Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
Higehiro: After Being Rejected, I Shaved and Took in a High School Runaway (light novel)
Available on Manga Store
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (5) « First ... « 2 3 [4] 5 »
May 4, 2021 7:51 AM

Offline
May 2017
125
Gab5 said:

Glad someone else has said it. I was accused of forcing my opinions on others yesterday. I really don't care who ends with who in a stupid anime, but the attitudes displayed in people making their choices, on both sides, are out of the 19th century. One is being called all kind of derogatory names for their background, and the other is being called shady and suspicious for not falling at the MCs feet. I have argued with my girlfriend about anime not being particularly sexist, etc, etc, but having my doubts now. Look at all the comments here, all the women are getting judged but Yoshida is just a top guy, can't do any wrong. It's just blatant.


Gab5 said:
Yes, but she doesn't fall at Yoshida's feet while he's staring at her boobs so people don't trust her. People are even claiming she asked Sayu to leave, which is nonsense. She gave a better talk than the one Yoshida gave and she probably is in a better position to understand Sayu, and what she needs than he is.

I find all the sl*t name calling of Sayu just as bad but the kind of subtle bias against a strong person just because they don't fold is kind of annoying. Just goes to show, if people are biased against you there is nothing much you can do about it.

I suppose that is what anime has taught us and a more complex character just totally bamboozles people.


I'm with you all the way, but again, at the risk of beating a dead horse, one's ability to really get what's going on is down to maturity level. This is the reason why that leading negative review irks me; the author (and those that thumbed it up) has actually reviewed a completely different anime than the one we are watching. Too many people have broken anime into tropes and then misapplied those tropes because they just don't understand anything on a deeper contextual level. This is why you keep getting people throwing the 'harem' tag around even though this has been set up to be no such thing. But multiple possible love interests automatically equals harem, amirite?

I'll also agree with the lack of proper criticism against Yoshida, even though I like him and agree with most here that he's 'too nice'. Call me guilty of projection if someone likes, but the fact is that through his actions he has left the door open for a future relationship with Sayu. How noble is he being, really? All those leering shots of her in scanty clothing are purposely there to make us aware that Yoshida is very aware that she is sexually attractive and that it turns him on, even if he is doing the adult thing at the moment and fights it off. Is what he's doing completely altruistic? I don't know. Yoshida might not even know. But I have my doubts.

Of course, we've already had commenters wonder why this is even a taboo, because hey look Sayu's developed boobs so she's really an adult. And age of consent is age eleven on some island somewhere so it's all arbitrary herp derp.

Reality check: Sayu is a homeless high school girl runaway. Meaning she is powerless and vulnerable, which makes her not only susceptible to the short-term physical predations of men, but to the long-term mental manipulation of men, and to be honest the latter route is often far easier for men to execute. This is why age differential matters to people no matter which gender is on the older/younger end - with different levels of maturity it doesn't feel like you're playing fair. Us older guys and gals know that it's entirely too easy to manipulate and control someone younger, even if it's not malicious or even consciously done. And again, Sayu is not only vulnerable because she's young, but also homeless and also troubled.

Mature watchers don't need to be explained all this - and neither does Gotou. Or Mishima. Or even Yoshida. All three of them know how men generally think and behave. All of them know the huge risk Yoshida is taking by bringing Sayu in. What happens if he gives in to temptation? What happens if Sayu flips out? If there's an altercation, how is one supposed to figure out who to believe? Why is Yoshida going through so much risk, the potential of losing his job, or even his freedom to jail time, and also risking his potential relationship to his only crush over the last five years over a girl he just met freaking twenty minutes ago?

Or, I dunno, maybe Yoshida is just the purest being to walk this anime earth, or something.

In closing, I'm just posting here as food for thought. I like the story so far, and I like Yoshida. But I thought I'd steelman the argument against shipping the two lead characters, and why Yoshida isn't beyond criticism.
Forum sniper of MAL. Accuracy, efficiency. Beware the catgun.
May 4, 2021 9:14 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:
ManlyTear said:
Are people for real with the Gouto Airi hate even now? She could've done any number of things to put pressure on Sayu to get out ASAP, but instead she pointed out how she found a safe place. Naturally, she had to ask the hard question a.k.a. how long does she plan to stay here because really, Sayu can't stay here forever, this is a temp solution.

THEN, Gotou also encourages Yoshida himself to take care of Airi, all while still having feelings for him herself. She could've very well lose interest in him here, since if it's validation that she'd want, there'd be better targets, but she didn't. The manga showed it's more of an "feelings on-hold" situation, but still still likes Yoshida.

That and what she said about watching him since the early days when he came to the company, which she proved in ep 2 when pointing out how she likes that she doesn't have to act like the "proper,sweet lady the bosses/co-workers want" with him and she can be more open & enjoying herself by gulping down some yakiniku & beer around him.

Regardless of whether these two will end up together or not, Gotou Airi's proving to be quite the fine woman.





Yes, but she doesn't fall at Yoshida's feet while he's staring at her boobs so people don't trust her. People are even claiming she asked Sayu to leave, which is nonsense. She gave a better talk than the one Yoshida gave and she probably is in a better position to understand Sayu, and what she needs than he is.

I find all the sl*t name calling of Sayu just as bad but the kind of subtle bias against a strong person just because they don't fold is kind of annoying. Just goes to show, if people are biased against you there is nothing much you can do about it.

I suppose that is what anime has taught us and a more complex character just totally bamboozles people.




I guess that some people are talking bad about Sayu knowing what happened in the past and her choices along the way.
removed-userMay 4, 2021 9:23 AM
May 4, 2021 9:16 AM

Offline
Jun 2016
2107
perfect couple is Yoshida X Gotou-san !!!

no doubt !!
May 4, 2021 9:41 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10505
nightcrawlercyp said:
No I am not. How is a woman at 16 biologically a child?


Um....the MENTAL part is important too; that's why it's illegal for 16-year-olds to have sex with adults in most places of the world....ya stupid.....


About being too immature for marriage but what standards?


Um society's?



May 4, 2021 9:41 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:


I guess that some people are talking bad about Sayu knowing what happened in the past and her choices along the way.


People gotta have someone to hate. I can just imagine what people will be calling her. Next episode is going to be interesting.
May 4, 2021 9:52 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Phantasy_Starved said:

I'm with you all the way, but again, at the risk of beating a dead horse, one's ability to really get what's going on is down to maturity level. This is the reason why that leading negative review irks me; the author (and those that thumbed it up) has actually reviewed a completely different anime than the one we are watching. Too many people have broken anime into tropes and then misapplied those tropes because they just don't understand anything on a deeper contextual level. This is why you keep getting people throwing the 'harem' tag around even though this has been set up to be no such thing. But multiple possible love interests automatically equals harem, amirite?

I'll also agree with the lack of proper criticism against Yoshida, even though I like him and agree with most here that he's 'too nice'. Call me guilty of projection if someone likes, but the fact is that through his actions he has left the door open for a future relationship with Sayu. How noble is he being, really? All those leering shots of her in scanty clothing are purposely there to make us aware that Yoshida is very aware that she is sexually attractive and that it turns him on, even if he is doing the adult thing at the moment and fights it off. Is what he's doing completely altruistic? I don't know. Yoshida might not even know. But I have my doubts.

Of course, we've already had commenters wonder why this is even a taboo, because hey look Sayu's developed boobs so she's really an adult. And age of consent is age eleven on some island somewhere so it's all arbitrary herp derp.

Reality check: Sayu is a homeless high school girl runaway. Meaning she is powerless and vulnerable, which makes her not only susceptible to the short-term physical predations of men, but to the long-term mental manipulation of men, and to be honest the latter route is often far easier for men to execute. This is why age differential matters to people no matter which gender is on the older/younger end - with different levels of maturity it doesn't feel like you're playing fair. Us older guys and gals know that it's entirely too easy to manipulate and control someone younger, even if it's not malicious or even consciously done. And again, Sayu is not only vulnerable because she's young, but also homeless and also troubled.

Mature watchers don't need to be explained all this - and neither does Gotou. Or Mishima. Or even Yoshida. All three of them know how men generally think and behave. All of them know the huge risk Yoshida is taking by bringing Sayu in. What happens if he gives in to temptation? What happens if Sayu flips out? If there's an altercation, how is one supposed to figure out who to believe? Why is Yoshida going through so much risk, the potential of losing his job, or even his freedom to jail time, and also risking his potential relationship to his only crush over the last five years over a girl he just met freaking twenty minutes ago?

Or, I dunno, maybe Yoshida is just the purest being to walk this anime earth, or something.

In closing, I'm just posting here as food for thought. I like the story so far, and I like Yoshida. But I thought I'd steelman the argument against shipping the two lead characters, and why Yoshida isn't beyond criticism.


Thank you. The best thing about this show is that it is a serious subject being handled and, obviously, a lot of people are talking about it. So people looking at it with harem eyes is disappointing, although I think the author must take some of the blame. Some of these characters are not needed to tell the main story.

I couldn't put any of that any better and I'm happy that someone sees it the same way. People thinking that debate is about who Yoshida should end up with, when it is about their attitude to people who are saying and doing the right thing.

As I've said many times, if Sayu had been a 15 year old guy, would he be in Yoshida's flat? And his behaviour while going out with Gotou has been downright rude, staring at her chest, asking her to sleep with him and asking her cup size. I've never seen anyone do this while drinking with a woman and I'd expect a slap in the face if i did it. Not sure where this 'good guy' narrative has come from. It's 'good guy' within typical anime behaviour but anyone acting like that in real life wouldn't be very popular.

Your post has helped restore some of my faith in the human race!!
Gab5May 4, 2021 9:58 AM
May 4, 2021 10:28 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

Thank you. The best thing about this show is that it is a serious subject being handled and, obviously, a lot of people are talking about it. So people looking at it with harem eyes is disappointing, although I think the author must take some of the blame. Some of these characters are not needed to tell the main story.

I couldn't put any of that any better and I'm happy that someone sees it the same way. People thinking that debate is about who Yoshida should end up with, when it is about their attitude to people who are saying and doing the right thing.

As I've said many times, if Sayu had been a 15 year old guy, would he be in Yoshida's flat? And his behaviour while going out with Gotou has been downright rude, staring at her chest, asking her to sleep with him and asking her cup size. I've never seen anyone do this while drinking with a woman and I'd expect a slap in the face if i did it. Not sure where this 'good guy' narrative has come from. It's 'good guy' within typical anime behaviour but anyone acting like that in real life wouldn't be very popular.

Your post has helped restore some of my faith in the human race!!


Well, I don't find those things to be as bad as you say they are and I'm also sure that if Sayu was a 15 year old guy he would still let him stay in his apartment. Maybe things would go a little bit different but I think that what Yoshida does here in the anime is basically what a father would do to her daughter. He talks with her reffering to her as a kid, which she obviously is.. He says numerous times that he doesn't feel anything for her even though Sayu wanted to charm him by undressing and stuff like that. When he blushes sometimes, it is because Sayu is a stunning girl, not that he would like to have his way with her. He was serious when Sayu asked him to have sex. He gives her advice and tells her that what she's doing is not right (in his mind he thinks that what she has done is utterly stupid and that she is wasting her life, but he does his best to be the nice guy, which he also is). He respects the girl's will to stay away from her family for a bit until she becomes a little more stable with help from him. He buys her a phone since he thinks that she feels lonely at home, he tells her that it would be better if she gets a job. What has Yoshida done until here that doesn't make him a nice guy? That he blushed when Sayu had makeup on? That's not something bad, he most likely thinks that she's pretty but he sucks at giving compliments. He was dead serious when she was undressed so we know that he doesn't have ill thougts. He is a nice guy, but wierd with conversations aswell. He can give good advices, be serious when the situation calls for it, and respect other's peoples needs. He likes Gotou's body, so what? He stares at her boobs and asked her the size of her cup, he's just a goofball. He was also testing Gotou to see if she really means it when he asked her if she wanted to sleep with him, it was obviously just a joke.

