Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (4) « 1 2 [3] 4 »
Dec 20, 2020 11:51 AM

Offline
Apr 2020
446
So Youta has a massive group chat with the friends he made while Hina was him along with his family? The messages and phone calls were heartwarming.

I like how Izanami said she loved both him and Hina. To me, it shows that Hina's inclusion in his life and everyone else's changed everyone for the better.

I still hope Youta ends up with Izanami and thelove everyone has is platonic to Hina.

That insert song still brings on the feels.
Dec 20, 2020 1:15 PM

Offline
Feb 2014
3966
I must admit that this was a rather tricky episode to watch, as it did well to play with my emotions.

Considering how close he was to Hina before her "operation", Yota is acting rather unwisely in his approaches to what Hina is right now, which does make for some uncomfortable scenes. I do sympathise with Yota, considering the circumstances and, let's be real, most of us on this discussion thread would be walking on thin ice and also be making mistakes if we tried to get Hina's trust in this scenario and someone his age do tend to make really dumb choices with their lack of judgement, but it doesn't change the fact that he got a little too loud and impatient at times.

Nevertheless, he did start to learn from those early mistakes, also inspired from the calls he had with Izanami, Ashura and the others, and was able to gain Hina's trust, mostly thanks to the knock-off Dragon Quest game of all things. Big respect for Yota for doing an all-nighter, grinding the character's levels, so that Hina can have an easier time playing the game.

However, it looks like his identity has been blown, which is earlier than the allotted time he had left. Only one episode left now and with this development, my hope for a somewhat happy ending looks less likely now. =(
Dec 20, 2020 1:34 PM
Offline
Apr 2013
6
Youta might be the dumbest character on this show. I get hes supposed to be in high school, but he has no understanding on how to handle things. Even at the end he should have contacted Hiroto before replying to the officer.
Dec 20, 2020 2:49 PM
Offline
Oct 2020
1
It upsets me to see how Youta doesn't care about Hina's sensibility... He definitely looks stupid screaming in front of her
Dec 20, 2020 4:17 PM
Offline
Jun 2020
19
RiceKnight59 said:
I still hope Youta ends up with Izanami and thelove everyone has is platonic to Hina.
To be honest, at this point, no one going is to end up with Youta. With Hina's current condition, the chances are already 0.1%. Also, didn't Izanami brother-zoned Youta this episode? If the familial love can be said for Hina in Episode 9, the same can be said for Izanami as well in today's episode.
Dec 20, 2020 4:46 PM

Offline
Jan 2017
603
I cringed so fu*** hard when Youta keeps scaring Hina... You can't speed run this kind of this you *****!

Also, I know this is anime, etc but really nobody checked Youta's background/skills/knowledge when he arrived at the rehab center? Just by the way he behaves the 1st day they should notice that something is off...
Dec 20, 2020 7:08 PM
Offline
Jul 2020
9
Agora fica a pergunta. Ela vai recobrar suas lembranças?
Dec 20, 2020 8:11 PM

Offline
Dec 2018
775
Chiibi said:
Nikmomo93 said:
(Except for Kanon and Air since I haven't watch them),


Air's protagonist is great; he's playful and fun...but also moody so he makes a face like T_T during shenanigans and he is able to figure things out WAY faster than Youta also he's total EYECANDY He is my favorite Key boy by a long shot. Yukito is SO much cooler than Youta, it's pathetic.



^Trying to steal Haruko's bike. xD

Lol Maeda really likes motorcycles....


I see, looks interesting. I'll watch them soon, Thanks :3
Dec 21, 2020 12:05 AM
Offline
Feb 2017
6009
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.


You haven’t seen God of High School, huh?
Dec 21, 2020 12:07 AM
Offline
Feb 2017
6009
Didn’t Jun Maeda say this’ll be his “saddest work”? I see no other way of this show ending than Hina dying.
Dec 21, 2020 12:34 AM
Offline
Feb 2018
186
Hrybami said:
Neaow said:
Desperation, and being scared of running out of time, plus he didn't got to see her for whole year...as an anime character and according to his personality I think it works...I have no complaints...I have watched anime for a daem long time now, I don't need anyone's friking lame @$$ judgement about what their own fricking taste goes good with, they should just stick to their fricking shounen,or high school love comedy whatnot's...even if I am the only one in this fricking universe this one was pretty good show for me, I would say not for teenagers, I don't think you understand but not all the show is about being fricking cool or trying to elope with each other in most ravishing way in the name romance and cr@p, well what can you expect most of the times anime is targeted to teenage audience, that's how they make sales, just need to lur all the horny teenage kids with big bazookas and whatnot, I know this cause I have been through the same, well all I can say is it's not the right time for you...I have seen dozens and dozens of animes now, so I know what I am talking about, everytime you grow by a year or two your way of thinking changed with, that's why don't be shocked when you will be laughing at your past self.


