My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong, As I Expected (light novel)
Who is your best girl?
kshin172 said: If Orimoto develops as a character, I would be fine with an Orimoto ending as unrealistic as that is. Can be realistic if Hachiman found himself loving her again and Orimoto changed her character to more of using facade and kinder. Then maybe yes lol, but I hope not. |
 |
DarklordVor said: kshin172 said: If Orimoto develops as a character, I would be fine with an Orimoto ending as unrealistic as that is. Can be realistic if Hachiman found himself loving her again and Orimoto changed her character to more of using facade and kinder. Then maybe yes lol, but I hope not. That would be somehow a good ending... Like, if they are already married or something, they can talk about the hardships of their love life and how they reached the finish line. |
 |
testamentKAISER said: Terapin said: The better question would be, who wants a girl willing to be completely, inconsiderately honest (and be inevitably rude and insensitive at that too) about everything you say and do? Just simplify it, who wants Orimoto? XD I would. I'm a masochist. She's not completely honest actually. She might seems a bit brash but it just the way she treats everybody, she was like Yui on LSD. I think she was taken aback by 8man confession because they didn't even properly talked and know each other before. The way she ridicule 8man is her defense mechanism. She was in the similar position with Ebina had 8man didn't stop the confession. Although she often ridicule him it is mostly not in an ill intent, she keeps doing it as a facade because otherwise she would felt awkward with him, it is the only way she could maintain the 'friendliness' without giving the wrong signal. Quite interesting though that she still remembers him and says hi when they meet again. If she felt him as 'disgusting' she would rather ignored their encounter, but on the most occurrences she strikes me saw 8man as 'interesting' plaything, because I think all the friend she had is all pretentious, even on the highschool. For her, 8man is probably the only honest friend she had. Then again, I don't read the LN, so take it as a grain of salt. |
azzuReMay 14, 2015 10:04 AM
| The most important things in life is the people that you care about |
azzuRe said: testamentKAISER said: Just simplify it, who wants Orimoto? XD I would. I'm a masochist. She's not completely honest actually. She might seems a bit brash but it just the way she treats everybody, she was like Yui on LSD. I think she was taken aback by 8man confession because they didn't even properly talked and know each other before. The way she ridicule 8man is her defense mechanism. She was in the similar position with Ebina had 8man didn't stop the confession. Although she often ridicule him it is mostly not in an ill intent, she keeps doing it as a facade because otherwise she would felt awkward with him, it is the only way she could maintain the 'friendliness' without giving the wrong signal. Quite interesting though that she still remembers him and says hi when they meet again. If she felt him as 'disgusting' she would rather ignored their encounter, but on the most occurrences she strikes me saw 8man as 'interesting' plaything, because I think all the friend she had is all pretentious, even on the highschool. For her, 8man is probably the only honest friend she had. Then again, I don't read the LN, so take it as a grain of salt. Good point, I know similar girls like her thats just awkward with talking to a school mate after all these years, there wasnt any ill intent in that, they just wanted to add drama in it adding Hikki's style, if I were Hikki I would have teased her back that would have been more fun lol. I cant speak for her friend tho.... |
  |
| Let's all be honest here.....Iroha is best girl. Yuki is end game girl. Yui is ideal girl. |
| Big Order (TV):great anime or greatest anime? |
bobzanny said: Let's all be honest here.....Iroha is best girl. Yuki is end game girl. Yui is ideal girl. I just have to QFT this one. |
| for fun watari wataru's fav character is komachi iroha have all traits of little sister type,8man considered her as his sister so pretty much we'll got iroha end |
bobzanny said: Let's all be honest here.....Iroha is best girl. Yuki is end game girl. Yui is ideal girl. I must agree with this. Yui is an ideal girl, and Yuki is the end game because of her popularity and all. I'm not sure if Iroha is the best girl, because I think Komachi got that place... |
|
| ^ Komachi is the best imouto. but can never be best girl. |
| >I had no brain when I was 12 >Then everyone must had no brain when they were 12 >I experimented 100 samples and proved that they had no brain when they were 12 >Therefore children cannot consent This is what science has done to humanity. |
| 1. Yui 2. Saika 3. Shizuka 4. Isshiki 5. Komachi 6. Saki 7. Hina 8. Yukino 9. Haruno 10. Yumiko |
| I think Yui's the best girl here. But, I can see Iroha's potential, she's might be more superior than Yui later. Give the girl some time to develop. :3 |
 |
kidlat020 said: ^ Komachi is the best imouto. but can never be best girl. thats why we have iroha :) |
 someone else always have what you want, but it usually means nothing to them... |
| Yukino and Iroha |
| Iroha. That's not even a question at this point IMO. |
Smudy said: Iroha. That's not even a question at this point IMO. Then rejoice, Because |