I think that the main reason he kept her in his apartment instead of instantly ratting her out, is because of her situation. I bet that if he tried to rat her out and not let her get a reality check from him to be able to stay stable, she would've returned home and leave again. Making the same stupid mistakes again and again with strangers that don't give a damn about her. He wants to be sure that the girl understands that she doesn't have to do all that to live and that she needs to confront her issues rather than run away from them. Gotou's talk with Sayu was extremely helpfull aswell, it made Sayu understand even more what she has to do. He keeps her away from that toxic way of living that she chose.
May 4, 2021 11:16 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:


Well, I don't find those things to be as bad as you say they are and I'm also sure that if Sayu was a 15 year old guy he would still let him stay in his apartment. Maybe things would go a little bit different but I think that what Yoshida does here in the anime is basically what a father would do to her daughter. He talks with her reffering to her as a kid, which she obviously is.. He says numerous times that he doesn't feel anything for her even though Sayu wanted to charm him by undressing and stuff like that. When he blushes sometimes, it is because Sayu is a stunning girl, not that he would like to have his way with her. He was serious when Sayu asked him to have sex. He gives her advice and tells her that what she's doing is not right (in his mind he thinks that what she has done is utterly stupid and that she is wasting her life, but he does his best to be the nice guy, which he also is). He respects the girl's will to stay away from her family for a bit until she becomes a little more stable with help from him. He buys her a phone since he thinks that she feels lonely at home, he tells her that it would be better if she gets a job. What has Yoshida done until here that doesn't make him a nice guy? That he blushed when Sayu had makeup on? That's not something bad, he most likely thinks that she's pretty but he sucks at giving compliments. He was dead serious when she was undressed so we know that he doesn't have ill thougts. He is a nice guy, but wierd with conversations aswell. He can give good advices, be serious when the situation calls for it, and respect other's peoples needs. He likes Gotou's body, so what? He stares at her boobs and asked her the size of her cup, he's just a goofball. He was also testing Gotou to see if she really means it when he asked her if she wanted to sleep with him, it was obviously just a joke.

I think that the main reason he kept her in his apartment instead of instantly ratting her out, is because of her situation. I bet that if he tried to rat her out and not let her get a reality check from him to be able to stay stable, she would've returned home and leave again. Making the same stupid mistakes again and again with strangers that don't give a damn about her. He wants to be sure that the girl understands that she doesn't have to do all that to live and that she needs to confront her issues rather than run away from them. Gotou's talk with Sayu was extremely helpfull aswell, it made Sayu understand even more what she has to do. He keeps her away from that toxic way of living that she chose.


I don't know that he would, I'm certainly not 'sure' that he would or he wouldn't.

Presumably, if you see him as a father, the romance angle with Sayu is out for you? So what if the 'father' starts dating the 'daughter'? I see them as more brother and sister but you can't be a father figure, or guardian, and then start screwing around with the person that you are looking after.

Do you believe that all Sayu sees as good and right in the world should come from Yoshida or maybe she should get out in the real world, stand on her two feet and decide for herself, maybe even make some mistakes along the way.

Who would be a better guardian for Sayu, given her history, Mishima, Gotou or Yoshida? Who would give better advice?

A goofball, asking someone what their cup size is? And asking if they will sleep with him? I don't think a lot of women will go for that, to be honest.

You are certain there is no ulterior motive at all and he doesn't have any romantic ideas? Sayu told Gotou more about her situation in a short time than she has told Yoshida in all the time she has been there. Sayu needs to understand things for herself and not just everything that Yoshida says, how do you think that will affect her? He's been told about the risks and potential problems but still thinks he knows better. It is a crazy risk and I don't think people do that just because they are nice.

May 4, 2021 11:48 AM
Offline
Aug 2016
1709
Great episode. Loved the interaction between Sayu and Gotou. It was slightly different from the manga, but still good nevertheless. Also, my blood boiled badly in the end when



5/5

May 4, 2021 12:19 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:


I don't know that he would, I'm certainly not 'sure' that he would or he wouldn't.

Presumably, if you see him as a father, the romance angle with Sayu is out for you? So what if the 'father' starts dating the 'daughter'? I see them as more brother and sister but you can't be a father figure, or guardian, and then start screwing around with the person that you are looking after.

Do you believe that all Sayu sees as good and right in the world should come from Yoshida or maybe she should get out in the real world, stand on her two feet and decide for herself, maybe even make some mistakes along the way.

Who would be a better guardian for Sayu, given her history, Mishima, Gotou or Yoshida? Who would give better advice?

A goofball, asking someone what their cup size is? And asking if they will sleep with him? I don't think a lot of women will go for that, to be honest.

You are certain there is no ulterior motive at all and he doesn't have any romantic ideas? Sayu told Gotou more about her situation in a short time than she has told Yoshida in all the time she has been there. Sayu needs to understand things for herself and not just everything that Yoshida says, how do you think that will affect her? He's been told about the risks and potential problems but still thinks he knows better. It is a crazy risk and I don't think people do that just because they are nice.




I, as one of the people who think that Yoshida is being a nice guy, believe that he is the person Sayu needed in her life at that exact moment. You say that "or maybe she should get in the real world and decide for herself, maybe even make some mistakes along the way", well, we saw how her going in the real world alone went like :) She basically became a sex slave. Making some mistakes is fine. But having sex at 16 years old with strangers that don't give a single damn about you is not just "some mistake". She is self-destructing at that point. Did you see that face in ep 3? That's the face of a human that gave up in life and everything is 'whatever' now. The worst thing in life in my opinion is to try to solve things or do things alone, especially at that age, in this society. Yoshida saved her from wasting her whole life or even becoming extremely depressed and later probably choosing suicide as an way out. So yes, I do belive that Yoshida is a good guardian for her.

"Presumably, if you see him as a father, the romance angle with Sayu is out for you? So what if the 'father' starts dating the 'daughter'? I see them as more brother and sister but you can't be a father figure, or guardian, and then start screwing around with the person that you are looking after."
--About the situation with them two togheter. Well, if Yoshida doesn't do anything to Sayu untill she's legal, and of course, he finds her another place to stay. It would be wierd if they stay years and years togheter, but not that wierd because he acts like a father, like I said. But it' still wrong and illegal, just not immorall though atm.

"Do you believe that all Sayu sees as good and right in the world should come from Yoshida."
--I bet that what Yoshida finds good and wrong is better than what Sayu thought good and wrong was. And tbh, I think that she knew what she was doing, she was just naive and thought that this was the only way for her to leave her family. Even though a close person to her tried to help(before Yoshida).

"Who would be a better guardian for Sayu, given her history, Mishima, Gotou or Yoshida? Who would give better advice?"
--All 3 of them could be her guardians. They are all with their heads on their shoulders and know what real life is.

"A goofball, asking someone what their cup size is?"
--Yes. You act like you've never seen those type of scenes in anime till now.. Yoshida is also naive when it comes to love. Just because you're an adult, it doesn't mean that you automatically know how to behave in front of your crush.

"You are certain there is no ulterior motive at all and he doesn't have any romantic ideas?"
--Of course I am certain, atleast atm he doesn't seem like he wants to be with her nor that he loves her at all(in that way). "Sayu told Gotou more about her situation in a short time than she told Yoshida", that's not true. She told her exactly the same things she told to Yoshida and she skipped the same things from her story aswell. She obviously opened to Gotou because the truth came out. Gotou is intelligent and didn't fall for Yoshida's silly story. That's why she told Gotou certain things so fast. They are also both girls. I bet that Sayu saw Gotou as someone close to a mother or a sister.


Sayu doesn't need to understand all the things for herself at all. She's a teenage girl, very young and naive. It's obviously good that she's being taught some things from people with experience. The risk that Yoshida takes is obviously big. But again. He does this because he wants to help Sayu get to a point where he doesn't need to worry about her doing the same stupid mistakes again. He doesn't have any ulterior motives.
removed-userMay 4, 2021 12:26 PM
May 4, 2021 12:22 PM

Offline
Feb 2008
628
Boomers like me aren't that naive to believe Gotou in just one episode. I still prefer the other office girl, but Gotou has two good reasons though.

Also, that guy at the end looks familiar... seems like some very uncomfortable episodes are coming up.
"Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum. They should really do their whining at manga forums."

Stolen from Janethan23. Add in visual novel readers too
May 4, 2021 1:28 PM
Offline
Apr 2021
13
Bakrakon said:
It's funny to see so many people misinterpret Gotou playing the "Nice older sister'-type when, she clearly has no romantic experiences in life, has no idea how to handle her own emotions regarding Yoshida and is basically just jealous.

Gotou dumped him aside with a silly excuse at a previous date, on the same day he met Sayu and when she realized he seems to have a girl in his life she practically forces herself into his home to "see" this girl. Forcing him into dinner dates with his boss(Gotou) because rejecting would be impolite and also knowing he had/has feelings for her.

Gotou is simply said a control freak, when there was no indication of him having a significant other she just went on with her life, but the moment there were signs she suddenly forces herself into his life.

Then when she had her private talk with Sayu she used the most roundabout way to tell Sayu to GTFO while remaining friendly, so it doesn't end up in drama where Sayu tells Yoshida about it. Exchanging phone-numbers is just another way to assert control and have a direct line of communication to gather information about both of them / entrapping them in their lies if ever there comes a time.

She also reminds Sayu she's a high school girl to show her her place in the world, coming from an adult this is a roundabout way of asserting her dominance as to say "I'm higher in the picking order".

Then you have people say Sayu is selfish? She is misguided and has a very low self-esteem, she clearly tries to cling onto something to keep her footing, which in this case is Yoshida.

Sure Gotou says some things that make sense and some things that Sayu may possibly learn from, but it's all really just for her own personal gain.



Why is everyone ignoring this comment ?? this guy speaks the truth.
I totaly agree with you.
Even if manga readers are spamming the anime threads and know how she'll turn, this episode was fcking disturbing. I don't like Gotou at all.
GreycasMay 4, 2021 1:33 PM
May 4, 2021 2:22 PM
Offline
Oct 2018
156
My opinion of Mishima just changed quite a bit. I was practically shipping her with Yoshida just a couple eps ago but now she seems like a creepy jealous stalker. Gotou’s stock has risen, she seems more sincere, but I have reservations about her too, and I’m not sure she can be trusted 100%.

So lots of drama all over. Things could go in a lot of different directions.
May 4, 2021 2:24 PM

Offline
Apr 2020
312
The guy at the end.
Oh boy, next episode is gonna be wild.
Nina supporter for life💕
May 4, 2021 2:56 PM
Offline
Mar 2021
15
90293otaku said:
My opinion of Mishima just changed quite a bit. I was practically shipping her with Yoshida just a couple eps ago but now she seems like a creepy jealous stalker. Gotou’s stock has risen, she seems more sincere, but I have reservations about her too, and I’m not sure she can be trusted 100%.

So lots of drama all over. Things could go in a lot of different directions.


Sincere? We must've seen a completely different show then...

- She obviously lied about having a boyfriend for 5 years.
- She gets jealous and possessive as she realizes Yoshida isn't chasing her any more.
- She puts up a fake smile to hide her intentions/feelings.
- She uses her position as Yoshida's boss (and his crush on her) to force dinner dates on him to entrap him to acquire information about his personal life.
- She pretends to be friendly by "helping" Sayu which is just an attempt at getting Sayu out of Yoshida's house, so she has Yoshida for herself, but does it in a calculated fashion in order not to rise any suspicion.
- She exchanged phone numbers with Sayu, surely not to be friends with each other but as a source of information on both Yoshida and herself.

