pakoko said:dokidokidoing said:
I hope you don't mind me giving my two cents about the show.
I like Lisa. I've never been part of an abusive household, but I have been bullied several times in the past, and I identify heavily with her desire to please, be useful and to fit in. I'll be the first to admit that that's an overpowering desire that doesn't always make you act rationally. The things I was doing in my early/mid-teens... you'd honestly think I should've known better (heh...). She's a lost kid trying to fit in with other lost kids, but the problem is that these other kids are facing circumstances that are way out of her depth- something that didn't fully hit her until this episode. People say that she doesn't really belong anywhere... I think that's kind of the point.
As for Five... I think her character actually makes sense considering the background we've been given. We know that she, Nine and Twelve were from an institution that essentially robbed them of their identities. Nine and Twelve escaped, but Five didn't, so I'm assuming that she completed whatever conditioning process that the institution offered. Because of that, Five's development and maturity has been messed up. Simply put, she's a unbalanced kid stuck in a more mature woman's body. I'd go out on a limb and say that Nine and Twelve would probably have ended up like her if they hadn't escaped. I think it's interesting to note that she chose to embrace this hollow, childish insanity- Nine implied that she could have escaped from the institution if she wanted to. The following is purely speculation, but maybe it's her way of making up for the loss of her previous identity. The show never struck me as being particularly realistic in the first place, so her character didn't really bother me.
At its core, I think Zankyou no Terror is a story about outcasts trying to connect with each other. As much as I enjoy how the show handles things thematically, and as much as I enjoy the visual storytelling (I think this is one of those shows where the visuals/cinematography/music are as important as the dialogue in helping viewers fill the blanks), it isn't perfect. I think it's obvious that Watanabe wanted the show to be equal parts psychological study/social commentary and action thriller, but he hasn't really succeeded in weaving those elements together. So he chooses to deal with them separately instead. Mind you, I think he deals with each individual topic well enough, but the narrative would have been smoother if he'd somehow meshed the two together. And I think this disjoint in the narrative isn't a recent problem- in my opinion, it was present even in the earlier episodes, though it manifested differently then.
It's definitely refreshing to see your comment amongst comments that more or less all say the same thing about Lisa or Five. I definitely get that characters have been a problem for this show, but the main focus of this show is not necessarily about the characters' development. Some people are so caught up about Lisa doing something stupid or Five acting like a classic villain (what does that even mean?) that they're like "See? there she does it again!" like it matters hugely looking at the series as a whole. The show has so much more to offer than just its weak characters, like the story, great cinematography, beautiful animation, and amazing soundtrack that it doesn't make much sense to rate this show lowly because one (or two) character(s) ruins it for viewers.
Lisa was not supposed to be anyone special. I don't know what people's expectations were, but she wasn't supposed to be some super intelligent hacker or some secretly crazy arson. She's a completely average, softspoken girl that just happened to witness Nine and Twelve during the first bombing. Have you ever considered a scenario in which the protagonist is actually not that special? Put yourself in Lisa's shoes. If you were to be picked up by two skilled terrorists, chances are you'd mess up just like Lisa. Sometimes people are forgetting that we're not watching a shounen anime in which Lisa will develop some hidden ability. She's an outcast in a realistic society that is trying hard to fit in and do something right for a change, but keeps failing miserably. She's practically been doing nothing her whole life, but I guess people expected that she'll suddenly become a crazy good terrorist or develop into some strong, outspoken hero. She shouldn't be bashed on every single week for every single stupid thing she does, but I suggest that people wait to see or at least theorize why she's one of the main protagonists despite her being a VERY unlikely protagonist.
Five's circumstances are not known 100%. But like you said, she probably didn't want to become who she was right now. It's implied that she was experimented on with various drugs, and we see her suffering some withdrawal symptoms as a result of drug addiction or overdose. We get a glimpse of Five's true character this episode for the first time and people still hate her as a "classic villain" because of a couple mean things she said to Lisa. Rather, she only seems evil and psychotic because she is desperately trying to kill Nine and Twelve. We'll have to wait to see what her exact reasons are, but she's certainly suffering. It's like if she doesn't kill Nine and Twelve soon she'll die or experience something along the lines of death. She's been downright evil not caring about who she kills because whatever the consequences are of failing to kill Nine and Twelve is driving Five insane and making her fearful.
Well said on your last paragraph. Watanabe definitely isn't perfect in his execution of this show, and because he was trying to approach the psychological study/social commentary and action thriller together, it's understandable that he'd sacrifice characters to become more like plot devices in order to deliver a story strong enough for a 1-cour.