Thank you. I couldn't stop rolling my eyes reading some people replies here. I feel relieved to know I'm not alone to have a foot in the reality realm.
Well it is what it is I guess...anime had had a huge influence on me...changed me, shaped me, opened my eyes towards reality and much more that I can never be more grateful to anyone or anything else.
Dec 21, 2020 12:59 AM

Offline
Oct 2012
226
skysurf said:
Let's ASSUME for a moment the writer didn't make the MC a retarded teenager with the emotional intelligence of a 5 years old, and that the plan to impersonate a researcher went perfectly well, NOW WHAT?

He clearly stated he wanted to take her home, but can he afford the special 24/7 medical care that Hina requires? Can he take care of her personally while earning a living (studying/working in the future)? Will he just burden her mom to take care of Hina while he lives his own life?... ANSWER IS: Clearly he hasn't think this through. It seems like MC is betting on an asspull miracle where Hina magically recovers her mental faculties.


I get why people are angry, but I think that's the point. Youta has no idea what he's doing. He's getting scolded and feels like shit. Heck, Shiba might not even have the best intentions. I think this post on Reddit by cerdaco sums it up pretty well:


I don't think you're supposed to side with him. Even if the show paints it as some heroic effort, it is through Youta's perspective, no?

skysurf said:
dlxuniuniu said:
I don't see why Hina should die or anything like that

The illness was described as a degenerative disease in previous episodes, which means the symptoms get worse over time and life expectancy is short. On the other hand, she looks in a much better state than what was described (cerebral atrophy and neurogenic muscular atrophy) and can move around and say some words, so I guess we shouldn't take it too literal and anything is possible with sci-fi + miracles...


There is a slight possibility they could reveal something next episode, though it would feel rushed to do so. If they don't, then we can chalk her current condition up to the quantum computer somehow "healing" her, even though it doesn't make much sense.

--------------------

Thanks to Sou on the Kamisama ni Natta Hi Discord for letting me know, but Jun Maeda deleted his Twitter recently. I honestly feel bad for the guy. In the end, I wish people would just remember that this is simply a TV show. I've seen quite a few comments in English and Japanese berating Jun Maeda as a person for not being able to create a show that they like. We can have our opinions about whether it's good or bad, about whether the characters were written well, but it's just a TV show. :
If I imagine myself in his shoes, I don't think I could take much of this either. I spent so much time and energy creating something that I enjoy, but people are very vocal about how what I'm doing is terrible or getting worse and worse, almost personally so. And for some reason, all of the talk always revolves around my name, despite the fact that there's a whole team of people who worked together to produce it. Yeah, I'd shut myself off from the internet too.
It's not like Jun Maeda is the only person involved in this show. He's not the main director, and each episode also has its own director, separate from the main director. Why do we only talk about Jun Maeda like he's solely responsible?
I get that he probably shouldn't have said how he was trying to make this the saddest show ever. I bet he regrets ever saying that with every episode that comes out. He said it once and everyone jumps at this every single time they find something wrong with the show. He didn't even say it directly. The voice actress for Hina read it from a letter that he sent to the preview interview before the show aired.
Reading all of these posts honestly makes me kind of depressed too.
EpicCh33seDec 21, 2020 2:16 AM
Dec 21, 2020 2:19 AM

Offline
Feb 2016
959
Yeah yeah Youta was irritating, but his case is special, he always was like that to Hina, he shouted at her a lot and that way both had fun, but now a part of him just can't accept the fact she is a totally different person now. if we see it that way it's fkng sad.

And that woman, I don't even care about her name, she is right about the fact that Hina is better staying at that place for OBVIOUS reasons, but still she is a terrible person, trying to use the poor Hina as a tool to satisfy her need of a child, raising her the way she wasn't able to do with her true daughter, she is not a bad person but looking at Hina that way makes her a total creep.
Sorry if my english is bad (っ˘▽˘)っ~~~
Btw, cry about it.

