Which best describes your feelings regarding the show's conclusion?
| So, I think it's safe to say that the series finale was a bit... divisive. One needs only to read a few pages of the episode 12 discussion to grasp that. I am curious, however - on which exactly side does everyone fall, and with what reasoning? Perhaps you would've been more in favor of a Kirie or Momoe path, or simply disliked Yuuko as a character. Maybe you just couldn't accept the idea of a human/ghost relationship, and wanted a more "realistic" ending. Perhaps you were just looking for something well-written, regardless of the outcome, and don't feel as though you got it. Then again, maybe you were happy when Yuuko returned, but, deep down, wish they'd done it with more dignity (they could've at least dedicated more than 30 seconds, right?). Or, on the other hand, perhaps you're completely satisfied with the ending as it was, and wouldn't change a thing. Thus, in the interest of science, a poll. |
| I think it was quite befitting. The comeback was expected due to the whimsical nature of Yuuko. Every story does not have to be a Greek tragedy to be good. A good ending doesn't mean it has to be sad. |
bla bla bla The endless debate between fans and haters. At one point, after spending a lot of time on MAL, you just realize it's totally pointless.Niko-kun said: On MAL, everyone who has used the lame rating system becomes a critic and an intellectual by default, haven't you heard? |
| He actully says that she possing him now so I take that to mean she's haunting him and not the school building. So she goes where he goes rather then having to say on the school grounds. Loved the ending myself as I really dislike sad endings and can do without bittersweet ones as well. |
Valkyrie-Ryu said: I wouldn't change a thing actually. Though it's tempting to assume that it's a cliche ending for her to come back, I think it actually fits with the story.. it was about love, and well, how could they forget about each other so easily? That love had healed Yuuko and made her accept her past, and it was continuing to grow. If she had disappeared it would have been an awkward closure to their relationship because their relationship was going very well so really there was no reason to end it. Hence Yuuko came back. tl;dr Her coming back highlighed the theme of "power of love" Even before episode 12, I was kind of wondering why unfulfilled love wouldn't continue to bind her to the mortal world - after all, it's not altogether different than the earthly regrets that made her a ghost in the first place. Of course, with that in mind, one can't help but wonder why she was disappearing at all. Did she really reach the precipice of some afterlife before bouncing back, or was she just trolling? Some have called it a "new haunting," although that was only loosely illustrated. Trav644 said: Oh also, wtf is he gonna do when he gets thrown in the Effin loony bin? people already think theres something wrong with him, seeing how he talks to himself in public 24/7. A possibility. Although, to be fair, Yuuko seems perfectly capable of interacting with any physical object or person (it's never quite explained why nobody notices when she's wearing real clothes), and is apparently visible to anyone who "believes in her." If she can indeed leave the school at the end, I suppose there's not a whole lot else holding her back. Plus, Teiichi will never have to pay full price for date night at the movie theater. |
ArdRaeiss said: Cons: in e12 Momoe totally aware on Yuuko-Teiichi relationships, yet she can't see her. True. I don't recall if they ever gave a better explanation, but, in Momoe's case, they seemed to be eschewing consistency in favor of comedy. |
wakka9ca said: Every story does not have to be a Greek tragedy to be good. A good ending doesn't mean it has to be sad. Don't assume people who would prefer a sad ending prefers sad endings in general. I myself would not mind a happy end. If you watch Clannad, then you should know I loved their ending very much. The reason I didn't like this happy end because it was forced. It wasn't good writing. They just decided to put the final 2 minutes there just to create a "love forever" ending. No I do not hate TeichiiXYuuko pairing. In fact I love them. The final 2 minutes threw away all the emotional impact of the farewell scene. That scene was so perfectly bittersweet and the background music made me love it even more. It reminded me of Sweet November's ending. True, a good ending doesn't mean it has to be sad. I can also say a good ending doesn't need to be a happy one either which is what the writers were thinking when they forced the last 2 minutes. It in fact has to be well developed and not just throw a scene out there just to make it into a happy end. The story was developing for an ending where Yuuko rests in peace. Therefore I was very disappointed when I hear Yuuko's voice after Keichii opened the box. But still, a great anime overall. |
| How could anyone have a problem with GHOST SEX END? |
| Considering that the last episode was wonderfully done. The whole last date preparing for her to disappear was reminiscent of a Key anime and as such was well implemented. Manly tears wanted to come out as she vanished, they didnt and it's just as well as the whole point of the episode got turned on it's head when all of a sudden Yuuko is back. Personally I would have preferred her to have disappeared, it would have been a good ending for me in the regard that Teiichi could finally let go and move on like she wished him to do. A potential future romance with the very real Kirie got thrown completely out of the window. |
 |
| The ending was awesome! That is all. |
 |