Sayu is definitely the better choice of the 3 love interests... It's better to have a naïve, misguided girl with low self-esteem than the Manipulative Control freak(Gotou) or the Obsessive Stalker freak (Mishima).

Sayu hasn't done anything in the show thus far that makes her come across as selfish or freaky as the other two, she's put herself second to everybody else, she actually considers Yoshida's/Gotou's feelings for others, whereas Gotou is already trying to get rid of Sayu and Mshima is meddling with both Sayu/Gotou being in his home.

Those two just seem to be out to get what they want rather than caring about what Yoshida wants or decides to do. They don't respect his decision of taking in and taking care of Sayu and try to undermine his decision by playing mind games on both Sayu and Yoshida.

No matter how good looking or successful a woman is, they will always be afraid a man will pick a younger woman over them.
BakrakonMay 4, 2021 2:59 PM
May 4, 2021 3:18 PM

Offline
Apr 2019
1
It is good that Gotou now knows about Sayu and Yoshida's situation and that she and Sayu had a talk, if she is trustworthy at least.

However Mishima was being extremely stupid and the worst part is that mc doesn't realize it enough to tell her she was stupid. What did she want him to do? Throw Sayu out? Hide her in a room while Gotou and him are having sex? It's like the anime desperately wants to make Yoshida choose between Sayu and Gotou, even though that comparison is entirely invalid in this situation. Keeping Sayu in his house doesn't mean he likes Sayu more. It is just what any decent human being would do.

Also that last part is a pretty weird way to make your audience excited for the next episode ngl
May 4, 2021 4:34 PM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:

I, as one of the people who think that Yoshida is being a nice guy, believe that he is the person Sayu needed in her life at that exact moment. You say that "or maybe she should get in the real world and decide for herself, maybe even make some mistakes along the way", well, we saw how her going in the real world alone went like :) She basically became a sex slave. Making some mistakes is fine. But having sex at 16 years old with strangers that don't give a single damn about you is not just "some mistake". She is self-destructing at that point. Did you see that face in ep 3? That's the face of a human that gave up in life and everything is 'whatever' now. The worst thing in life in my opinion is to try to solve things or do things alone, especially at that age, in this society. Yoshida saved her from wasting her whole life or even becoming extremely depressed and later probably choosing suicide as an way out. So yes, I do belive that Yoshida is a good guardian for her.

"Presumably, if you see him as a father, the romance angle with Sayu is out for you? So what if the 'father' starts dating the 'daughter'? I see them as more brother and sister but you can't be a father figure, or guardian, and then start screwing around with the person that you are looking after."
--About the situation with them two togheter. Well, if Yoshida doesn't do anything to Sayu untill she's legal, and of course, he finds her another place to stay. It would be wierd if they stay years and years togheter, but not that wierd because he acts like a father, like I said. But it' still wrong and illegal, just not immorall though atm.

"Do you believe that all Sayu sees as good and right in the world should come from Yoshida."
--I bet that what Yoshida finds good and wrong is better than what Sayu thought good and wrong was. And tbh, I think that she knew what she was doing, she was just naive and thought that this was the only way for her to leave her family. Even though a close person to her tried to help(before Yoshida).

"Who would be a better guardian for Sayu, given her history, Mishima, Gotou or Yoshida? Who would give better advice?"
--All 3 of them could be her guardians. They are all with their heads on their shoulders and know what real life is.

"A goofball, asking someone what their cup size is?"
--Yes. You act like you've never seen those type of scenes in anime till now.. Yoshida is also naive when it comes to love. Just because you're an adult, it doesn't mean that you automatically know how to behave in front of your crush.

"You are certain there is no ulterior motive at all and he doesn't have any romantic ideas?"
--Of course I am certain, atleast atm he doesn't seem like he wants to be with her nor that he loves her at all(in that way). "Sayu told Gotou more about her situation in a short time than she told Yoshida", that's not true. She told her exactly the same things she told to Yoshida and she skipped the same things from her story aswell. She obviously opened to Gotou because the truth came out. Gotou is intelligent and didn't fall for Yoshida's silly story. That's why she told Gotou certain things so fast. They are also both girls. I bet that Sayu saw Gotou as someone close to a mother or a sister.


Sayu doesn't need to understand all the things for herself at all. She's a teenage girl, very young and naive. It's obviously good that she's being taught some things from people with experience. The risk that Yoshida takes is obviously big. But again. He does this because he wants to help Sayu get to a point where he doesn't need to worry about her doing the same stupid mistakes again. He doesn't have any ulterior motives.


You give the exact reason why, for me, Sayu has to learn and do it things the right way. It isn't healthy for her to only learn the world according to one person and never truly understand what she likes or doesn't like. She should be going home and working with people who are trained to look after a 17 year old runaway, not some self proclaimed expert. This is meant to be a serious story, i thought, not some harem.

Until she's legal, I'm not sure if you are saying it is ok for them to date or not. I couldn't care less about the age gap, I care more about him being the centre of her world, and guardian, and then proceeding to date her. That is not healthy. She needs to learn to think for herself. And if he is a prospective romantic interest, she shouldn't be learning it from him.

Yoshida became sheepish when Gotou asked if it was a boy or girl, if there is nothing in it, why would he get like that? The old family friend lie would have been easy to pull off, but they can't, why would that be? Could they be subconsciously leaving the romance option open and not feeling comfortable saying anything that makes them sound like 100% platonic?

Yes, I've seen the goofball character in anime, High School DxD and shows like that. Funny thing is that Yoshida isn't presented as that much of a goofball, more like a bit of a curmudgeon, but when he sees Gotou, his behaviour changes. It is entertaining in anime, for sure, but I'm not sure it is meant to portray the best way to get a girlfriend. If I'm single any time soon, I will try it.

Ok, you don't think he wants to be with her, I'm not convinced, I'm pretty sure he doesn't really want to be with the other women in the story, Mishima gave him a big heads up about choosing between Sayu and other people.

If they end up together, do you think there were ulterior motives or it just happened and he had no way of knowing that could happen?

I have no issue with Yoshida ending with Sayu, but I do think it goes against the early message in the first couple of episodes, but I would like to see her go home, spend some time away from him, learn to recognise good and bad people for herself and achieve things on her own before she went back to him. We are at episode 5 and she's still thinking the same childish thoughts, he hasn't convinced her of anything yet. But this is anime land, so i suppose anything is possible. I hope they keep at least some level of realism, though.
Gab5May 4, 2021 4:50 PM
May 4, 2021 4:38 PM
Offline
Mar 2015
13636
I was surprised that Gotou and Sayu reached an understanding even if Sayu does not understand her Here comes trouble from the past for Sayu
May 4, 2021 4:58 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
162
i wish that it turns out that gotou was pretending to be nice to sayu so she can get her outta here and have yoshida for herself but that's too good to be true cuz in this anime it's all about making sayu the queen of everything. i hate sayu so much this anime is so garbage way beyond comprehension. PLSSS END ALREADY let's hope there isn't s2 PLEASE
May 4, 2021 5:01 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
162
Reminder #1: Sayu Is One Of The Worst Characters Of All Time.
May 4, 2021 6:13 PM
Offline
Dec 2017
1
ngl this episode was boring af
May 4, 2021 8:17 PM

Offline
Nov 2014
719
I think in the end i wiill suport gotou x yoshida. Even if i feel bad for mishima, she doesn't picture anything in with the current situation yoshida is in to be honest, and i think she by knowing that should respecfully step out, but instead shes just sticking her nose more and more... also i really didn't like the way she implied yoshida should just kick sayu out of the house, it really damage the image i had of her...

The new guy seems like trouble now...
May 4, 2021 8:19 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
25755
This is the good series but this is why Japan has such a low birth rate. This pathetic simpery they're depicting. This gotou bitch is doing nothing for this series besides being a boring cock tease. Fuck this cunt. Seriously hope this guy doesn't get with her - there's literally 0 point. if you like someone fucking say it and do something about it.
May 4, 2021 9:27 PM
Offline
May 2019
195
PiyushSan said:

Does he get arrested or something? He was literally fucking a high schooler.


It'd be her word against his and any physical evidence is probably long gone, so...what basis would there be for an arrest? We're privy to that info as we're the readers/viewers but in-world who'd know it happened besides him and Sayu?
May 4, 2021 10:23 PM
Offline
Mar 2021
62
Damn. I thought Gotou was going to do something bad to Sayu, so I was wrong.

The guy at the end. All my homies hate you.
May 4, 2021 10:52 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
13718
i'm already having bad vibes from the conbini co-worker of Asami! go rapey-rapey all the way!! lolz NTR!
5/5.


May 4, 2021 11:43 PM
Offline
May 2019
213
I honestly can't tell if Gotou was trying to give Sayu tough love and advice. Or if she was just being a bitch, though I'm gonna say it was more advice. Though if there's one thing I would change with this episode it is how they throw around the term high school girl. I would use teenager instead.
May 5, 2021 12:33 AM
Offline
Sep 2019
257
I don't like that guy at the end >:(((((
May 5, 2021 2:20 AM
Offline
Jul 2020
485
The conversation between sayu and gotou was underwhelming. The way it was executed was so out of place seriously speaking.

That guy at the end jdndkeufiwd dammit

3/5 for the ep
May 5, 2021 3:57 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

You give the exact reason why, for me, Sayu has to learn and do it things the right way. It isn't healthy for her to only learn the world according to one person and never truly understand what she likes or doesn't like. She should be going home and working with people who are trained to look after a 17 year old runaway, not some self proclaimed expert. This is meant to be a serious story, i thought, not some harem.

Until she's legal, I'm not sure if you are saying it is ok for them to date or not. I couldn't care less about the age gap, I care more about him being the centre of her world, and guardian, and then proceeding to date her. That is not healthy. She needs to learn to think for herself. And if he is a prospective romantic interest, she shouldn't be learning it from him.

Yoshida became sheepish when Gotou asked if it was a boy or girl, if there is nothing in it, why would he get like that? The old family friend lie would have been easy to pull off, but they can't, why would that be? Could they be subconsciously leaving the romance option open and not feeling comfortable saying anything that makes them sound like 100% platonic?

Yes, I've seen the goofball character in anime, High School DxD and shows like that. Funny thing is that Yoshida isn't presented as that much of a goofball, more like a bit of a curmudgeon, but when he sees Gotou, his behaviour changes. It is entertaining in anime, for sure, but I'm not sure it is meant to portray the best way to get a girlfriend. If I'm single any time soon, I will try it.

Ok, you don't think he wants to be with her, I'm not convinced, I'm pretty sure he doesn't really want to be with the other women in the story, Mishima gave him a big heads up about choosing between Sayu and other people.

If they end up together, do you think there were ulterior motives or it just happened and he had no way of knowing that could happen?

I have no issue with Yoshida ending with Sayu, but I do think it goes against the early message in the first couple of episodes, but I would like to see her go home, spend some time away from him, learn to recognise good and bad people for herself and achieve things on her own before she went back to him. We are at episode 5 and she's still thinking the same childish thoughts, he hasn't convinced her of anything yet. But this is anime land, so i suppose anything is possible. I hope they keep at least some level of realism, though.


Look, imo, I gave you some pretty good answers to your questions. I think that you are overthinking things too hard. We are talking about anime charachters here, I know that this is a serious topic, but their reactions/decisions are scripted and we can't do anything about it. They aren't real people that have constantly 1000 thoughts running trough their minds, they always know what to do because that's how the manga author made them to.

I can't tell you what Yoshida is thinking right now, because I didn't read the manga nor do I want to. That goes for you aswell if you didn't read it. All that you are saying is just speculation. Yoshida never gave a sign that he loves or wants to be with Sayu. So idk why you think that he has ulterior motives. The arguments you bring are just the way you think that the things happened. But in my eyes, things just go the way they should have to go. It is indeed weird the fact that Sayu is still in Yoshida's place after her meeting with 2 women... But I guess that not every adult wants to deal with a runaway child. It is illegal for both of them to have Sayu even though they are women and they probably don't want to take the risk like Yoshida did. Hence why he's a good guy.