Dec 21, 2020 2:32 AM
Offline
Jun 2020
19
EpicCh33se said:
Thanks to Sou on the Kamisama ni Natta Hi Discord for letting me know, but Jun Maeda deleted his Twitter recently. I honestly feel bad for the guy. In the end, I wish people would just remember that this is simply a TV show. I've seen quite a few comments in English and Japanese berating Jun Maeda as a person for not being able to create a show that they like. We can have our opinions about whether it's good or bad, about whether the characters were written well, but it's just a TV show. :
If I imagine myself in his shoes, I don't think I could take much of this either. I spent so much time and energy creating something that I enjoy, but people are very vocal about how what I'm doing is terrible or getting worse and worse, almost personally so. And for some reason, all of the talk always revolves around my name, despite the fact that there's a whole team of people who worked together to produce it. Yeah, I'd shut myself off from the internet too.
It's not like Jun Maeda is the only person involved in this show. He's not the main director, and each episode also has its own director, separate from the main director. Why do we only talk about Jun Maeda like he's solely responsible?
I get that he probably shouldn't have said how he was trying to make this the saddest show ever. I bet he regrets ever saying that with every episode that comes out. But come on, he said it once and everyone jumps at this every single time they find something wrong with the show. He didn't even say it directly. The voice actress for Hina read it from a letter that he sent to the preview interview before the show aired.
Reading all of these posts honestly makes me kind of depressed too.
True. Maybe this isn't his saddest show ever, even I feel he did talk big & I believe he's regretting it now. It's also correct we may have our opinions about how the anime is currently going. But just blaming one person for this isn't correct. As EpicCh33se said, he worked on this for like 5 years he loved the most & when people are belittling the show like it's some trash, even I will feel depressed. Jun Maeda before closing his Twitter account said that he did read every single comment every single day. With negativity especially on Twitter, MAL & even Reddit, I can feel his pain. If this anime isn't to your liking, go watch other anime. It's not like this is the only single anime in the world.

The anime has its ups & downs, and I do feel it can be better in some areas but I firmly believe this is a good anime. Although, not 100% perfect, but if this show brings a smile to my face while watching, I don't mind the flaws at all. A 7/10 anime for me.
saxena5355Dec 21, 2020 5:49 AM
Dec 21, 2020 3:16 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564074
EpicCh33se said:
I don't think you're supposed to side with him. Even if the show paints it as some heroic effort, it is through Youta's perspective, no?


This is what confuses me the most. Are we supposed to be rooting for Yota at this point? It feels like he's going about this all the worst possible way, but then you get the whole bit with everyone sending him encouraging messages and he powers on.

Like it feels like from the show's perspective we're supposed to feel sad that Yota can’t get through to Hina and be on his side for trying to be her hero, but all I can think is that what Yota wants out of the whole thing absolutely isn’t what Hina needs right now, and that he’s being a completely selfish dolt in the whole thing.
Dec 21, 2020 3:32 AM

Offline
Feb 2020
716
Its getting kind of weird.
Only 1 episode left. Don't know how it will all turn out.

I really like the slice of life type starting episodes.
My Candies:
Dec 21, 2020 3:40 AM

Offline
Oct 2012
226
BenDTU said:
EpicCh33se said:
I don't think you're supposed to side with him. Even if the show paints it as some heroic effort, it is through Youta's perspective, no?


This is what confuses me the most. Are we supposed to be rooting for Yota at this point? It feels like he's going about this all the worst possible way, but then you get the whole bit with everyone sending him encouraging messages and he powers on.

Like it feels like from the show's perspective we're supposed to feel sad that Yota can’t get through to Hina and be on his side for trying to be her hero, but all I can think is that what Yota wants out of the whole thing absolutely isn’t what Hina needs right now, and that he’s being a completely selfish dolt in the whole thing.


The scene with the phone makes me pity Youta. He wants to do what is seemingly good for him and everyone else. Everyone loves Hina. It justifies his actions to himself. But we know that he can't treat Hina very well at the moment, and that he doesn't know how to take care of her. Shiba tells him this.

This makes me really wish this show was longer. In a normal story structure, this type of ordeal would happen slightly after the halfway point. The main character goofs up and suffers the consequences. But they learn what they did wrong and get up back to some sort of climax.
I'm honestly not sure how it's going to be handled in one episode.
Dec 21, 2020 3:41 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
90
Oh my god. I treated Youta neutral all the time, but after this episode something broke in me. I understand the pressure of time and everything, but how can you be such an irresponsible brat?

Dec 21, 2020 3:44 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564074
EpicCh33se said:

I'm honestly not sure how it's going to be handled in one episode.


For sure. I can’t think of anything the show could do that only takes a single episode that isn’t a complete deus ex machina, short of a downer end where everyone just has to admit defeat.
Dec 21, 2020 4:37 AM

Offline
Jan 2020
7312
I felt very sympathetic for Hina, but man, Yota really pissed me off in this episode. He, for some reason, thinks Hina would be better off with him but never does anything to actually prove so. Instead, he keeps shouting at her repeatedly and makes her scared.

