I agree with the UN here.
Wam should be non-proliferated. It is outrageous. I agree with Tsukai(She so cute, best girl) here. Humanity is way too early to have something like this.
If Mr.Alien offered something lower tier, like a easily accessible long lasting clean energy... Then yes that would be wonderful. But infinite energy is TOO much.
1) Wam will render ALL energy sources obsolete. Not only do fossil fuel plants, nuclear, solar energy, wind, geothermal plants would shut down. Significant amount of mining companies that supply the industry will also go under. This will lead to a massive unemployment and thus less spending. That's detrimental to a market economy. The economy will enter a potential depression.
2) Developing nations rely on natural resources as their source of income. Particularly fossil fuels. This will be detrimental to their development. In many ways it can harm the livelihood of millions, not help it. Nations like these will be heavily opposed to the Wam, while others may be open to it
3) The world is not united. Every nation has different goals. And that include taking advantage of the Wam for militaristic use. Wam is an infinite energy source. That means we can take that energy and store it. Then release it all at once as a weapon that may even exceed nuclear power.
4) Ideally it will be distributed equally to the world, but the world is not equal. There are higher members of society that will control this distribution. There are superpowers in the world that can rely on conventional military, and economic might to force weaker nations to surrender their Wam. This only feeds in to the strength of major powers.
5) On the other end of the spectrum, unstable nations like those in the middle east may lose control of its Wam to rogue non-state actors. Unlike nuclear weapons, is much simpler to weaponize as it scales with the device it is powering. This means terrorists can easily use this to threaten major powers, where as terrorist would not have the expertise and infrastructure to deploy nuclear weapons.
6) As mentioned in the anime, Wam will unbalance the energy equilibrium of the planet. Not space, space is simply too big. Humanity can use it for the rest of our existence and have negligible effect on the Universe's energy state. However that's not the case for Earth.
It will lead to global warming, because unlike traditional energy sources, we aren't 'recycling' energy within the planet. We are ADDING energy in to the planet.
And it isn't necessarily heat energy. It could be in the form of kinetic energy depending on how its converted and used. This added energy is PERMANENT. Fossil fuels convert chemical energy in to heat and generate new gaseous elements. While this gas causes global warming, they will also eventually decay and form back to new elements, maintaining equilibrium given enough time. Wam adds energy, so even if it converts in to something else, there will be an excess in whatever form it is in.
As it is INFINITE energy, it can theoretically knock Earth out of its orbit with enough kinetic energy added in to the system. Absolutely a environmental hazard.
A theoretical solution would be to somehow extract the extra energy and expend it in space. But we do not have the technology to magically remove energy from our atmosphere and planet and expel it in to space.
We can be really inefficient and store it in batteries, then launch it in to space. However there's no way to capture 100% of the energy generated by Wams. Energy is lost in the form of sound and heat, none of our technology has 100% efficiency. Once it's lost in to the atmosphere, it will be practically impossible to retrieve it in to a physical form where we can transport it. Additionally, the materials that make up batteries will be lost to use forever in space even though it CAN BE USED IN MANY OTHER APPLICATIONS.
7) And there's also a reason why infinite energy doesn't exist in the real world. If it did, the entire balance of the universe would be broken. Physical laws would be broken. It can theoretically allow travel at the speed of light which also breaks physics.
It's a can of worm where nothing make sense anymore. |