 |
panzer999 said: While Yukinon, her scary sister , and Isshiki are interesting, Yui is definetely the best girl, as she is the only truly genuine person in this show. Everyone else mostly lies, manipulates , and maintains a facade. Komachi comes in as second IMO. WHAT!!!!!!!!!! Yui fans, just stop..... |
Temera1re said: panzer999 said: While Yukinon, her scary sister , and Isshiki are interesting, Yui is definetely the best girl, as she is the only truly genuine person in this show. Everyone else mostly lies, manipulates , and maintains a facade. Komachi comes in as second IMO. WHAT!!!!!!!!!! Yui fans, just stop..... What? People can't express their opinion on the character they like? |
|
DarklordVor said: Temera1re said: WHAT!!!!!!!!!! Yui fans, just stop..... What? People can't express their opinion on the character they like? Just ignore, he/she might be bitter about Kawasomething x Hikki not getting adapted in the anime. (Although i am bitter about that too. ) |
|
testamentKAISER said: DarklordVor said: What? People can't express their opinion on the character they like? Just ignore, he/she might be bitter about Kawasomething x Hikki not getting adapted in the anime. (Although i am bitter about that too. ) Well yeah :( too bad Kawasaki and Keika don't get a scene. Most of Kawasaki's scene gets omitted a lot. |
|
panzer999 said: While Yukinon, her scary sister , and Isshiki are interesting, Yui is definetely the best girl, as she is the only truly genuine person in this show. Everyone else mostly lies, manipulates , and maintains a facade. Komachi comes in as second IMO. I disagree. If anything 8man and Yuki are the most brutally honest characters in the show. I do see where you're coming from though, but I still think Yui 'lies, manipulates, and maintains a facade'. After all, these past few episodes she's been trying to do all these things in order to lighten the atmosphere in the club. I mean, that's a good reason to lie, but at the same time doesn't that make it not genuine? |
| I was all about Yui in first season but after seeing Isshiki in last weeks episode, she was just my kind of girl! |
appu1232 said: panzer999 said: While Yukinon, her scary sister , and Isshiki are interesting, Yui is definetely the best girl, as she is the only truly genuine person in this show. Everyone else mostly lies, manipulates , and maintains a facade. Komachi comes in as second IMO. I disagree. If anything 8man and Yuki are the most brutally honest characters in the show. I do see where you're coming from though, but I still think Yui 'lies, manipulates, and maintains a facade'. After all, these past few episodes she's been trying to do all these things in order to lighten the atmosphere in the club. I mean, that's a good reason to lie, but at the same time, doesn't it make it not genuine? Yeah Yui's facade actually bothers Hachiman in the S2E7. As Hachiman said "Yuigahama forced cheerfulness", Yui's facade is for the best to keep the club together. So Yui's facade is not as bad as people claim to be. |
|
DarklordVor said: appu1232 said: I disagree. If anything 8man and Yuki are the most brutally honest characters in the show. I do see where you're coming from though, but I still think Yui 'lies, manipulates, and maintains a facade'. After all, these past few episodes she's been trying to do all these things in order to lighten the atmosphere in the club. I mean, that's a good reason to lie, but at the same time, doesn't it make it not genuine? Yeah Yui's facade actually bothers Hachiman in the S2E7. As Hachiman said "Yuigahama forced cheerfulness", Yui's facade is for the best to keep the club together. So Yui's facade is not as bad as people claim to be. True but at the same time it's only good in moderation or else everything just ends up being superficial. This show needs characters that confront the problems at hand directly like Yukino so I don't think she deserves the backlash she is getting for her cold behavior. |
appu1232 said: True but at the same time it's only good in moderation or else everything just ends up being superficial. This show needs characters that confront the problems at hand directly like Yukino so I don't think she deserves the backlash she is getting for her cold behavior. Yes Yukino don't deserve the backlash because after all she is probably the only direct person that confronts the problem as seen in the end of episode 7. But we also get Hachiman's break up with the club and he will not be hanging out with Yui or Yukino again for sometime. Sometimes it is good to lie to prevent something bad happening, at least that's what Yui's doing. Now Hachiman is going to be spending more time with Iroha, I'm smelling some date coming... |
|
DarklordVor said: appu1232 said: True but at the same time it's only good in moderation or else everything just ends up being superficial. This show needs characters that confront the problems at hand directly like Yukino so I don't think she deserves the backlash she is getting for her cold behavior. Yes Yukino don't deserve the backlash because after all she is probably the only direct person that confronts the problem as seen in the end of episode 7. But we also get Hachiman's break up with the club and he will not be hanging out with Yui or Yukino again for sometime. Sometimes it is good to lie to prevent something bad happening, at least that's what Yui's doing. Now Hachiman is going to be spending more time with Iroha, I'm smelling some date coming... Well the part in the LN that picks up from this episode |