Great OST, but a horrible episode.
Dec 21, 2020 5:52 AM

Offline
Oct 2018
304
The way Yota keeps mistreating her and yelling alot pisses me off so much, he's too impatient and doesnt think about her feelings, is he really stupid? Well at least he's calming down but damn he pissed me off lmfao
Dec 21, 2020 6:18 AM
Offline
Mar 2019
280
saxena5355 said:
EpicCh33se said:
Thanks to Sou on the Kamisama ni Natta Hi Discord for letting me know, but Jun Maeda deleted his Twitter recently. I honestly feel bad for the guy. In the end, I wish people would just remember that this is simply a TV show. I've seen quite a few comments in English and Japanese berating Jun Maeda as a person for not being able to create a show that they like. We can have our opinions about whether it's good or bad, about whether the characters were written well, but it's just a TV show. :
If I imagine myself in his shoes, I don't think I could take much of this either. I spent so much time and energy creating something that I enjoy, but people are very vocal about how what I'm doing is terrible or getting worse and worse, almost personally so. And for some reason, all of the talk always revolves around my name, despite the fact that there's a whole team of people who worked together to produce it. Yeah, I'd shut myself off from the internet too.
It's not like Jun Maeda is the only person involved in this show. He's not the main director, and each episode also has its own director, separate from the main director. Why do we only talk about Jun Maeda like he's solely responsible?
I get that he probably shouldn't have said how he was trying to make this the saddest show ever. I bet he regrets ever saying that with every episode that comes out. But come on, he said it once and everyone jumps at this every single time they find something wrong with the show. He didn't even say it directly. The voice actress for Hina read it from a letter that he sent to the preview interview before the show aired.
Reading all of these posts honestly makes me kind of depressed too.
True. Maybe this isn't his saddest show ever, even I feel he did talk big & I believe he's regretting it now. It's also correct we may have our opinions about how the anime is currently going. But just blaming one person for this isn't correct. As EpicCh33se said, he worked on this for like 5 years he loved the most & when people are belittling the show like it's some trash, even I will feel depressed. Jun Maeda before closing his Twitter account said that he did read every single comment every single day. With negativity especially on Twitter, MAL & even Reddit, I can feel his pain. If this anime isn't to your liking, go watch other anime. It's not like this is the only single anime in the world.

The anime has its ups & downs, and I do feel it can be better in some areas but I firmly believe this is a good anime. Although, not 100% perfect, but if this show brings a smile to my face while watching, I don't mind the flaws at all. A 7/10 anime for me.


Upu are ok in all. The author not have all responsabilites. But one thing that he need to know because of previous animes, its this finals are not so good.
Anime for me its so good but for only 12 episodres not, because its go so fast in this last episodes.

Really i want to know what pass with Hina but also i want to know of the organization that decide this things. The have a lot of hisotry to do more episodes
Dec 21, 2020 6:26 AM

Offline
Jul 2014
5407
How many damn times is Youta going to yell in Hinas presence or manhandle her? How many times does he have to be told that he can't do that in her presence cos she's scared of men now? I fully understand why he's acting like this, because he's never experienced anything like this before, but it's frustrating.

Oh, and of course the female scientist has a tragic backstory to justify her treatment of Hina, and her contempt towards Youta. Until that point, this episode was at least vaguely effective despite Youta's frustrating actions (though, most of those scenes about Hina's daily routine would have been as uncomfortable wherever they were in the show, in the same way that Hina's overall ordeal doesn't need the context to be effective), but that completely ruined and then Youta's continued persistence with the video game just worsened the situation.

There's no way this train wreck is satisfactorily resolved in one episode, and I barely care to see how it even is at this point. I'm assuming it will be with Youta "rescuing" Hina from the facility somehow, even though he can't provide for her in any capacity even remotely close to what the facility offers her, especially as her Logos Syndrome is degenerative and will eventually kill her (though, given Hina's apparent, minor recovery this episode, the show seems to have forgotten that important detail anyway).

I don't even know what this show is trying to be at this point: what's the purpose of any of this? Where's the thematic grounding that made Angel Beats so effective despite its flawed pacing? Where's the intrigue and suspense that made Charlotte work despite its flaws? Where's even a single well-written character to allow any of this to work even through all the holes in the writing?
AtavisticDec 21, 2020 6:37 AM
Dec 21, 2020 7:07 AM

Offline
Sep 2014
9556
Neaow said:
Hrybami said:


Thank you. I couldn't stop rolling my eyes reading some people replies here. I feel relieved to know I'm not alone to have a foot in the reality realm.
Well it is what it is I guess...anime had had a huge influence on me...changed me, shaped me, opened my eyes towards reality and much more that I can never be more grateful to anyone or anything else.


The same thing happened to me. This is funny since it looks like anime is doing the opposite effect on some people. Well I guess having too much realism in an anime makes it harder to handle for some people.
Dec 21, 2020 9:16 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
Youta's reaction IS realistic for a teenager who's never been around disabled kids...and I can accept that.