I would do the same thing irl tbh. Obviously it wouldn't take that much since the parents would call police and the first step Sayu takes outside, she would get caught and would have to return home. This is an anime, keep this in mind. She would be caught on cameras entering my house the first day and ruin all her plans. This anime doesn't show 100% how reality is, that's how it's entertaining. A story like this would probably go different in real life.

I do not say that Sayu should learn EVERY single thing from Yoshida or Gotou or Mishima. They don't teach her every single thing about life either. I just said that she should atleast know that what she did is bad and that she should be taught some things that could 1. save her form self-destructing again. 2. how to actually live life and not waste it. (if you don't go to school, you should get a job. Like Yoshida taught her. Not beg for a place to stay from strangers in exchange for sex.) You should earn it trough hard work. Also, you should confront things with your parents. You shouldn't just run away before even setting things right with them. And other usefull things that a teenager should get from his parents. All of these are good lectures. Idk why you think that they teach her anything else besides this..

Sayu definetly wants to be with Yoshida, there's no denying in that. Like I said, I do want them to be togheter since I like both Yoshida and Sayu and I don't want her to be with some perverted teen that doesn't care at all about her again. I want her to get a good guy. But then I feel bad about Gotou. It's complicated.
May 5, 2021 4:45 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
714
Yoshida needs to find a decent girlfriend. All five women/girls in his harem are psycho's or have baggage.

As for who he'll end up with, it's a "Romance Anime" so he'll end up with one of them.

I'm pretty sure he'll end up with Sayu - maybe after a time-slip where she returns to school/collage and graduates, at some point they'll have to cover exactly why she ran away, why her parents haven't logged a missing persons record and why no-one is looking for her (The flashback last episode gave some pretty grim impressions why - Rape/Suicide).

The Yoshida/Sayu red flags are already flying as they keep referring to Yoshida as an "Older Brother" figure more than father/guardian.

Or maybe looking after Sayu will change Yoshida and he'll grab what will make him happy and do something with it, rather than living to work and being almost a lock-in. Gotou & Misha have both spotted he's changed for the better since Sayu moved in, so he's already changed to be more desirable.


And what will happen when Sayu recovers her value and self worth enough for Yoshida to see her as an "Adult" rather than a "Child".

May 5, 2021 8:04 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:

Look, imo, I gave you some pretty good answers to your questions. I think that you are overthinking things too hard. We are talking about anime charachters here, I know that this is a serious topic, but their reactions/decisions are scripted and we can't do anything about it. They aren't real people that have constantly 1000 thoughts running trough their minds, they always know what to do because that's how the manga author made them to.

I can't tell you what Yoshida is thinking right now, because I didn't read the manga nor do I want to. That goes for you aswell if you didn't read it. All that you are saying is just speculation. Yoshida never gave a sign that he loves or wants to be with Sayu. So idk why you think that he has ulterior motives. The arguments you bring are just the way you think that the things happened. But in my eyes, things just go the way they should have to go. It is indeed weird the fact that Sayu is still in Yoshida's place after her meeting with 2 women... But I guess that not every adult wants to deal with a runaway child. It is illegal for both of them to have Sayu even though they are women and they probably don't want to take the risk like Yoshida did. Hence why he's a good guy.

I would do the same thing irl tbh. Obviously it wouldn't take that much since the parents would call police and the first step Sayu takes outside, she would get caught and would have to return home. This is an anime, keep this in mind. She would be caught on cameras entering my house the first day and ruin all her plans. This anime doesn't show 100% how reality is, that's how it's entertaining. A story like this would probably go different in real life.

I do not say that Sayu should learn EVERY single thing from Yoshida or Gotou or Mishima. They don't teach her every single thing about life either. I just said that she should atleast know that what she did is bad and that she should be taught some things that could 1. save her form self-destructing again. 2. how to actually live life and not waste it. (if you don't go to school, you should get a job. Like Yoshida taught her. Not beg for a place to stay from strangers in exchange for sex.) You should earn it trough hard work. Also, you should confront things with your parents. You shouldn't just run away before even setting things right with them. And other usefull things that a teenager should get from his parents. All of these are good lectures. Idk why you think that they teach her anything else besides this..

Sayu definetly wants to be with Yoshida, there's no denying in that. Like I said, I do want them to be togheter since I like both Yoshida and Sayu and I don't want her to be with some perverted teen that doesn't care at all about her again. I want her to get a good guy. But then I feel bad about Gotou. It's complicated.


I know this is anime, but, anime or not, if you are going to do something about a 17 year old screwing around to escape a situation at home, that is meant to be traumatic, it should be at least a bit thoughtful.

I am trying to understand the character of Yoshida. As you say, they aren't going to tell us everything that is going through their mind. So, when I watch him I wonder

Does he understand that Sayu is a young girl that can fall for him?
Does he want her to fall for him?
What will he do if she does?
What if she loses it if he rejects her?
Why would he do so much for stranger when there is so much risk involved?
It never crossed his mind that they could end up in a relationship?

The fact is, he isn't in any way in control in this situation. We don't need to know 1000 thoughts to see that. So, why is he doing it? Because he's a great guy? Risking his entire life?

Sayu should be sticking to her friend Asami as close as she can, and trying to learn from her. Someone who doesn't potentially have an ulterior motive, and I include Gotou here, in what is an adult situation. She's out of her depth with them. Asami is a good example and the best thing Yoshida has done was to tell Asami to be a friend for Sayu. After trying to lie to Asami, of course.

Asami, and more friends like her, is all Sayu needs to get herself back on track. Learning lessons from adults who have different priorities to her would be a mistake, even the nice ones. At the moment, Sayu hasn't learned anything and still has childish thoughts about being abandoned and what does she need to do to stay in the house. She's hardly progressed at all and only wants to please Yoshida and see where that gets her.

I don't care who Yoshida ends with, if he doesn't actually like Gotou enough it is better that they don't get together. But if he ends up with Sayu without her spending any time away from her it does feel a bit like grooming, she doesn't know anything. What she wants is only part of the issue while she remains so ignorant to how things work.

I agree, this is anime, but I thought the idea of this show was to provide some kind of food for thought. Wasted opportunity if it descends into harem nonsense.
May 5, 2021 9:16 AM
Offline
Feb 2020
522
for u guys who complain saying that "theres too many cliche,tropes etc"
let me remind u,that this is just a "drama,romance" probably should be "harem and shounen" too why? because its clearly for that target audience and exactly have the same problem.
if u know AOT(dont worry i wont spoil it) and higehiro have the same problem,its their "genre/target audience" that hold them back,both aot and higehiro has element that should be straight "seinen/adult",but no,they are on the genre/demographic of young audience,thats why their character isnt fleshed out/fully well written,because theres many thing stopping them(trope,cliche,mature content like nudity,violence,theme,message etc).
thats why in the end of the day,yoshida is still a HAREM PROTAGONIST,which is why he still dense toward his kouhai who clearly want his D so bad,despite most of the time yoshida is a "perfect normal adult should be",but later on back to the typical harem mc.its the same for the story too,the theme of this story and sayu problem are heavy and complicated,but because its not targeted for adult,author didnt dig deep to the topic,but stay as a "harem romance" at the end of the day.
May 5, 2021 10:11 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
714
So if he'd taken in a teenage boy - would everyone be screaming BL, Yaoi???


May 5, 2021 10:26 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

I know this is anime, but, anime or not, if you are going to do something about a 17 year old screwing around to escape a situation at home, that is meant to be traumatic, it should be at least a bit thoughtful.

I am trying to understand the character of Yoshida. As you say, they aren't going to tell us everything that is going through their mind. So, when I watch him I wonder

Does he understand that Sayu is a young girl that can fall for him?
Does he want her to fall for him?
What will he do if she does?
What if she loses it if he rejects her?
Why would he do so much for stranger when there is so much risk involved?
It never crossed his mind that they could end up in a relationship?

The fact is, he isn't in any way in control in this situation. We don't need to know 1000 thoughts to see that. So, why is he doing it? Because he's a great guy? Risking his entire life?

Sayu should be sticking to her friend Asami as close as she can, and trying to learn from her. Someone who doesn't potentially have an ulterior motive, and I include Gotou here, in what is an adult situation. She's out of her depth with them. Asami is a good example and the best thing Yoshida has done was to tell Asami to be a friend for Sayu. After trying to lie to Asami, of course.

Asami, and more friends like her, is all Sayu needs to get herself back on track. Learning lessons from adults who have different priorities to her would be a mistake, even the nice ones. At the moment, Sayu hasn't learned anything and still has childish thoughts about being abandoned and what does she need to do to stay in the house. She's hardly progressed at all and only wants to please Yoshida and see where that gets her.

I don't care who Yoshida ends with, if he doesn't actually like Gotou enough it is better that they don't get together. But if he ends up with Sayu without her spending any time away from her it does feel a bit like grooming, she doesn't know anything. What she wants is only part of the issue while she remains so ignorant to how things work.

I agree, this is anime, but I thought the idea of this show was to provide some kind of food for thought. Wasted opportunity if it descends into harem nonsense.


Hmm, I'm gonna answer some of your questions with what I think is a "right" answer and some facts.

Yoshida's character is pretty much easy to understand. He's a nice guy in general that does his job at work and is also pretty good at it. That's why Gotou likes Yoshida in the first place. If he wasn't like this, I doubt that Gotou would be interested. She said that she's only interested in him afterall. That means that there are a lot of workers there that don't meet her agenda. Which is also true in real life. You don't meet people as nice as Yoshida quite often.. He is named "The solutionist"or whatever by the higher ups, so that means that he helps a lot of colleagues, that's one of his jobs aswell. The way he reacts to Mishima is also meant to make her understand that she can't do so many mistakes. Anyway.

Does he understand that Sayu is a young girl that can fall for him?
--I mean, it's obvious to me that he does, he discussed this with both Gotou and Mishima and his friend at work. He's not dumb.

Does he want her to fall for him?
--From my perspective, a big NO. If he wanted to, he could've had sex with her when he wanted, or when SHE wanted. And also, he wouldn't get mad at her for undressing if he wanted that. He's an adult with his head on his shoulders, he likes girls like Gotou, not minors like Sayu.

What will he do if she does?
--At this moment in anime. He would most likely do what he did until now. Reject her with not even a wasted thought. He is aware that Sayu is naive and young. He also understands that she thinks that she can get whatever she wants with her body. Hence why she let her touch him and then immediatly reject and get mad at her.

What if she loses it if he rejects her?
--He already rejected her numerous times. I think that she got the idea that Yoshida is not interested in her or her body. She probably would try to get him to like her in different ways. Idk. I can't see the future.

Why would he do so much for stranger when there is so much risk involved?
--We gotta understand the fact that when he took her in, he was drunk beyond help. So, he already made a mistake by bringing her in. After hearing her story, he thought that it would be rude to rat her out if the girl doesn't feel safe/fine with returning home. He isn't grooming her like other people say, he just wants her to settle down a bit and calm down and realise what to do. He doesn't lecture her everyday, he barely even sees her at night when he comes home.


It never crossed his mind that they could end up in a relationship?
--I don't think so. He knows that Sayu is a minor. His morals are also pretty good. I don't think that Yoshida is the type to think of things like that, atleast atm. All he wants is for the girl to be happy again and slowly reenter normally in society and return home to confront her problems, rather than running again and doing the same mistakes.

He isn't in control of the situation but neither is anyone else, Sayu included. He just gave the girl what she wanted, a place to stay. Ofc, Yoshida doesn't want her to stay there forever, he just wants to be sure that she's alright and ready to go.