appu1232May 15, 2015 9:12 AM
DarklordVor said: Temera1re said: WHAT!!!!!!!!!! Yui fans, just stop..... What? People can't express their opinion on the character they like? Is not that what i mean. Just stop the shit talk. Most of thing what yui fans are saying dont even make sense and make me wonder if actualy all of you watch the anime or read de novel.  |
Temera1reMay 15, 2015 10:09 AM
| Yukinon is the first girl, the reason he is in the club, the girl most similar to him, the one with which he has the best dialogue. Has to be Yukinon. Yui will be a "close" second imo, but will not (I hope at least) win. She's always not quite been on the same level as those two, and I think she has remarked about that in the past... and it's true. |
| One day we will come upon each other, and for that day my claws, teeth, ears, hands and hair are at the ready. |
DriveYouCrazy said: Yukinon is the first girl, the reason he is in the club, the girl most similar to him, the one with which he has the best dialogue. Has to be Yukinon. Yui will be a "close" second imo, but will not (I hope at least) win. She's always not quite been on the same level as those two, and I think she has remarked about that in the past... and it's true. *First girl does not always mean she will end up with mc. *Hiratsuka is the reason why Hikki is in the club. *Having similarities does not always make for good compatibility. |
|
| Who the hell votes for Miura?!! LOL. And while Iroha is a great character that gives a spark to the series, I don't get how people love her so much. She's a sly girl, hiding behind a facade and weaseling her way into Hachiman's life, while being a bucketload of work for him. She doesn't have the sincerity and cuteness of Yui or the intellect or beauty of Yukino. |
| Yes yes, I was finally able to vote for Yui. Thanks for providing me with this opportunity. But seriously, I like all the girls (and Saika) in this anime. When it comes to interactions tho, I like Hikki and Yui's the best. |
 |
Brego1 said: Who the hell votes for Miura?!! LOL. And while Iroha is a great character that gives a spark to the series, I don't get how people love her so much. She's a sly girl, hiding behind a facade and weaseling her way into Hachiman's life, while being a bucketload of work for him. She doesn't have the sincerity and cuteness of Yui or the intellect or beauty of Yukino. Well, she has imouto features. XD and examine her "rejections" to Hikki, it will turn to subtle "confessions" everytime she says it. :) |
|
testamentKAISER said: DriveYouCrazy said: Yukinon is the first girl, the reason he is in the club, the girl most similar to him, the one with which he has the best dialogue. Has to be Yukinon. Yui will be a "close" second imo, but will not (I hope at least) win. She's always not quite been on the same level as those two, and I think she has remarked about that in the past... and it's true. *First girl does not always mean she will end up with mc. *Hiratsuka is the reason why Hikki is in the club. *Having similarities does not always make for good compatibility. I agree with this, a mainstream example is Naruto. Because he end up with Hinata, the supporting character and not the first girl, Sakura. So there's always hope for secondary characters like Yui or Iroha. |
|
testamentKAISER said: DriveYouCrazy said: Yukinon is the first girl, the reason he is in the club, the girl most similar to him, the one with which he has the best dialogue. Has to be Yukinon. Yui will be a "close" second imo, but will not (I hope at least) win. She's always not quite been on the same level as those two, and I think she has remarked about that in the past... and it's true. *First girl does not always mean she will end up with mc. *Hiratsuka is the reason why Hikki is in the club. *Having similarities does not always make for good compatibility. Agree'd especially on the last part. Brego1 said: Who the hell votes for Miura?!! LOL. And while Iroha is a great character that gives a spark to the series, I don't get how people love her so much. She's a sly girl, hiding behind a facade and weaseling her way into Hachiman's life, while being a bucketload of work for him. She doesn't have the sincerity and cuteness of Yui or the intellect or beauty of Yukino. She's basically like Hikki's girl version but with good appearance. |
| |
DarklordVor said: testamentKAISER said: Just ignore, he/she might be bitter about Kawasomething x Hikki not getting adapted in the anime. (Although i am bitter about that too. ) Well yeah :( too bad Kawasaki and Keika don't get a scene. Most of Kawasaki's scene gets omitted a lot. Something like that happened and they skipped it? *time to read the LN* |
| |
| I saw a statement of the author saying he's not gonna end the series like other Rom/Coms. What does he mean by that? |
Soli18 said: I saw a statement of the author saying he's not gonna end the series like other Rom/Coms. What does he mean by that? If thats a fact then he probably meant no gf/bf ending. Im expecting a bitter sweet ending from this. |
| |
SansrivaaL said: Soli18 said: I saw a statement of the author saying he's not gonna end the series like other Rom/Coms. What does he mean by that? If thats a fact then he probably meant no gf/bf ending. Im expecting a bitter sweet ending from this. Ugh that's gonna hurt. |
| yui is the best one |