But after she cries just ONCE from his shouting, he shouldn't have to be reminded to STOP doing it; that's a goldfish memory. xD

I don't hate the character or think he's a bad person or anything...but it was a little annoying, that's all.
ChiibiDec 21, 2020 9:32 AM



Dec 21, 2020 9:37 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
252
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.

Writing talents and skills are fading His golden times are over now.
Of course it can be possible that the anime producer carry also the same blame like the writer because they want to reduce outgoing costs (e.g. make less episodes). But then, he should either stop / disallow the production or wrap up the whole story that could fit into a movie.
Dec 21, 2020 12:02 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
funnyRunny said:
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.

Writing talents and skills are fading His golden times are over now.
Of course it can be possible that the anime producer carry also the same blame like the writer because they want to reduce outgoing costs (e.g. make less episodes). But then, he should either stop / disallow the production or wrap up the whole story that could fit into a movie.


Charlotte was successful in Japan.

There is no reason "he should stop" just because some simps on an English forum "didn't like it".

And not every artist will produce a masterpiece. My point is, he has the creative freedom to do whatever tf he wants. I bet a lot of you aren't even paying to watch his shows so don't act so damn entitled.



Dec 21, 2020 1:56 PM
Offline
Jul 2020
1
Since this world has sci-fi elements in it (futuristic super-computer, Hiroto's gear), my guess for the ending will be the following.

"The day I became god" actually indicates both Youta and Hina. Hina became a god when she received the computer. For Youta, it will be different. As of current state, Hina will eventually die, and Youta will keep regretting forever about this incident. In the near future, Youta becomes a renowned scientist, and even better than Hina's grandpa. He creates a new version of super computer and this is when he "becomes a god".

We can already have an open ending at this point, but there can also be a few different paths from here.

1. Youta is able to time travel due to the power of his sci-fi device, and he decides to return to the past in order to save Hina. Open ending.
2. He uses the technology to help the world, therefore no one else will suffer what Hina experienced. Closed ending.
3. He uses the technology to get revenge (?), although this path is kinda impossible considering his personality. Open ending.
4. Time loop (?). Youta returns to the past and he actually is Hina's grandpa, and the story goes on. Closed ending.

Dec 21, 2020 6:06 PM

Offline
Nov 2020
32
This was briliant, awesome episode, my head hurts @__@
the whole anime has gotten very complex since a few episode I almost collapsed on my keyboard bruuuh. My brain is steamy lmao
Youta is a very good psychiatrist, Hina is in good hands, gambatte Youta-kun you're very stylish!!!! :DD this anime is legally a masterpiece
😻😹😽
Dec 21, 2020 7:03 PM

Offline
Oct 2012
226
Crowterrror said:
saxena5355 said:
True. Maybe this isn't his saddest show ever, even I feel he did talk big & I believe he's regretting it now. It's also correct we may have our opinions about how the anime is currently going. But just blaming one person for this isn't correct. As EpicCh33se said, he worked on this for like 5 years he loved the most & when people are belittling the show like it's some trash, even I will feel depressed. Jun Maeda before closing his Twitter account said that he did read every single comment every single day. With negativity especially on Twitter, MAL & even Reddit, I can feel his pain. If this anime isn't to your liking, go watch other anime. It's not like this is the only single anime in the world.

The anime has its ups & downs, and I do feel it can be better in some areas but I firmly believe this is a good anime. Although, not 100% perfect, but if this show brings a smile to my face while watching, I don't mind the flaws at all. A 7/10 anime for me.


Upu are ok in all. The author not have all responsabilites. But one thing that he need to know because of previous animes, its this finals are not so good.
Anime for me its so good but for only 12 episodres not, because its go so fast in this last episodes.


It's not up to one person to decide how many episodes a show gets. There's a lot of financial and other reasons that we don't know of. Jun Maeda doesn't have every responsibility, but people are sure making him out to have every responsibility.

funnyRunny said:
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.

Writing talents and skills are fading His golden times are over now.
Of course it can be possible that the anime producer carry also the same blame like the writer because they want to reduce outgoing costs (e.g. make less episodes). But then, he should either stop / disallow the production or wrap up the whole story that could fit into a movie.


You can't just stop production, especially after funds and time are allocated to different staff and shareholders. Changing the script entirely wouldn't be out of the picture, but one should assume that making a movie is a completely different process than making a TV show.

Chiibi said:
Charlotte was successful in Japan.

There is no reason "he should stop" just because some simps on an English forum "didn't like it".

And not every artist will produce a masterpiece. My point is, he has the creative freedom to do whatever tf he wants. I bet a lot of you aren't even paying to watch his shows so don't act so damn entitled.


While I agree that he shouldn't stop simply because people tell him to, it's not just English forums. Many Japanese viewers are just as harsh and I've been told that even Chinese viewers are as well. The negativity is universally present.

