies to lover arc when??? |
 just wanna feel wanted by someone other than the police 😫 |
| I want to thank the mal dude who wrote character description of airi, so anime guys who saw first season and clicked on her profile and saw the spoiler thinking 'its fine I just finished s1' and got hit by a truck of emotions because of the incident described there takes place in 20th book. I was one of them so I thought I appreciated this visionary. This volume had the best aspects of cote but I have deep and serious problems with it. They never needed to go in the expel vote. They could've guessed who was the traitor quite easily, even every guy who studies logic can do it. It's one of the very basic problems. Here's the solution: At every vote, suzune selects one person and instructs them to flip their vote. If they are innocent, they'll flip it and result would be 37/2. This would take 38 turns, but they could've limited the search easily. They couldn't use binary division because kushida could manipulate her vote and throw confusion. They even could've forced kushida to take first or second turn coz they already knew. If kushida thought she'll just flip hers when it was someone else's turn, suzune could instruct to continue vote and told some other person secretly to not flip it to get consensus. There can be many ways to point to her because they already knew. This really sucks man. I feel like airi was cut off from the story coz she didn't have much role later. She was the first good friend kiyo made, and was her best friend for a long time. That means he will throw out anyone if the need arises. Also I think people hate kushida for wrong reasons. Kiyo is basically doing the same thing. Confronting people when they're vulnerable and taking advantage of situation. She should be hated for showing her true face to ryuuen, while only targeting our duo. Also she is helping yagami, when she should eliminate him instead because he'll be here longer than she will. She could have even asked kiyo's help with the contract as the sacrifice. |
Anime was it's best 20000 years ago, when cavemen drew art with real depth. Modern anime is all garbage. I miss great old days of anime. |
| Expel the unstable, bipolar, sly and manipulative classmate who has been actively sabotaging your class from the beginning or expel an innocent girl? Horikita: 🤔 the potential tho... I get that Kinugod loves his plot twists but my god this decision was farcical. No way any sane human ever plays devil's advocate for Kushida after seeing her try to make your class burn over her persecution complex Also what is the logic behind Kushida voting in favor? Did she honestly think that she could expel Ayanokouji/Horikita in this exam? She knew the voting had to be unanimous and Horikita and Ayanokouji would never vote each other out right? All this bs and the insane gaslighting at the end.. yeah probably my least favorite volume so far Obligatory volume meme  |
Light-Aug 21, 2023 4:12 AM
ANIME LIST
PROFILE
MUSIC
| Its a good volume and actually made me feel emotions. The only thing is the ending, which I find it quite hard to believe that the class actually kept Kushida and chose to expel Airi. I do get that the school's whole point is to rank people based on their abilities, but how could the entire class still chose to expel Airi after hearing Kushida talking so much shit about them? It's also hard to believe that after hearing Horikita saying Kushida has potential, they just chose to go along with it and sacrifice Airi who was humble did no harm to class. Even from the sense of keeping the class united, its a much better choice to keep Airi, rather than Kushida who already got her secret revealed to the entire class. |
| Man… Up until this point I was willing to go to bat for Horikita because I really believed in her character, and leadership skills. (in many fashions I still do), but this was not at all satisfying as an end. It was nothing short of selfish, her unyielding desire to cling to what Kushida ‘could be’ ends up seriously fracturing the class. Do I think it will be resolved after some time? Of course, but just like I was disappointed with the anticlimactic end of Tsukishiro’s looming threat in the previous volume, the seeds of annoyance have finally begun to grow for me towards Horikita. She made the wrong call here, but I suppose it doesn’t matter if she’s simply growing in Ayanokouji’s petri dish so-to-speak. Great volume overall though. |
 |
| well damn, what the flip horikita... |
 It's useless! From here on, the path is only a One-way road! Just put your tail between your legs and get your ass back where you came from! - Accelerator |
Reply to ZlyWilk
what the hell i have read a ton of books in my life but Airi's expulsion got me more emotional than any other book 😣😣😣 especially the scene where she came to Kiyotaka to say goodbye, it made me so sad that i almost started crying
when Haruka was talking about renovating her i envisioned the future Sakura, the prettiest girl of Horikita's class that overcame her weaknesses and became more sociable, smarter and stronger. that was the moment when i started to seriously care for her character, especially for her possible development.