Soli18 said: I saw a statement of the author saying he's not gonna end the series like other Rom/Coms. What does he mean by that? Can you link us to a source on that? |
SansrivaaL said: DarklordVor said: Well yeah :( too bad Kawasaki and Keika don't get a scene. Most of Kawasaki's scene gets omitted a lot. Something like that happened and they skipped it? *time to read the LN* Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. |
|
DarklordVor said: SansrivaaL said: Something like that happened and they skipped it? *time to read the LN* Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. Sagami? dang that would have been a good comedy episode! how dare they skip that part! Theyre putting everything on Yukino/Yui and Iroha too much! not that I dont have a problem with that tho, just a pity, would have lol'd at that part animated. |
| |
SansrivaaL said: DarklordVor said: Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. Sagami? dang that would have been a good comedy episode! how dare they skip that part! Theyre putting everything on Yukino/Yui and Iroha too much! not that I dont have a problem with that tho, just a pity, would have lol'd at that part animated. Yeah, Sagami. Damn because of Kawasaki role in season 1 is omitted a lot, the season 2 can't just pop up Kawasaki as a romantic interest or regular supporting character because that would confuse anime only viewers. |
|
| Neither Yui nor Yukino really stood out for me, neither in S1 and even more so season. 8man interacting with other girls is proving to be just as interesting. Sadly, there hasn't been much of Shizuka this season either. Instead, there's quite a bit of Isshiki and there's some small chemistry moving along between her & 8man, though it most likely won't go too far(the ship won't sail but I'd still like to see them become friends). 8man's carrying this season more so than the 1st and among all the other characters, I find his interactions with Hayama to be the most interesting so far. |
DarklordVor said: Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. I'm gonna have to express my honest opinion here: I'm glad they chose not to adapt that part. It distracts us from the more urgent matter at that time, it unnecessarily complicates things, and makes this series more closely resemble a harem, making the interpersonal drama harder to take seriously. Her entire existence is currently inessential to the story. Having said that, I want her to have greater relevance befitting a supporting role, but not as a romantic interest. She should be doing something apart from just existing. |
supracseduch said: DarklordVor said: Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. I'm gonna have to express my honest opinion here: I'm glad they chose not to adapt that part. It distracts us from the more urgent matter at that time, it unnecessarily complicates things, and makes this series more closely resemble a harem, making the interpersonal drama harder to take seriously. Her entire existence is currently inessential to the story. Having said that, I want her to have greater relevance befitting a supporting role, but not as a romantic interest. She should be doing something apart from just existing. Well said. I hear a lot of complaint about all these little things that the anime didn't adapt from the LN and I think it's a bit unfair. Little things like that make the LN more interesting yes, but in the anime i feel like it would just take up too much time for 20 min. episodes. |
supracseduch said: DarklordVor said: Yeah even earlier in the novel, supposed to be in season 1, there should be an exchange between Hachiman and Kawasaki when he's looking for that annoying woman trying to be president of student council. Hachiman said Lol I wonder why that don't get adapted. I'm gonna have to express my honest opinion here: I'm glad they chose not to adapt that part. It distracts us from the more urgent matter at that time, it unnecessarily complicates things, and makes this series more closely resemble a harem, making the interpersonal drama harder to take seriously. Her entire existence is currently inessential to the story. Having said that, I want her to have greater relevance befitting a supporting role, but not as a romantic interest. She should be doing something apart from just existing. Yeah I actually kind of agree, pretty much all of Kawasaki scene with Hachiman is for gag or fun. A 20 minutes episode of 13 episodes would be hard to adapt everything :/ |
|
SansrivaaL said: Soli18 said: I saw a statement of the author saying he's not gonna end the series like other Rom/Coms. What does he mean by that? If thats a fact then he probably meant no gf/bf ending. Im expecting a bitter sweet ending from this. Alot of rom/coms end on bittersweet no gf/bf ending, so i donno about that. In all likelihood, i expect it to be something original, or something more similar to how such a scenario would play out in reality. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 21, 2015 |
673 |
by MylanP
»»
Yesterday, 8:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 25, 2015 |
1006 |
by MidnightStar5
»»
Dec 27, 2024 6:53 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 4, 2015 |
545 |
by JavanyXD
»»
Dec 25, 2024 10:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 2, 2015 |
527 |
by powermaiden02
»»
Dec 1, 2024 2:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 11, 2015 |
481 |
by hanyuhi16
»»
Nov 30, 2024 12:56 PM |