----------------------

I think this show is a lot more thematically cohesive than Charlotte, though much of that depends on how the final episode plays. I can see this taking a "enjoy things while they last" approach, going off of everything that has happened so far, including Izanami's episode. Korogi tried to delay the inevitable with Hina, but look where that ended up. Ashura learned to move past his leg injury and keeps it from holding him back. Youta, on the other hand, is to fixated on wanting to return to those summer days that he's making a lot of mistakes. The film imagery throughout some of the show falls in line with this, as do many of the song lyrics. If that's the case for the theming, then I hope Hina does not end up going home with Youta.

Keeping in mind that it has been years since I've seen and analyzed Charlotte, it's hard for me to remember any overarching themes. The powers were seen as a sort of disease, but what does that ultimately mean? A few users and I initially thought that the powers were some sort of allusion to puberty and the problems that teenagers face, since they disappear in adulthood. But that clashes with the illness view and the fact that Yuu literally "takes away" people's youth in the end.
EpicCh33seDec 21, 2020 7:09 PM
Dec 21, 2020 7:29 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
EpicCh33se said:


While I agree that he shouldn't stop simply because people tell him to, it's not just English forums. Many Japanese viewers are just as harsh and I've been told that even Chinese viewers are as well. The negativity is universally present.


Criticism online really doesn't matter at all though as long as blurays sell.

That's all there is to it.

And I have a hard time believing Japanese viewers are "just as harsh"...do you have links to such sites?

If you look up Charlotte on amazon jp, the reviews and ratings are very high.
ChiibiDec 21, 2020 7:36 PM



Dec 21, 2020 10:07 PM

Offline
Oct 2012
226
Chiibi said:
EpicCh33se said:


While I agree that he shouldn't stop simply because people tell him to, it's not just English forums. Many Japanese viewers are just as harsh and I've been told that even Chinese viewers are as well. The negativity is universally present.


Criticism online really doesn't matter at all though as long as blurays sell.

That's all there is to it.

And I have a hard time believing Japanese viewers are "just as harsh"...do you have links to such sites?

If you look up Charlotte on amazon jp, the reviews and ratings are very high.


If that were true, Jun Maeda would still have his Twitter, assuming that he deleted his Twitter because of the negativity. He's still a person and an artist. He values his work, as should everyone else who worked on this.

I've screenshotted a couple posts from 5ch.
https://imgur.com/a/Oh1LZ70

1. "Maeda has made many original anime already, but how come there's still no progress?"

2. "The one who should be criticized for this work is Jun Maeda, not PA Works. PA just made it as the shit script says."

3. "It feels like having weak connections from sub-character to character is what Jun Maeda meant by "returning to the origin." With eroge-like layouts and events."

4. "Even though Maeda gets so much criticism like this, he doesn't have intent to kill(?). It's strange. If he was normal, he would act like 青葉." (I'm not sure who 青葉 is)

5. "Unthinkably, the garbage anime was violently born."

From:
https://rosie.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/anime/1607225391/
https://rosie.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/anime/1607340164/l50
https://rosie.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/anime/1607595349/l50

--------------

I'd say that at least a quarter of posts, maybe half, are negative on 5ch. I don't follow the Japanese viewerbase too much. Of course, that doesn't mean there aren't people who like this show too. In both English and Japanese, there are many people who sing praises, especially if you look on Youtube comments.

The people who buy the Charlotte blu-rays to begin with are those that are watching it for the first time or people who enjoyed the TV run.
I know that Amazon JP is known to be pretty harsh sometimes. I didn't know any Japanese back when Charlotte aired (my Japanese now is only so-so anyway), so I can't comment on the Japanese viewerbase then. But people are very harsh for Kamisama ni Natta Hi, again, personally so against Jun Maeda.
Dec 22, 2020 12:03 AM
Offline
Oct 2020
4
This episode was extremely hard to watch, I hope he gets kicked out in the next episode. Youta has 50 IQ points.
Dec 22, 2020 1:52 AM

Offline
Nov 2013
564
While I do like the development we got in this episode, I highly doubt we’ll get a satisfying conclusion next episode that resolves all the different plot points.

It’s a shame there’s only one episode left, the pacing of this anime was part of the problem. They spent so much time with slice of life episodes, that they had to play catch up during the past few episodes when the actual plot regarding Hina began.

The way they paced it, this anime really should’ve been two cours.
Dec 22, 2020 2:24 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
535
This is getting really depressing. It's hard to look at Hina at her current condition. Hopefully she liked this video game.
Well, one episode to go, we'll see how it ends. But, I don't know if it's too late to save this series..
Dec 22, 2020 4:13 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
252
Chiibi said:
funnyRunny said:

Writing talents and skills are fading His golden times are over now.
Of course it can be possible that the anime producer carry also the same blame like the writer because they want to reduce outgoing costs (e.g. make less episodes). But then, he should either stop / disallow the production or wrap up the whole story that could fit into a movie.