Asami recognized Yoshida as a good guardian, we also don't know what Asami is up to. Last time I checked, she knew that guy that made Sayu feel horrible. I don't think that another teenager is better than an adult at giving advices, etc. Yoshida has a nice stable job, compared to what Asami has.

I don't understand what you mean with priorities.. Everyone tries to save/help Sayu. They ofc have to go to their jobs. It would be stupid if they just quit just to help her more. She gets all the help she needs from Yoshida and his friends. I don't think that people her age would be better, they are probably doing some stupid mistake aswell. Two wrongs can't make a right. She has learned a lot, especially after she talked with Gotou, she got motivated to do the right thing.

Sayu knows a lot. She knew that what she was doing was wrong. Especially after doing it for so many times that she basically gave up on life. She's not that stupid. She doesn't remain ignorant, she made so much progress, why don't you see it?
She has a job now, she has finally a place where she doesn't have to pay with her body, she recently got motivated to confront her problems, she got advices from people that know what life is, how is she ignorant? The girl is doing her best.

This will never be a harem, Yoshida is not the person to have more girlfriends. The only one he likes and loves in a sexual way, is Gotou. He is too naive to understand Mishimas messages and he doesn't want to be with Sayu since she's a minor.
removed-userMay 5, 2021 10:35 AM
May 5, 2021 11:32 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:

Hmm, I'm gonna answer some of your questions with what I think is a "right" answer and some facts.

Yoshida's character is pretty much easy to understand. He's a nice guy in general that does his job at work and is also pretty good at it. That's why Gotou likes Yoshida in the first place. If he wasn't like this, I doubt that Gotou would be interested. She said that she's only interested in him afterall. That means that there are a lot of workers there that don't meet her agenda. Which is also true in real life. You don't meet people as nice as Yoshida quite often.. He is named "The solutionist"or whatever by the higher ups, so that means that he helps a lot of colleagues, that's one of his jobs aswell. The way he reacts to Mishima is also meant to make her understand that she can't do so many mistakes. Anyway.

Does he understand that Sayu is a young girl that can fall for him?
--I mean, it's obvious to me that he does, he discussed this with both Gotou and Mishima and his friend at work. He's not dumb.

Does he want her to fall for him?
--From my perspective, a big NO. If he wanted to, he could've had sex with her when he wanted, or when SHE wanted. And also, he wouldn't get mad at her for undressing if he wanted that. He's an adult with his head on his shoulders, he likes girls like Gotou, not minors like Sayu.

What will he do if she does?
--At this moment in anime. He would most likely do what he did until now. Reject her with not even a wasted thought. He is aware that Sayu is naive and young. He also understands that she thinks that she can get whatever she wants with her body. Hence why she let her touch him and then immediatly reject and get mad at her.

What if she loses it if he rejects her?
--He already rejected her numerous times. I think that she got the idea that Yoshida is not interested in her or her body. She probably would try to get him to like her in different ways. Idk. I can't see the future.

Why would he do so much for stranger when there is so much risk involved?
--We gotta understand the fact that when he took her in, he was drunk beyond help. So, he already made a mistake by bringing her in. After hearing her story, he thought that it would be rude to rat her out if the girl doesn't feel safe/fine with returning home. He isn't grooming her like other people say, he just wants her to settle down a bit and calm down and realise what to do. He doesn't lecture her everyday, he barely even sees her at night when he comes home.


It never crossed his mind that they could end up in a relationship?
--I don't think so. He knows that Sayu is a minor. His morals are also pretty good. I don't think that Yoshida is the type to think of things like that, atleast atm. All he wants is for the girl to be happy again and slowly reenter normally in society and return home to confront her problems, rather than running again and doing the same mistakes.

He isn't in control of the situation but neither is anyone else, Sayu included. He just gave the girl what she wanted, a place to stay. Ofc, Yoshida doesn't want her to stay there forever, he just wants to be sure that she's alright and ready to go.

Asami recognized Yoshida as a good guardian, we also don't know what Asami is up to. Last time I checked, she knew that guy that made Sayu feel horrible. I don't think that another teenager is better than an adult at giving advices, etc. Yoshida has a nice stable job, compared to what Asami has.

I don't understand what you mean with priorities.. Everyone tries to save/help Sayu. They ofc have to go to their jobs. It would be stupid if they just quit just to help her more. She gets all the help she needs from Yoshida and his friends. I don't think that people her age would be better, they are probably doing some stupid mistake aswell. Two wrongs can't make a right. She has learned a lot, especially after she talked with Gotou, she got motivated to do the right thing.

Sayu knows a lot. She knew that what she was doing was wrong. Especially after doing it for so many times that she basically gave up on life. She's not that stupid. She doesn't remain ignorant, she made so much progress, why don't you see it?
She has a job now, she has finally a place where she doesn't have to pay with her body, she recently got motivated to confront her problems, she got advices from people that know what life is, how is she ignorant? The girl is doing her best.

This will never be a harem, Yoshida is not the person to have more girlfriends. The only one he likes and loves in a sexual way, is Gotou. He is too naive to understand Mishimas messages and he doesn't want to be with Sayu since she's a minor.


Ok, I'll buy your answers about what a nice guy he is, the fact that he doesn't want a relationship with her and that he doesn't want her to fall for him.

But this is why I say he's too clever for his own good, he doesn't know that she ran from the flat to spy on him, or that she met Mishima because she was thinking of running away in case he didn't want her there anymore. It is dangerous for him to think he knows everything. Despite what he has said, Sayu hasn't given up on him.

She's still a stranger and he doesn't know if she is lying to him or not. So far, she just seems to be at home doing chores, I don't see how she is learning anything. She is learning more from her job.

I'm not sure, a girl the same age who is doing better than Sayu would be a better bet than a 26 year old man for giving advice to Sayu, I think.

Priorities, they are all breaking the law or accessories to someone who is breaking the law, Yoshida has put them all in a dangerous situation. Sayu is still thinking about running if she thinks Yoshida has any plans of getting a girlfriend and 'replacing her'. Or, rather, pushing her out. She already sees it as her vs any potential girlfriend, why do you think she keeps freaking out when he meets someone? She said she would support him with Gotou but she clearly doesn't support him with anyone. Has he even considered that? Mishima asked him and he is clueless. That is what I mean by priorities, they are all taking big risks and Yoshida and Sayu are just going through this without thinking it through properly.

The last two points you made, they remain to be seen. Anyway, I am glad you are enjoying the show, it isn't the best thing I've ever seen but it gives plenty of food for thought, which is what any decent entertainment is meant to do, i think. Any show that has so many differing views about what should happen can't be all bad.

May 5, 2021 12:49 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

Ok, I'll buy your answers about what a nice guy he is, the fact that he doesn't want a relationship with her and that he doesn't want her to fall for him.

But this is why I say he's too clever for his own good, he doesn't know that she ran from the flat to spy on him, or that she met Mishima because she was thinking of running away in case he didn't want her there anymore. It is dangerous for him to think he knows everything. Despite what he has said, Sayu hasn't given up on him.

She's still a stranger and he doesn't know if she is lying to him or not. So far, she just seems to be at home doing chores, I don't see how she is learning anything. She is learning more from her job.

I'm not sure, a girl the same age who is doing better than Sayu would be a better bet than a 26 year old man for giving advice to Sayu, I think.

Priorities, they are all breaking the law or accessories to someone who is breaking the law, Yoshida has put them all in a dangerous situation. Sayu is still thinking about running if she thinks Yoshida has any plans of getting a girlfriend and 'replacing her'. Or, rather, pushing her out. She already sees it as her vs any potential girlfriend, why do you think she keeps freaking out when he meets someone? She said she would support him with Gotou but she clearly doesn't support him with anyone. Has he even considered that? Mishima asked him and he is clueless. That is what I mean by priorities, they are all taking big risks and Yoshida and Sayu are just going through this without thinking it through properly.

The last two points you made, they remain to be seen. Anyway, I am glad you are enjoying the show, it isn't the best thing I've ever seen but it gives plenty of food for thought, which is what any decent entertainment is meant to do, i think. Any show that has so many differing views about what should happen can't be all bad.


Oh God. Don't take this as negative. I didn't say "Oh God" because I don't like what you write or that I'm bored. But the way you think of things, sounds like you are young, I don't want to say teenager because I may be rude if you are not one.

So, Yoshida is indeed a clever guy, but not clever in the way you think he is. He obviously couldn't have known that Sayu left the flat to spy on him. Who would know that? I for certain wouldn't think of that happening. But this is anime, and she arrived at the perfect time "When she hugged him" and also left at the perfect time "Before he pushed her away". You can't really bring too much logic in anime, you will get nowhere.

Sayu likes Yoshida because he is different. He is an angel compared to the other guys she had to put up with. He also helps her very much. He has a stable job. He's intelligent. Handsome. Who wouldn't date this guy? No wonder so many girls like him. I'm a guy and I respect him aswell. So of course that she is afraid of losing him to another girl. But Yoshida doesn't see Sayu as someone he would go out with on a date. He also doesn't have that much experience with love. So ofc that he can't understand everything that Sayu feels about him.


Yes, Sayu did chores until she got a job and a new friend, and?
People that go trough so many problems and so much stress, feel relieved when they take a pause from that toxic environment. Hence why Sayu left home and school. To run away from her problems.

Her being at home and doing chores, cooking for someone who cares and helps her, washing for someone who gave her a place to stay, cleaning for someone who comes late after working his ass off, the whole day. This is a nice break and at the same time a nice feeling/experience for Sayu that she probably never had at home. It's exactly what Sayu wanted, to do things for someone who cares about her. She wanted someone to care about her like Yoshida does. And that's why her love of him grows in a way that even she doesn't realise sometimes.

I do not know why you still think that an 16/17 yr old teenager can give better advice than an 28 yr old women, and a 26 yr old man can. Have you seen what teenagers do nowadays? With TikTok and stuff. I'd never take advice from a teen compared to an adult these days, only if I find it reasonable and right. That's kinda why I think that you're young and a little bit naive aswell. Don't get me wrong, if they were some trash people that didn't have jobs or the wisdom to get a place to stay in, I would understand, but this isn't the case. They are adults, with stable jobs and homes, a stable life, and a very good mindset and personalities and are very nice people in general. I can't think of better people to help a naive teenager that lost its way in todays society's expectations. Do you know how many teenagers and adults are out there who would laugh at her stories? You would be surprised that there is even someone who would take this as a joke and not serious. She's really lucky that they crossed paths. Otherwise, she would still be having sex with some douchebag.

Yoshida didn't put anyone in a dangerous situation. Their friends could rat them out at any moment, but they chose not to. That means that they put themselves in those situations. Yoshida didn't want Gotou to meet Sayu, but she wanted to anyway, she knew that his story didn't add up and she still wanted to check, how did Yoshida make her do any of this ? He thought that she didn't care much about him no long ago because that's literally the vibe she was giving. Mishima wouldn't get in trouble, since she didn't do much anyway.

Sayu doesn't freak out when Yoshida meets people. She freaks out when she hears that he's out with some girl. Because she loves Yoshida. Her reactions are to be expected, but a little exaggerated with the spy stuff...But it's understandable if she doesn't want to lose him. But then she talks about leaving and stuff because she thinks that she's bothering him. You see now why I say that she's naive and young? She can't decide what's right even when she knows that staying there is better than on the streets.


And now, on a serious note. My guy Yoshida gave Sayu all the help she needed, along with his friends. Why would he bother himself to also solve the problems she's creating right now by her trying to seduce him? Let's be real here, the girl should understand that he took her only to save her from that toxic lifestyle and give insight on what should be done next. Not to make her his bride. Sayu is a handfull. But Yoshida and her aswell, are trying their best. Yoshida tries to help her in a way that he doesn't break/cross any boundaries. I said this already, Yeah it's illegal what he is doing, but not immorall. It depends where you put more value in. Your life? Or saving someone else's life and also trying not to cause anything problematic in your life, even though it's risky as hell.