i really want to blame Kushida, Horikita or even Ayanokōji for Airi's expulsion but I cant bring myself to blame any of them. i also think that if Kushida changed and started being honest with everyone else, she would become a strong asset to Horikita's class and that's why i can't hate Horikita for taking that risk
Kushida also cannot be completely blamed for Sakura's expulsion because she was what she was and somebody just had to be expelled. she was the one started the situation that resulted in Airi's expulsion but she was not the one who guided it towards choosing her
if i were to choose then i would 100% expel Kushida, but if you exclude her from the equation then Sakura with the lowest OAA score is unfortunately the obvious option. even if Kiyotaka was more emotional then he would still chose to expel Sakura, as in this specific situation, if he chose anyone with higher OAA, it would have created hesitation and probably resulted in losing the exam. i can't find any flaws with his reasoning to expel Airi.
still i will mourn Sakura's expulsion for at least a few volumes ahead
im not a native english so some sentences may be incorrect but i hope that they are at least understandable
also if you read through my somewhat pathetic soliloquy and have some thoughts then i'll be happy if you write something in response 😸
when Haruka was talking about renovating her i envisioned the future Sakura, the prettiest girl of Horikita's class that overcame her weaknesses and became more sociable, smarter and stronger. that was the moment when i started to seriously care for her character, especially for her possible development.
i really want to blame Kushida, Horikita or even Ayanokōji for Airi's expulsion but I cant bring myself to blame any of them. i also think that if Kushida changed and started being honest with everyone else, she would become a strong asset to Horikita's class and that's why i can't hate Horikita for taking that risk
Kushida also cannot be completely blamed for Sakura's expulsion because she was what she was and somebody just had to be expelled. she was the one started the situation that resulted in Airi's expulsion but she was not the one who guided it towards choosing her
if i were to choose then i would 100% expel Kushida, but if you exclude her from the equation then Sakura with the lowest OAA score is unfortunately the obvious option. even if Kiyotaka was more emotional then he would still chose to expel Sakura, as in this specific situation, if he chose anyone with higher OAA, it would have created hesitation and probably resulted in losing the exam. i can't find any flaws with his reasoning to expel Airi.
still i will mourn Sakura's expulsion for at least a few volumes ahead
im not a native english so some sentences may be incorrect but i hope that they are at least understandable
also if you read through my somewhat pathetic soliloquy and have some thoughts then i'll be happy if you write something in response 😸
| @ZlyWilk i have read a ton of books in my life but Airi's expulsion got me more emotional than any other book 😣😣😣 especially the scene where she came to Kiyotaka to say goodbye, it made me so sad that i almost started crying Just finished volume 5 and I feel the same. This scene broke my heart... poor Airi... I hope her sacrifice won't be in vain. This volume is my favorite one and also the saddest one so far... It put me in a state of emotional turmoil. |
| I also want to say that I'm very happy and pleasantly surprised that Kikyou Kushida hasn't been expelled. I really thought she was going to depart from the school from the moment I started knowing what the unanimous exam was about. She's valuable for the class and I always had hope that she could change for the better. She's also one of my fav character so I might be biased I guess... :D |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e: 2-nensei-hen Volume 12 DiscussionNaughtySempai - Aug 13 |
10 |
by JayKitsuneTV
»»
Sep 4, 9:42 PM |
|
» Sakayanagi vs Ryueenkiyopon111 - Sep 4 |
2 |
by deebosamuel
»»
Sep 4, 11:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e: 2-nensei-hen Volume 11 DiscussionPussyit8 - Jun 10 |
4 |
by ImenonoawaiDream
»»
Aug 11, 10:44 PM |
|
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e: 2-nensei-hen Volume 9 DiscussionSyureria - Feb 24, 2023 |
10 |
by szewc
»»
Jul 31, 5:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e: 2-nensei-hen Volume 8 DiscussionSyureria - Oct 24, 2022 |
29 |
by jas-samaaa
»»
Jul 24, 7:30 AM |