Natsu_D_Luffy said: everyone here is a faggot. except yuki. yuki is not a faggot.
Most awesome comment I've seen in a while. It's time for troll-hunt! :D
Oh my, I got a lot of replys here. °x° Let's see:
Yuki_Giou said: Not everyone can be a badass, there must be a weak one as well. Since Uraboku is a shoujo anime as well, usually the shoujo main characters are weak, yet important.
Like Francie-Fugitive stated, Yuki is a Mary-Sue. There's a difference between a weak yet likeable character and a total disaster of a weak character. Yuki is just badly written, he behaves totally unrealistic and is being loved by everyone for ... whatever? We don't even know why he's so important or what he did (in his past life?) to deserve this treatment and we're through 22 episodes. It's like we're being told that we have to like him, because he's so awesome, but we don't get to know WHY he's so awesome. That's some piece of information we need a bit earlier, or else we don't really understand why he deserves to be treated the way he is.
We have the pleasure to go to endless boring flashbacks. Flashbacks without any realy important content. It's all just about Luka loving female Yuki and male Yuki loving/liking Kanata. That's all, but how about showing us some important stuff regarding female Yuki, so we can understand the other characters behavior towards Yuki better? I'm sorry to tell you, but there are only 2 episodes left, this anime is nearly finished.
This clearly doesn't have anything to do if I like or don't like this kind of Genre, because I like Shounen-Ai and Shoujo. If that wouldn't be the case, I would've never even begin to watch this anime and if this anime would've been this bad since the beginning, I would've dropped it already. The point is: it just keeps getting more absurd. The more characters appear, the more love Yuki gets and more of his Mary-Sue-characters shines through.
Great, if it was still bearable when 5 people were worshipping Yuki like some kind of goldlike person, now we have 10 people and it's twice as annoying.
Yuki_Giou said: First of all, let's look at Yuki's past.
His totally clichée-filled past? Spare me. His past is so overly sad to make us like him even more and feel sorry for him, so it's part of his Mary-Sue-character. He's the poor character who had to live through all his bad things, he needs a hug so bad, but he still decides to fight and oh~~~ he's so strong still wanting to rescue everyone and... urg, cut this crap, please. This is like a character comming right out of a bad fanfiction.
ilikeyouevenmoreI said: just don't understand why simply being a healer makes everyone nearly worship him.
I don't understand either. From my experince in anime and manga, healers tend to make fights less interesting for the audience, because: Injury? no problem, get the healer. :D And in case of Uragiri, it's not as if the characters really needed Yukis healing ability so much until now. Plus: they don't even want him to use it, because he'll take the pain upon himself.
Yuki_Giou said: Exactly, so what's wrong with Yuki being unrealistic? I actually love the fact that Luka is so devoted to Yuki, but let's not forget it is an anime.
Let me guess, you like Twilight, too, do you? Of if you haven't read it, I bet you'd like it.
What's wrong with Yuki being unrealistic? Probably because he's the main character? Main characters are usually used so that the readers can identify themselves with them, but Yuki is too perfect, he's too nice, too much loved, too flawless... he's too much everything and at the same time, he can't do anything in a fight. That's pretty bad.
There's no way I can believe such a human being can exist and this is what makes him unfitting as a main characters. I'm not telling that I want super-realistic humans in an anime. I just want believable characters and Yuki is not believable. I don't want to read a fairytale, I want to see an anime with character whose action I can somehow relate to and understand. Not some unrealistic, selfish decisions that don't make sense, but are still approved by everyone around him. Where's the point? There is none and that's why it's bad.
Linalee-Stratos said: If compared his female version seems better than the male version.
Exactly my toughts. XD I'm actually pretty interested in her, what she was like (besides being emo, because she loved Luka), how she was fighting, what she did for the others, what her character was like. They said, that the male Yuki is different from his female version. I want to know that, but the anime doesn't tell us interesting and important facts. It's a bit furstrating.
akromataof said: I just don't get why this show went so downhill..It had everything to become great. And that's the very reason why I had faith this anime could turn out good, why I watched even after I was pretty pissed when I was around episode 10, because I still thought, it could get better. Unfortunately, it only got worse.
You know, there's something that has been on my mind for quite a while. It's about the being reborn-thing. I think it's pretty... hard. I mean: it seems like everyone is reborn exactly the same way he/she was before he/she died and even has his/her memories from back then, right? I think that's really cruel, because you're born to other parents. Parents who love you, parents who think of you as a part of them, as a product of their love, but you're not. You're actually a complete stanger with no relations to them at all, besides using your "mother" as a container to be able to be reborn. That's a bit cruel...
Last word to all the fangirls being annoyed by the people ranting about the bad things in this anime: This is not a place for "fans only", this is not a place to worship this anime and this is certainly not a place where negative comments are forbidden.
This is a place for discussions, if you don't like the point of view from another user, don't tell him. "Don't watch this anime!", because this is nonsense. Pick of a discussion and try to explain why you thing differently, but don't expect the other to turn into a fangirl. |