And final note, If someone cried like Sayu cried and acted like she did in all of those episodes, I would 100% believe that what they've been trough and their stories are real. I'm pretty sure that Yoshida knows that Sayu said the truth. It's not everyday that you meet a teenager late at night on the streets asking you to let them in your apartment in exchange for sex.


removed-userMay 5, 2021 2:26 PM
May 5, 2021 2:19 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
2131
My NTR senses are tingling...
yup that's the guy at the beginning of ep3. He bangs Sayu senseless until he passes out from exhaustion. If what I've seen from NTR themed anime is that the guy probably has some leverage on Sayu to coerce her into doing what the guy wants (pictures & video) perhaps. Will Sayu be able to overcome the possible blackmail the guy might pull? Maybe he'll just go for it and force his way to shock Sayu back into what she was. This is will test her progress as an individual trying to overcome her trauma. Maybe she'll succumb to the temptation and revert back to her promiscuous ways because deep down her mind broke a long time ago because she's already a pervert.
"Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum.
They should really do their whining at manga forums.


USERS ON MY IGNORED LIST:
RayReynolds - SSL443 - Dr4kon - Nerdanimefan1992 - ToTheMountains - Fiveskies
To add users to the Ignore list: (1) Go to Account settings (2) Click Forum tab and toggle down (3) Type or paste user name on entry box (4) Click Add and you're done.
Problem solved, you'll never have to see someone trolling ever again because their post will be closed/collapsed.
May 5, 2021 8:20 PM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:


Oh God. Don't take this as negative. I didn't say "Oh God" because I don't like what you write or that I'm bored. But the way you think of things, sounds like you are young, I don't want to say teenager because I may be rude if you are not one.

So, Yoshida is indeed a clever guy, but not clever in the way you think he is. He obviously couldn't have known that Sayu left the flat to spy on him. Who would know that? I for certain wouldn't think of that happening. But this is anime, and she arrived at the perfect time "When she hugged him" and also left at the perfect time "Before he pushed her away". You can't really bring too much logic in anime, you will get nowhere.

Sayu likes Yoshida because he is different. He is an angel compared to the other guys she had to put up with. He also helps her very much. He has a stable job. He's intelligent. Handsome. Who wouldn't date this guy? No wonder so many girls like him. I'm a guy and I respect him aswell. So of course that she is afraid of losing him to another girl. But Yoshida doesn't see Sayu as someone he would go out with on a date. He also doesn't have that much experience with love. So ofc that he can't understand everything that Sayu feels about him.


Yes, Sayu did chores until she got a job and a new friend, and?
People that go trough so many problems and so much stress, feel relieved when they take a pause from that toxic environment. Hence why Sayu left home and school. To run away from her problems.

Her being at home and doing chores, cooking for someone who cares and helps her, washing for someone who gave her a place to stay, cleaning for someone who comes late after working his ass off, the whole day. This is a nice break and at the same time a nice feeling/experience for Sayu that she probably never had at home. It's exactly what Sayu wanted, to do things for someone who cares about her. She wanted someone to care about her like Yoshida does. And that's why her love of him grows in a way that even she doesn't realise sometimes.

I do not know why you still think that an 16/17 yr old teenager can give better advice than an 28 yr old women, and a 26 yr old man can. Have you seen what teenagers do nowadays? With TikTok and stuff. I'd never take advice from a teen compared to an adult these days, only if I find it reasonable and right. That's kinda why I think that you're young and a little bit naive aswell. Don't get me wrong, if they were some trash people that didn't have jobs or the wisdom to get a place to stay in, I would understand, but this isn't the case. They are adults, with stable jobs and homes, a stable life, and a very good mindset and personalities and are very nice people in general. I can't think of better people to help a naive teenager that lost its way in todays society's expectations. Do you know how many teenagers and adults are out there who would laugh at her stories? You would be surprised that there is even someone who would take this as a joke and not serious. She's really lucky that they crossed paths. Otherwise, she would still be having sex with some douchebag.

Yoshida didn't put anyone in a dangerous situation. Their friends could rat them out at any moment, but they chose not to. That means that they put themselves in those situations. Yoshida didn't want Gotou to meet Sayu, but she wanted to anyway, she knew that his story didn't add up and she still wanted to check, how did Yoshida make her do any of this ? He thought that she didn't care much about him no long ago because that's literally the vibe she was giving. Mishima wouldn't get in trouble, since she didn't do much anyway.

Sayu doesn't freak out when Yoshida meets people. She freaks out when she hears that he's out with some girl. Because she loves Yoshida. Her reactions are to be expected, but a little exaggerated with the spy stuff...But it's understandable if she doesn't want to lose him. But then she talks about leaving and stuff because she thinks that she's bothering him. You see now why I say that she's naive and young? She can't decide what's right even when she knows that staying there is better than on the streets.


And now, on a serious note. My guy Yoshida gave Sayu all the help she needed, along with his friends. Why would he bother himself to also solve the problems she's creating right now by her trying to seduce him? Let's be real here, the girl should understand that he took her only to save her from that toxic lifestyle and give insight on what should be done next. Not to make her his bride. Sayu is a handfull. But Yoshida and her aswell, are trying their best. Yoshida tries to help her in a way that he doesn't break/cross any boundaries. I said this already, Yeah it's illegal what he is doing, but not immorall. It depends where you put more value in. Your life? Or saving someone else's life and also trying not to cause anything problematic in your life, even though it's risky as hell.

And final note, If someone cried like Sayu cried and acted like she did in all of those episodes, I would 100% believe that what they've been trough and their stories are real. I'm pretty sure that Yoshida knows that Sayu said the truth. It's not everyday that you meet a teenager late at night on the streets asking you to let them in your apartment in exchange for sex.


Well, I'm certainly not a teenager, but I'm not going to take offence about anything like that. We all have different takes on different things and come across in different ways at different times, it isn't a problem.

Sure, it is anime, but I hope they will go down a more realistic route with this story, the things that he is not seeing, that he cannot know, are still potentially dangerous for him. What if someone else finds her wandering around the street and they don't buy her lies about what she is doing there? Her behaviour doesn't strike me as someone who has bought into what Yoshida has told her.

Fine, I will go with that, he is a nice guy and people like him. But as long as his feelings and Sayu's are not aligned, there is a potential problem. As long as he doesn't understand that she hasn't given up on seducing him, she is just looking for another way of doing it, he has a problem. And everyone connected to him can get dragged into it.

She's 17, she shouldn't be staying in someone else's house like a housewife. She knows he is nice and it is better than what she has experienced up to now. But, as she has been told, she will only be a high school girl once and she should be living her life like a high school girl, not cleaning a salaryman's clothes and cooking him dinner. Of course she prefers life with him, because she doesn't know any better. That is sad.

Actually, I'm not a teenager, I have a friend who has a young daughter and even at her age, the stuff they come out with is terrifying. But Asami clearly has her head screwed on and Yoshida has met her. She's even given Yoshida a warning about not letting Sayu's smiles trick him. She's a good role model and would know about things more appropriate for Sayu than Yoshida does. His understanding of that life is really limited. If I had to look after my friend's daughter, it would be video games, anime and that would be it. The rest would be a total mystery for me. Asami is a perfect opportunity for Sayu to see things from the point of view of someone her age who is doing things in the right way. Yoshida acknowledged this.

Oh, for sure, a lot of people wouldn't take her situation seriously and dismiss it, Yoshida did not. But I am presuming his plan was to help her and send her home. I wonder if he is still sticking to that plan or if it has changed, as Mishima asked. There's a limit to how much he can help her and the rest she needs to learn to help herself.

Gotou is certainly an accesory, Mishima probably less so, because she can say that she believed that Sayu was a relative. I suppose Gotou could as well. But if a scandal broke out, they could all be involved. And the harem situation means that any of them could break ranks at any time and give Yoshida some real problems. At this point, Sayu probably wouldn't, but can he trust Gotou or Mishima that much? Two women who are interested in him? They haven't been portrayed as people who would sell him out but would anyone want to be at their mercy? Particularly if they themselves are worried about being implicated in a cover up.

Her freaking out and worrying, and she has jumped the gun twice already, is a potential problem. As Gotou said, what if she loses it when he starts seeing someone else? What if she starts turning up at his office or coming to the bar he is drinking at? There is a real danger that things could unravel. Can Yoshida control her to make sure that doesn't happen? I'm not sure. Until she can honestly say she supports Yoshida with someone else, she really is a potential timebomb. She's had a stressful life and now she meets a great guy who she is starting to love. At first she was playing around with him and now she is starting to feel jealous. He isn't seeing that, red alert!!

Totally with you there, illegal but not immoral. I'm not sure that the law will see the distinction, though.

Agreed, of course he believes her because what she said to him was so obviously heartfelt and she didn't have any filters. Why would anyone lie about those things? But he still doesn't understand everything.

I'm certainly not a teenager, I had a junior at work who ran away from home and asked to stay with me. Not the same as this because they were from the same city and they knew I had a girlfriend already, who used to meet us for work drinks. But her family used to park outside my flat and watch to see how she was entering and leaving my flat. Eventually I talked to her brother and they had seen her coming back with me and my girlfriend and they were happy because they knew she was safe. Funny thing was, she went home and then decided to go to a seaside town in the north of england with some friends, met some guys up there and ended up pregnant. Me and my girlfriend ended up taking her to an abortion clinic that she never told her family about. So these things are never clear cut. Now, if my girlfriend hadn't been staying with me nearly every night, there is no way that I would have gone near that situation. But, as it happened. she ended up being safer in my flat than with her parents. So, this show is quite interesting to me because it reminds me about something that happened and how there is no right answer to these things. But the main thing is for the guardian to make sure they are helping the person, getting into a relationship with them is really a no no in my opinion. But if Sayu goes home and starts to learn things for herself and comes back to Yoshida after some time, then fine.

I think the next few episodes are going to be interesting and will tell us more about where Sayu's head is at.

Still, it is an interesting topic and, as you can see, it has certainly got people fired up!!



Gab5May 5, 2021 8:27 PM
May 5, 2021 9:40 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10505
Gab5 said:

She's 17, she shouldn't be staying in someone else's house like a housewife. She knows he is nice and it is better than what she has experienced up to now. But, as she has been told, she will only be a high school girl once and she should be living her life like a high school girl, not cleaning a salaryman's clothes and cooking him dinner. Of course she prefers life with him, because she doesn't know any better. That is sad.


Well, I do think the show is WELL aware of that...which is why the author wrote Gotou's scene the way they did and why Sayu thanked her for telling her to face reality.

I would say Sayu prefers life with Yoshida because she feels more comfortable there compared to her home (we don't know the reasons yet) but even with Yoshida, the past isn't erased. She's still haunted by it and she knows she has to go back.

She has every intention of going back. She just needed to get away for a little while because it was ruining her mental health (I guess)



May 5, 2021 9:51 PM

Offline
Jul 2014
749
That Gotou-san is a snake man. She's really good at pulling off the player persona
May 6, 2021 2:48 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

Well, I'm certainly not a teenager, but I'm not going to take offence about anything like that. We all have different takes on different things and come across in different ways at different times, it isn't a problem.

Sure, it is anime, but I hope they will go down a more realistic route with this story, the things that he is not seeing, that he cannot know, are still potentially dangerous for him. What if someone else finds her wandering around the street and they don't buy her lies about what she is doing there? Her behaviour doesn't strike me as someone who has bought into what Yoshida has told her.

Fine, I will go with that, he is a nice guy and people like him. But as long as his feelings and Sayu's are not aligned, there is a potential problem. As long as he doesn't understand that she hasn't given up on seducing him, she is just looking for another way of doing it, he has a problem. And everyone connected to him can get dragged into it.