| The last episode was pretty shitty and cliche overall which is kind of shame because up to that point the second half of the anime had been very good at capturing the proper bittersweet emotions of this type of love story. I was really bored with the anime up to the point where Yuuko disappeared which made me think a little higher, even if I still think that scene could have had so much more emotional impact, of course that was all ruined when she came back and it solidified my hate for this episode. Yuuko's murder has been solved, her two halves have been reconciled and she finally had someone love her for her to disappear after all of that would have been bittersweet not really sad. She was a ghost that got a bit of true happiness before going to her final rest, that ain't a greek tragedy that is actually pretty sweet and little sad. However, the anime had to pull a bitch move and ruin a lot of what was good about the second half of the series. So for me this ending was nothing short of a disaster. However, in the end I still think the anime was decent just deeply flawed. The anime started terribly but improved with each episode until by the second half it had gotten to be very good but sadly that horrible ending had to come along and leave a very bitter taste on my tongue. Overall because of the terrible beginning and horrible last episode I can't call this anime good but I can say it's decent. And it was certainly more capable of getting it's emotions across than the completely boring Sankarea. |
 |
| Personally guys I am a sucker for happy endings especially when there's romance involved. Although the ending couldve been handled better you have to note that the series has not ended so the animators had to do something to just make an ending. Im sure the ending the author makes will be perfect. Also don't overthink it about how they can live together its an anime and it really doesn't matter; heck in anime rules of life don't apply for all I know the dude could become a shaman and bring her back to life...point is WHO CARES? If you're looking for realistic watch a autobiography or live action. |
 |
| +1 on ending cant believe its over now |
| Cty Best mid |
Craziel said: duowolf said: He actully says that she possing him now so I take that to mean she's haunting him and not the school building. So she goes where he goes rather then having to say on the school grounds. This is how I interpreted it as well. Instead of haunting the school, she now haunts him. And now they can live happily together until Teiichi dies of old age and go to Heaven together :) |
 GET DROPBOX HERE! Bonus space for you and me with this link! Now 500MB per referral, up to 16GB from referrals alone. |
| They really should gone with the sad final. Way better! |
| ... |
| 90% of male with good taste = sad ending 90% of female = happy ending b/c they're so cute together /thread |
 |
ricardocsc said: They really should gone with the sad final. Way better! Yeah, the sad ending would be more realistic. At least Teiichi could start a real family in the future. However, the happy ending was also good. Just like what 'linchpin' mentioned: they can go to heaven together. They both wont have any heavy regrets of leaving one behind. I guess I have mixed feelings for the ending. All I know is, I hope there's a season 2 since she's back and all that. lol |
You can just be yourself. Do things your own way, one step at a time. You'll get there. Just be yourself, you'll be fine." ~Fruit Basket |
| Touching ending although I wasn't expecting it to turn out to be a happy ending. I loved it. |
| Nekomimi~ |
| From the very start it felt extremely obvious and cliche if she would disappear. But this anime approached it in a good way and then ofc, the moment when she disappeared. But then she unexpectedly(for me) came back. Though it was good. Some may think that my reasoning is retarded.. But it feel good for me. I guess that's what's important. :3 |
Valkyrie-Ryu said: I wouldn't change a thing actually. Though it's tempting to assume that it's a cliche ending for her to come back, I think it actually fits with the story.. it was about love, and well, how could they forget about each other so easily? That love had healed Yuuko and made her accept her past, and it was continuing to grow. If she had disappeared it would have been an awkward closure to their relationship because their relationship was going very well so really there was no reason to end it. Hence Yuuko came back. tl;dr Her coming back highlighed the theme of "power of love" I agree. I absolutely loved this ending. |
Valkyrie-Ryu said: I wouldn't change a thing actually. Though it's tempting to assume that it's a cliche ending for her to come back, I think it actually fits with the story.. it was about love, and well, how could they forget about each other so easily? That love had healed Yuuko and made her accept her past, and it was continuing to grow. If she had disappeared it would have been an awkward closure to their relationship because their relationship was going very well so really there was no reason to end it. Hence Yuuko came back. tl;dr Her coming back highlighed the theme of "power of love" This & what duowolf said is how I felt about it. |
Aoi_sekai said: I hated the ending. She had to disappear. As she said, ghosts aren't supposed to be in the world of the living. She reunited with her other side and accepted the fact she ended up being a sacrifice. Now, there's nothing to hold her back. Loving Teiichi isn't a reason to come back. So all other people who died and moved on didn't love anyone? Poor guy... Even if he stops loving her, he will be hauted for the rest of his life... Couldn't agree more. |
| I disliked it. I wish Yuuko would have just disappeared and stayed that way. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Tasogare Otome x Amnesia Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )tsubasalover - Jun 3, 2012 |
144 |
by yumos07
»»
Nov 9, 7:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Tasogare Otome x Amnesia Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 24, 2012 |
572 |
by Kodreyu
»»
Oct 1, 6:39 AM |
|
Poll: » Tasogare Otome x Amnesia Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )tsubasalover - May 6, 2012 |
105 |
by little_raven
»»
Jul 28, 7:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Tasogare Otome x Amnesia Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Shih - Apr 29, 2012 |
147 |
by little_raven
»»
Jul 28, 1:17 PM |
|
Poll: » Tasogare Otome x Amnesia Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )tsubasalover - Apr 8, 2012 |
306 |
by gswelcome
»»
Jul 28, 5:13 AM |