Charlotte was successful in Japan.

There is no reason "he should stop" just because some simps on an English forum "didn't like it".

And not every artist will produce a masterpiece. My point is, he has the creative freedom to do whatever tf he wants. I bet a lot of you aren't even paying to watch his shows so don't act so damn entitled.

Before you start to criticize someone's opinion, you should avoid to use bad words. It recudes your quality of commentary.

But B2B, ofc he has the freedom to write the story he wants. But this story is lacking on quality. Maybe the story isn't even lacking, but the animes does. And before you set your bet on wrong horse, i watched Clannad, Kanon, Angel Beats, Little Busters and even Charlotte. But in my opinion this anime is the worst of his creations while Clannad it's the best.
My problem with the show are the characters. They're so flat that i can't empathize with them, except Izanami. And since i can't empathize them, maybe because they are too stereotype, the whole story lacks on quality. One of the problems, imo, the male MC has no background story like the our "godly little girl" or Izanami. But since he has no background, he feels too flat....just boring. Also he misses some character developement. Maybe it exists a developement, but it's so minor that i don't catching it.
Anyway, Mr. Maeda made better stories and this one is the worst of his stories. The description sounded really promising, but turned out to be an average TV-show with flat characters and non-developing environments.
Dec 22, 2020 7:05 AM
Offline
Oct 2019
7418
Absolutely Incredible Episode...
The depression everytime we saw Hina-chan, but Youta keep trying and never give up...

Everyone give support to Youta was Heartwarming...

I know Youta passion in that game but why keep yelling on Hina... That's so frustrated to watch...
Maybe i can understand a little bit, when you are frustrated you did stupid move...
Damn Juna Maeda-san, you really make us suffering with Youta...

That scene where Hina throw away Youta Drawing was funny... (Yeahh that's what you get from Yelling at her lol)

But i love how he turned into Gamer mode grinding the game till morning so Hina-chan cannot be defeated by the enemy and keep continue playing it...

Youta got busted, it's funny how long that it took for the girl to figured it out...

Next week Finale???
I'm prepare to cry.. please give us a good cry...
davidyodo24Dec 22, 2020 7:14 AM
Dec 22, 2020 7:06 AM
Offline
Oct 2019
7418
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.

Wait, isn't God of Highschool the worst one?
Dec 22, 2020 9:08 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
funnyRunny said:
[Before you start to criticize someone's opinion, you should avoid to use bad words. It recudes your quality of commentary.


Lol what "bad words" did I even use? If you think I used "bad words", you are too sensitive for the internet.

But in my opinion this anime is the worst of his creations


Look, I'm not disagreeing. I am disappointed in this show too. But that doesn't mean he should stop. He just needs to try harder.

Artists failing is good...because that's how we learn from our mistakes.



Dec 22, 2020 10:06 AM

Offline
Mar 2014
252
Chiibi said:
funnyRunny said:
[Before you start to criticize someone's opinion, you should avoid to use bad words. It recudes your quality of commentary.

Lol what "bad words" did I even use? If you think I used "bad words", you are too sensitive for the internet.

Don't worry, i haven't felt offended. But using words like "simp" (=bad word) or anything else to criticize someonelse opinion, i can't take your statement in full serious with this. Even there are bunch of people who would kick some asses against Maeda, doesn't mean to reduce the quality of the language.
That's what i try to say.

Chiibi said:
But that doesn't mean he should stop. He just needs to try harder.
Artists failing is good...because that's how we learn from our mistakes.

Maybe i understand you wrong or you understood me wrong. I didn't say, Maeda should stop his writing, but the production of the anime since the anime doesn't feel well developed. In this context he should have stopped.
Dec 22, 2020 10:11 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
funnyRunny said:
Chiibi said:

Lol what "bad words" did I even use? If you think I used "bad words", you are too sensitive for the internet.

Don't worry, i haven't felt offended. But using words like "simp" (=bad word) or anything else to criticize someonelse opinion, i can't take your statement in full serious with this. Even there are bunch of people who would kick some asses against Maeda, doesn't mean to reduce the quality of the language.
That's what i try to say.


"Simp" actually means "simpleton" before someone decided to randomly change it to some dumb sexual thing.

Maybe i understand you wrong or you understood me wrong. I didn't say, Maeda should stop his writing, but the production of the anime since the anime doesn't feel well developed. In this context he should have stopped.


You CANNOT "just stop production" on a show...that's not how it works over there. Up through the 90s, anime OVAs were produced until they ran out of budget so lots of stories were unfinished...but that's not the case here.