She's 17, she shouldn't be staying in someone else's house like a housewife. She knows he is nice and it is better than what she has experienced up to now. But, as she has been told, she will only be a high school girl once and she should be living her life like a high school girl, not cleaning a salaryman's clothes and cooking him dinner. Of course she prefers life with him, because she doesn't know any better. That is sad.

Actually, I'm not a teenager, I have a friend who has a young daughter and even at her age, the stuff they come out with is terrifying. But Asami clearly has her head screwed on and Yoshida has met her. She's even given Yoshida a warning about not letting Sayu's smiles trick him. She's a good role model and would know about things more appropriate for Sayu than Yoshida does. His understanding of that life is really limited. If I had to look after my friend's daughter, it would be video games, anime and that would be it. The rest would be a total mystery for me. Asami is a perfect opportunity for Sayu to see things from the point of view of someone her age who is doing things in the right way. Yoshida acknowledged this.

Oh, for sure, a lot of people wouldn't take her situation seriously and dismiss it, Yoshida did not. But I am presuming his plan was to help her and send her home. I wonder if he is still sticking to that plan or if it has changed, as Mishima asked. There's a limit to how much he can help her and the rest she needs to learn to help herself.

Gotou is certainly an accesory, Mishima probably less so, because she can say that she believed that Sayu was a relative. I suppose Gotou could as well. But if a scandal broke out, they could all be involved. And the harem situation means that any of them could break ranks at any time and give Yoshida some real problems. At this point, Sayu probably wouldn't, but can he trust Gotou or Mishima that much? Two women who are interested in him? They haven't been portrayed as people who would sell him out but would anyone want to be at their mercy? Particularly if they themselves are worried about being implicated in a cover up.

Her freaking out and worrying, and she has jumped the gun twice already, is a potential problem. As Gotou said, what if she loses it when he starts seeing someone else? What if she starts turning up at his office or coming to the bar he is drinking at? There is a real danger that things could unravel. Can Yoshida control her to make sure that doesn't happen? I'm not sure. Until she can honestly say she supports Yoshida with someone else, she really is a potential timebomb. She's had a stressful life and now she meets a great guy who she is starting to love. At first she was playing around with him and now she is starting to feel jealous. He isn't seeing that, red alert!!

Totally with you there, illegal but not immoral. I'm not sure that the law will see the distinction, though.

Agreed, of course he believes her because what she said to him was so obviously heartfelt and she didn't have any filters. Why would anyone lie about those things? But he still doesn't understand everything.

I'm certainly not a teenager, I had a junior at work who ran away from home and asked to stay with me. Not the same as this because they were from the same city and they knew I had a girlfriend already, who used to meet us for work drinks. But her family used to park outside my flat and watch to see how she was entering and leaving my flat. Eventually I talked to her brother and they had seen her coming back with me and my girlfriend and they were happy because they knew she was safe. Funny thing was, she went home and then decided to go to a seaside town in the north of england with some friends, met some guys up there and ended up pregnant. Me and my girlfriend ended up taking her to an abortion clinic that she never told her family about. So these things are never clear cut. Now, if my girlfriend hadn't been staying with me nearly every night, there is no way that I would have gone near that situation. But, as it happened. she ended up being safer in my flat than with her parents. So, this show is quite interesting to me because it reminds me about something that happened and how there is no right answer to these things. But the main thing is for the guardian to make sure they are helping the person, getting into a relationship with them is really a no no in my opinion. But if Sayu goes home and starts to learn things for herself and comes back to Yoshida after some time, then fine.

I think the next few episodes are going to be interesting and will tell us more about where Sayu's head is at.

Still, it is an interesting topic and, as you can see, it has certainly got people fired up!!


Look, you are overthinking things way too much.

The fact that Sayu stays now in Yoshidas flat isn't as bad as you say it is. She does chores, which not many people do, for example Yoshida, but since she's a girl she maybe cares more about hygiene? idk. She also goes to a job and has a friend. I think that we can all agree that those are things that she would do at home aswell. We also can not forget the fact that Sayu is slowly reentering society and it's expectations. She starts with small steps, the tips that Yoshida gave her. Having a job and doing chores is the exact same thing a teenager would have to do at home if they don't want to finish school. You can't just sit on your phone/pc and be a nobody. In our case though, Sayu really wants to confront her past and problems and return to her home and to school. Which is nice. Not all people have the strength to do so.

You seem to associate a lot of harmless things that can get solved easily with a serious talk or just some advice, to a potentially very harmfull situation. I don't get why. Everyone in the anime is mature enough to understand things if explained or if they're shown that they are wrong. No one is going to kill themselves for anything here.


She is 17, yes, but she isn't the housewife of anyone. The poor girl wanted a place to stay in to just run away from her toxic life at school and family. She does chores, etc, because that's her payment for staying in someone's house for free. Would you like it better if they had sex instead? Mhm, I didn't think so. She isn't meant to stay there forever. Both Yoshida and Gotou want Sayu to be able to function in society and be ready for what may come. The problem with teens like these that run from home and especially do ultra dumb things like sleeping with strangers for staying in their apartment rent free, are probably going to do it again if not helped until a certain point. Yoshida and everyone else, me included, are afraid that if Sayu leaves without enough things learned and a pause from her past life, she would probably get to her old toxic way of living, which doesn't sit well with any of us. Just leave the girl in Yoshida's hands for a while, he's a nice guy, intelligent and can definetly be her guardian.

Her freaking out and so on, is indeed a potential problem, I agree, judging by her history with running away from problems, it can get bad. But I don't think that such things would happen again, not only do I think that Yoshida wouldn't put Sayu in a situation like that where she gets sad because he gets a new girlfriend, but the fact that they already talked about it and from my point of view, it was kinda helpfull. I can't see the future so I can't be 100% sure.


I don't care that Asami knew about her smile being fake, or that Gotou told him that she can't stay there forever, I don't understand how you didn't realise that Yoshida recognized her fake smile from the beggining of the anime, he even got mad at her and told her to stop faking her smile. What Asami said was already old news for Yoshida, same goes with Gotou. He knows about Sayu way more than Asami and Gotou do and way better I would say.
The poor guy knows all these things, it's just that some people think it's better to remind others sometimes about certain things, that doesn't mean that they don't know them already, it just means that there are people that forget about their morals and do stupid things.. In our case though, Yoshida is not one to do such things.

I stand by my point and choose Yoshida any day over Asami or any other human being. Also, I don't think that being a store clerk is a "role model" in todays society, excuse me if someone is a clerk somewhere, but I think that they can agree aswell, it's not meant to say that store clerks are bad, it's just not a job you would think as a "role model" in life. Like I said, she also knows the guy that made Sayu feel horrible, I wouldn't trust her with my life.
Meanwhile our protagonist has a stable job with a cheap apartment even though he can buy himself better things and a better house, he chose to spare some money for something better, we know that he is a nice guy in general, intelligent and hard working. Now, this is what I would call a "role model". Asami wouldn't even have the money to buy Sayu a phone, which is crucial nowadays, she is also a teen, she has to take care of herself first, and then to take care of Sayu aswell? What if Sayu is getting raped and she calls Asami to come fast? If she goes there, she would get raped aswell. You can call the police but if they don't know where she is, or arrive too late, it's bad. I don't think that this could go right in any shape or form. But it's not my job to change your view so it's okay if you think otherwise.

So judging by what you said in your story, if the girl stayed with you and your girlfriend for a while, rather than with her parents, she wouldn't have to make an abortion, right? Then why are you so pissed at the fact that she stays with a nice guy that wouldn't let something like that happen? She is in good hands and I think that she isn't overextending her stay. She needs this whole time to recover from what she had to put up with in the past. It's just simple psychology, some people need more time, some don't, it depends, in our case Sayu saw some f-ed up shit and did something even worse not long ago before she met Yoshida, I won't give any spoilers though so dw, I don't know the whole story anyway, just some things.


You will hate the guy in the last scene though, that's for sure, and you will like Yoshida, probably, idk. I also want to see how their relationship and her mental health develops in the next episodes.


removed-userMay 6, 2021 2:57 AM
May 6, 2021 3:36 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
714
Asami isn't just a teenage store clerk, She's Sayu's same age role model. As will become clear soon. Asami has her own issues and baggage she's dealing with.

Sayu will become stronger and heal as her support bubble becomes larger and she gets more contacts in the phone. She'll also have to face her past and make painful decisions - the first of which will probably be the next episode.







May 6, 2021 3:53 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Chiibi said:
Gab5 said:

She's 17, she shouldn't be staying in someone else's house like a housewife. She knows he is nice and it is better than what she has experienced up to now. But, as she has been told, she will only be a high school girl once and she should be living her life like a high school girl, not cleaning a salaryman's clothes and cooking him dinner. Of course she prefers life with him, because she doesn't know any better. That is sad.


Well, I do think the show is WELL aware of that...which is why the author wrote Gotou's scene the way they did and why Sayu thanked her for telling her to face reality.

I would say Sayu prefers life with Yoshida because she feels more comfortable there compared to her home (we don't know the reasons yet) but even with Yoshida, the past isn't erased. She's still haunted by it and she knows she has to go back.

She has every intention of going back. She just needed to get away for a little while because it was ruining her mental health (I guess)


I wonder if the show knows that. Let's wait and see how they wrap it up. If Sayu and Yoshida end up together, without her spending a significant amount of time at home,is that the message they were giving at the beginning?

Of course she feels more comfortable there. But does she feel comfortable with him having a girlfriend? And if she is starting to have romantic feelings for Yoshida do people really think she's disciplined enough to decide to go home and not just ride it out until she's 18? Yoshida really is pretty naive.
May 6, 2021 5:27 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:

Look, you are overthinking things way too much.

The fact that Sayu stays now in Yoshidas flat isn't as bad as you say it is. She does chores, which not many people do, for example Yoshida, but since she's a girl she maybe cares more about hygiene? idk. She also goes to a job and has a friend. I think that we can all agree that those are things that she would do at home aswell. We also can not forget the fact that Sayu is slowly reentering society and it's expectations. She starts with small steps, the tips that Yoshida gave her. Having a job and doing chores is the exact same thing a teenager would have to do at home if they don't want to finish school. You can't just sit on your phone/pc and be a nobody. In our case though, Sayu really wants to confront her past and problems and return to her home and to school. Which is nice. Not all people have the strength to do so.

You seem to associate a lot of harmless things that can get solved easily with a serious talk or just some advice, to a potentially very harmfull situation. I don't get why. Everyone in the anime is mature enough to understand things if explained or if they're shown that they are wrong. No one is going to kill themselves for anything here.


She is 17, yes, but she isn't the housewife of anyone. The poor girl wanted a place to stay in to just run away from her toxic life at school and family. She does chores, etc, because that's her payment for staying in someone's house for free. Would you like it better if they had sex instead? Mhm, I didn't think so. She isn't meant to stay there forever. Both Yoshida and Gotou want Sayu to be able to function in society and be ready for what may come. The problem with teens like these that run from home and especially do ultra dumb things like sleeping with strangers for staying in their apartment rent free, are probably going to do it again if not helped until a certain point. Yoshida and everyone else, me included, are afraid that if Sayu leaves without enough things learned and a pause from her past life, she would probably get to her old toxic way of living, which doesn't sit well with any of us. Just leave the girl in Yoshida's hands for a while, he's a nice guy, intelligent and can definetly be her guardian.

Her freaking out and so on, is indeed a potential problem, I agree, judging by her history with running away from problems, it can get bad. But I don't think that such things would happen again, not only do I think that Yoshida wouldn't put Sayu in a situation like that where she gets sad because he gets a new girlfriend, but the fact that they already talked about it and from my point of view, it was kinda helpfull. I can't see the future so I can't be 100% sure.