Dec 22, 2020 12:56 PM

Offline
Dec 2020
306
This is probably the most essential chapter of this entire anime, although chapter 12 will probably come out to give us a heavy blow as expected from the author.

I found this chapter more moving than sad, still Hina has trouble responding positively, and Yota is getting into trouble. But the scene where his friends text him is fleeting. Then, it seems that Hina is recovering, although the conclusion of how well it will end will be given by the next chapter.

Something that I have understood about this anime from seeing the reviews dedicated to it is that it is not for everyone. Those who enjoyed Clannad and Angel Beats more for their originality in the plot I doubt that they will enjoy this as I did. The problem is not Jun Maeda, but the public that has been following him.
EyeViewerDec 22, 2020 1:05 PM
Dec 22, 2020 7:58 PM

Offline
Jul 2016
8621
Taking care of children with similar conditions as Hina is a really delicate matter so seeing Youta forcing her to remember him is seriously pissing me off. Until now, he wasn't particularly remarkable as MC but man, overreacting and raising your voice even when you were told not to... what a way to get on my nerves, seriously.

Well, that's it. This episode was painful to watch but for all the bad reasons. Everything is being executed in such a forced way in order to move the audience I can't take it anymore. From the female assistant tragically losing a child and finding a replacement (unconsciously or not) in Hina, to the cliché "we love you" message session, to finally Youta playing video games all night "for Hina's sake". Not to mention that I'm absolutely hating how the series is depicting Youta's "mission of rescuing Hina" as something beneficial for her health.

Also, the assistant not suspecting of Youta's identity despite his looks and notorious inability to interact with children with special needs is beyond stupidity at this point and please series, tell me MC isn't planning on kidnapping Hina from the health center now that his cover was exposed. Because seriously, that would be the last nail in this series' coffin.
SouthRzVaDec 22, 2020 8:02 PM
Dec 23, 2020 5:04 AM

Offline
Nov 2011
44
I hate Youta so damn much. What a selfish, arrogant, agressive douche.
Dec 23, 2020 12:34 PM

Offline
Sep 2020
327
Each time I saw Hina in this episode I dropped a tear. Specially when she smiled.

Dude, this is hard.

z00nex said:
Can Youta shut up and let her play the game?

In a certain way, talking is necessary to motivate.
Of course, not the way he did.
niko_sbDec 23, 2020 12:40 PM
Dec 23, 2020 12:43 PM

Offline
Sep 2019
2971
niko_sb said:
.

z00nex said:
Can Youta shut up and let her play the game?

In a certain way, talking is necessary to motivate.
Of course, not the way he did.
Yes, that’s what I was talking about. He kept shouting at her even though the nurse warned him many times about it.
Dec 23, 2020 1:06 PM

Offline
Sep 2020
327
z00nex said:
niko_sb said:
.


In a certain way, talking is necessary to motivate.
Of course, not the way he did.
Yes, that’s what I was talking about. He kept shouting at her even though the nurse warned him many times about it.


Yep.
It was hard to see Hina crying over his misbehaviors, too. Seemed so truly painful. Congrats to VA for that
niko_sbDec 23, 2020 1:10 PM
Dec 23, 2020 2:05 PM
Offline
Aug 2014
1099
Nefelupitou said:
And I thought that Tower of God would be the worst anime in 2020, Jun Maeda doesn't know how to write anymore and it all started with Charlotte.


You mean God of High School.
Dec 23, 2020 8:57 PM

Offline
Jun 2015
47
Urrr Yota was so annoying... Poor Hina :(
“The past, the future, and the present. Everything flows and all is connected. This eye is not merely seen reality. It is touching the truth. Open the eye of truth... There is nothing to fear.” -Cowboy Bebop
Dec 24, 2020 3:51 PM
Offline
Nov 2020
409
Damn, it was really frustrating to watch the video game scenes because MC couldn't control his excitement and patience.

Instead of losing his sleep, couldn't he get find out some kind of cheat code or use a Gameshark/Action Replay to make the video game character immortal and powerful? Or just get a pay-to-win game and buy all the necessary things to win lol.
Pages (4) « 1 2 [3] 4 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Nov 21, 2020

128 by CHT13 »»
Nov 28, 9:22 AM

Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

KANLen09 - Dec 26, 2020

309 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 1, 3:54 AM

Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Stark700 - Dec 12, 2020

168 by Archean-Return »»
Oct 31, 10:47 PM

Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Stark700 - Dec 5, 2020

228 by Archean-Return »»
Oct 31, 9:21 PM

Poll: » Kamisama ni Natta Hi Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Stark700 - Nov 28, 2020

170 by Archean-Return »»
Oct 31, 7:03 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login