I don't care that Asami knew about her smile being fake, or that Gotou told him that she can't stay there forever, I don't understand how you didn't realise that Yoshida recognized her fake smile from the beggining of the anime, he even got mad at her and told her to stop faking her smile. What Asami said was already old news for Yoshida, same goes with Gotou. He knows about Sayu way more than Asami and Gotou do and way better I would say.
The poor guy knows all these things, it's just that some people think it's better to remind others sometimes about certain things, that doesn't mean that they don't know them already, it just means that there are people that forget about their morals and do stupid things.. In our case though, Yoshida is not one to do such things.

I stand by my point and choose Yoshida any day over Asami or any other human being. Also, I don't think that being a store clerk is a "role model" in todays society, excuse me if someone is a clerk somewhere, but I think that they can agree aswell, it's not meant to say that store clerks are bad, it's just not a job you would think as a "role model" in life. Like I said, she also knows the guy that made Sayu feel horrible, I wouldn't trust her with my life.
Meanwhile our protagonist has a stable job with a cheap apartment even though he can buy himself better things and a better house, he chose to spare some money for something better, we know that he is a nice guy in general, intelligent and hard working. Now, this is what I would call a "role model". Asami wouldn't even have the money to buy Sayu a phone, which is crucial nowadays, she is also a teen, she has to take care of herself first, and then to take care of Sayu aswell? What if Sayu is getting raped and she calls Asami to come fast? If she goes there, she would get raped aswell. You can call the police but if they don't know where she is, or arrive too late, it's bad. I don't think that this could go right in any shape or form. But it's not my job to change your view so it's okay if you think otherwise.

So judging by what you said in your story, if the girl stayed with you and your girlfriend for a while, rather than with her parents, she wouldn't have to make an abortion, right? Then why are you so pissed at the fact that she stays with a nice guy that wouldn't let something like that happen? She is in good hands and I think that she isn't overextending her stay. She needs this whole time to recover from what she had to put up with in the past. It's just simple psychology, some people need more time, some don't, it depends, in our case Sayu saw some f-ed up shit and did something even worse not long ago before she met Yoshida, I won't give any spoilers though so dw, I don't know the whole story anyway, just some things.


You will hate the guy in the last scene though, that's for sure, and you will like Yoshida, probably, idk. I also want to see how their relationship and her mental health develops in the next episodes.




I think this show, despite being anime, is intended to make people think. Otherwise, the subject matter is just gratuitous and not really worth covering. Agree about the tasks and her getting a job and getting to know people, not convinced about how much she really wants to confront her past yet.

Because a 26 year old guy and a fragile 17 year has the potential to create a lot of problems, what they are doing is against the law, of course it is potentially harmful. It isn't just his work colleagues, what if someone at the store starts asking questions? The new guy?

In reality, the thing to do is hand her over to the authorities. If it wasn't the right call, society would realise that there are many Yoshidas out there that will take care of things. Yoshida can't watch her 24/7 and we will see what can happen as a result reasonably soon.

I think the issue of whether Sayu accepts a partner for Yoshida or not is central to everything. As you say, I don't know how this is going to go, but I don't think the signs are good so far. She still needs to do a lot of growing up before that happens and he is putting his life on hold. Regardless of the risks, why is he doing that? Is that an admission that he doesn't really love Gotou, looks that way. As it happens, she has accepted Sayu, but the fact that he was prepared to take that risk doesn't make me fancy her chances.

Yoshida recongised one fake smile, not many fake smiles. I think that a girl her age would notice a lot more than him.

Asami isn't just a store clerk, though. Practical stuff, Yoshida can help her, of course. Mental stuff, Asami is the best one to support Sayu.

Actually, that story had no bearing on what i thought was right or wrong here, it only explained my interest in the story. My jumior's parents couldn't watch her 24/7 any more than my girlfriend and i could. Although it was a disaster, I'm just glad it happened after she went home, as i could just imagine the blame getting thrown around if it had happened while she was at my place. No one can guarantee anything, but if something happens to Sayu under Yoshida's care, he will take the blame. The other difference is that my girlfriend was also around, which helped a lot. Nothing would have happened even if she wasn't but that is not how others would have looked at it. Other people's opinions, especially when someone else is under age, do matter, whether you are doing things with good intent or not.

The guy in the next episode is an interesting one and will take us back to the point of what is reasonable and what is not. But what I will say is that he isn't Yoshida's age. Sayu's reaction to him, and what people think that means, will be interesting.
May 6, 2021 7:03 AM

Offline
May 2014
114
Great episode overall. That ending though....

Was it only me or were the animation a bit choppy?
May 6, 2021 7:21 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
562355
Gab5 said:

I think this show, despite being anime, is intended to make people think. Otherwise, the subject matter is just gratuitous and not really worth covering. Agree about the tasks and her getting a job and getting to know people, not convinced about how much she really wants to confront her past yet.

Because a 26 year old guy and a fragile 17 year has the potential to create a lot of problems, what they are doing is against the law, of course it is potentially harmful. It isn't just his work colleagues, what if someone at the store starts asking questions? The new guy?

In reality, the thing to do is hand her over to the authorities. If it wasn't the right call, society would realise that there are many Yoshidas out there that will take care of things. Yoshida can't watch her 24/7 and we will see what can happen as a result reasonably soon.

I think the issue of whether Sayu accepts a partner for Yoshida or not is central to everything. As you say, I don't know how this is going to go, but I don't think the signs are good so far. She still needs to do a lot of growing up before that happens and he is putting his life on hold. Regardless of the risks, why is he doing that? Is that an admission that he doesn't really love Gotou, looks that way. As it happens, she has accepted Sayu, but the fact that he was prepared to take that risk doesn't make me fancy her chances.

Yoshida recongised one fake smile, not many fake smiles. I think that a girl her age would notice a lot more than him.

Asami isn't just a store clerk, though. Practical stuff, Yoshida can help her, of course. Mental stuff, Asami is the best one to support Sayu.

Actually, that story had no bearing on what i thought was right or wrong here, it only explained my interest in the story. My jumior's parents couldn't watch her 24/7 any more than my girlfriend and i could. Although it was a disaster, I'm just glad it happened after she went home, as i could just imagine the blame getting thrown around if it had happened while she was at my place. No one can guarantee anything, but if something happens to Sayu under Yoshida's care, he will take the blame. The other difference is that my girlfriend was also around, which helped a lot. Nothing would have happened even if she wasn't but that is not how others would have looked at it. Other people's opinions, especially when someone else is under age, do matter, whether you are doing things with good intent or not.

The guy in the next episode is an interesting one and will take us back to the point of what is reasonable and what is not. But what I will say is that he isn't Yoshida's age. Sayu's reaction to him, and what people think that means, will be interesting.


Yup, it really makes you think what everyone's goals are or what they really want from their decisions. I'm pretty sure that Yoshida caught on 90% of her fake smiles, but anyway, one of the big disadvantages that Sayu had because of her past actions is going to return to her pretty soon...

Handing her to authorities is probably not the best thing to do, but is the most legal way of handling the situation.. but like I said, it depends on the people, and where they want to put their values on. Not only Yoshida and Sayu don't seem to mind the legal risks right now but the others aswell, Asami included.

I mean, even if the girl did that when she was in your house or your protection, then it would still be the girls's fault. Like I said, if Sayu just thinks to run away or spy on Yoshida, that is outside of his powers, all he can do is lock her in but that's just rude at the end of the day. And neither Asami or Gotou could do anything about it either if she was in their house, because no one expects her to do something like this. That's why Sayu has to realise some things herself and Yoshida can't really explain everything to her, she's not dumb afterall, just very naive.

I think that Yoshida does a good job in both practical and mental ways, but if Asami went trough something similar, than of course, some insight from her would be helpfull for Sayu, but I think that Sayu knows that what she did is bad, and she regrets it. Regardless of what Asami may say, with the help that she's gotten until now, Sayu already knows what to do from now on.

You will not find the guy interesting or reasonable at all. It'll make your blood boil if you're like me and you hate stuff like that. But we have yet to see how they adapt that part.
May 6, 2021 8:37 AM
Offline
Dec 2018
609
Morsse said:

Yup, it really makes you think what everyone's goals are or what they really want from their decisions. I'm pretty sure that Yoshida caught on 90% of her fake smiles, but anyway, one of the big disadvantages that Sayu had because of her past actions is going to return to her pretty soon...

Handing her to authorities is probably not the best thing to do, but is the most legal way of handling the situation.. but like I said, it depends on the people, and where they want to put their values on. Not only Yoshida and Sayu don't seem to mind the legal risks right now but the others aswell, Asami included.

I mean, even if the girl did that when she was in your house or your protection, then it would still be the girls's fault. Like I said, if Sayu just thinks to run away or spy on Yoshida, that is outside of his powers, all he can do is lock her in but that's just rude at the end of the day. And neither Asami or Gotou could do anything about it either if she was in their house, because no one expects her to do something like this. That's why Sayu has to realise some things herself and Yoshida can't really explain everything to her, she's not dumb afterall, just very naive.

I think that Yoshida does a good job in both practical and mental ways, but if Asami went trough something similar, than of course, some insight from her would be helpfull for Sayu, but I think that Sayu knows that what she did is bad, and she regrets it. Regardless of what Asami may say, with the help that she's gotten until now, Sayu already knows what to do from now on.

You will not find the guy interesting or reasonable at all. It'll make your blood boil if you're like me and you hate stuff like that. But we have yet to see how they adapt that part.


Well, let's see how it plays out. I agree with you about illegal and immoral. Problem here is that moral carries more risk.

Agreed, it would be their fault, but it is hard to not feel responsible, and Yoshida is taking on a big responsibility.

Sayu knows what she should do but........... Let's see next week.

Definitely, how they adapt it is important. He's obviously a creep but his mindset isn't that different from Sayu's when she arrived at Yoshida's house. The discussions next week will be interesting, for sure.
May 6, 2021 11:11 AM
Offline
Aug 2019
27
Oh, yay, the big, bad villain has been introduced (or kinda reintroduced, I guess)… I can't wait for the completely unnecessary, chance encounter between these characters that will somehow move the plot forward.

Seriously, though, I'd like at least some originality.

I liked the show at first, but I can see myself losing interest over the next few weeks. Hopefully there's something that rekindles my interest in the series 'cause I really would like to enjoy this show. Though, this studio doesn't really have the best track record, so who knows how it's actually going to turn out.
May 6, 2021 11:56 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
4229
Welp turns out I was probably wrong about Gotou, she had a nice, mature talk with Sayu and helped her face reality. Mishima on the other hand was a bit annoying, not only for stalking Yoshida but also for saying immature things like let me sleep at your place and shit. Just let him be man.

The guy at the end will definitely bring about trouble, the appearance of a person from Sayu's traumatic past can't be good ;_;
Pages (5) « First ... « 2 3 [4] 5 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Hige wo Soru. Soshite Joshikousei wo Hirou. Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Jun 28, 2021

313 by gothangelsinner »»
Jan 6, 6:55 PM

Poll: » Hige wo Soru. Soshite Joshikousei wo Hirou. Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Stark700 - Jun 21, 2021

216 by W3TFT »»
Dec 14, 2024 3:40 PM

Poll: » Hige wo Soru. Soshite Joshikousei wo Hirou. Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Apr 26, 2021

281 by Paydah14 »»
Dec 7, 2024 8:15 AM

» Plan to watch have a question?

Jai_akash - Dec 4, 2024

20 by Heisenberg_69 »»
Dec 6, 2024 1:03 PM

Poll: » Hige wo Soru. Soshite Joshikousei wo Hirou. Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Apr 19, 2021

330 by Paydah14 »»
Dec 6, 2024 8:58 AM

Preview MangaManga Store

It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login