Do you think Kyoto Animation should remake the ONE animé?
| Well? |
| I think they should. Tt feels like it will be on-par with the Key-trio but the thing is that it probably won't happen since One belongs to Tactics and not Key...which is pretty sad. :( |
     |
| 2 words "without a doubt!" It's a great story that not so many people know, it's kind of sad :/ |
| It would be cool if they made a KyoAni anime :) Unless they would do the same thing they did with Clannad.. it sucks that we have to wait so much for the real end... |
 |
| CLANNAD was nothing more than a cash grab from the get go. . . So I wasn't surprised when they decided to release the ending as an OVA to make even MORE money. @Aisu: ONE has already been animated twice. I'm not sure if they got permission to even do it or not. Bottom line is, if Kyoto Ani wants to do it, I'm pretty sure they will do it. |
Quintessence said: CLANNAD was nothing more than a cash grab from the get go True... still loved some parts of it :) I actually didn't watch the One anime... is it good or I shouldn't waste my time, and wait for KyoAni to do it? XD |
|
SunyiNyufi said: Don't waste your time. At least not with the clean one. Apparently the H version is closer to the actual story, but I have no interest in watching an H version of ONE. The Tsukihime animé was actually better than the ONE animé. And THAT's saying something. . . The animé changed the stories (Mio could talk, Nanase's story was way off, etc.) and sort of tried to fill in the year gap where Kouhei is MIA. It was very confusing.I actually didn't watch the One anime... is it good or I shouldn't waste my time, and wait for KyoAni to do it? XD |
Quintessence said: @Aisu: ONE has already been animated twice. I'm not sure if they got permission to even do it or not. Bottom line is, if Kyoto Ani wants to do it, I'm pretty sure they will do it. Yeah that's true. I welcome a new/better anime for ONE by KyoAni anytime, with open arms. :D |
|
| @ Quintessence: Sounds awful :S Well then I wait for KyoAni :D |
|
| It WAS awful. What made it worse is that I watched it BEFORE I played the game. |
| Uhhh, that suxx :S It was the same for me with Tsukihime... although I liked the anime, but the game is so much better (well I only played Arc's route yet) and less confusing! But I think original is always better be it a game, a manga or a novel :) |
|
| heck yea! One's heavily underrated and needs a remake D: and kyo-ani's VN adaptations are holy... I watched the non-H anime of One before playing the game too. what a waste of time. it had no actual plot and kohei and shun we're so similar i couldn't keep them apart >__> i gave it a 3. 1 point for the effort and 2 for the fact it is a Key-adaptation. |
| I see I'm not the only one who could not tell Kouhei and Shun apart. . . |
| YES. PLAIN AND SIMPLE, YES. Screw those OVAs. I want a decent-length ONE anime. 24 episodes. I think it'd outsell Air easy. Maybe even Kanon. |
You can find me on IRC. |
| In terms of profit, summoning a classic from the grave and enhancing it makes more golden eggs than a chicken. But in terms of quality, I still think AIR is better (most people will agree on this if KyoAni made a faithful 24-ep version instead of the crappy 13+2 version). And this is one hell of a poll, 100% voted for "Hell yes!" |
| That's because we all have the superior opinion. XD Anyway, whether it would outsell Air or not, I know I'd like it more. :| I'd even bump Kanon off my fave anime list for ONE if it was done right. |
KuyuJul 6, 2008 4:51 PM
You can find me on IRC. |
| Lol why kick out Kanon for ONE? Both are great stories and deserve to be on the top list of every Key fan. The other non-Key work is expendable >.>; |
| I actually think that ONE is better than Kanon. I played a bit of the partial patch that Haeleth made for Kanon and, in my opinion, there is a high level of repetitiveness between the 2. Nanase also made a cameo in the Kanon game that I've seen so far http://hibikipics.250free.com/39206.jpg possibly a 2nd during the ball. I saw a blue haired girl wearing Nanase's light green dress but she was back on and far in the background. Regardless, her appearance in the animé was no coincidence. |
| i think they should remake it. the ova i saw failed epicly. and i'd really like to see how these characters look in kyoani form. does anyone have a screen shot of nanase's cameo in the kanon anime? i missed it when i initially watched it and i dont feel like searching through the series to find it. :D |
 |
| They really should remake the ONE anime. The game was so brilliant, yet they gave the anime so little attention. If KyoAni do a remake, that would extremely awesome. The story was so well crafted, I liked it better than Kanon and would put it on par with Clannad. The only issue I would have with a remake is that it would be likely to centralize around Nagamori, which is the route I least want to see animated. I guess you can't have your cake and eat it too =\. |
| Screen shot? No. But I DO have an animated .gif with Nanase in it. http://i238.photobucket.com/albums/ff2/HibikiRyouga/Sigs n Stuff/Dance.gif She's the girl in the far left in the background. |
| It's gone Quintessence :/ Man...I almost feel like we should start a petition for this. :O I know petitions are worthless more often than not but it's not like it wouldn't be worth a try :D |
You can find me on IRC. |
| Because there are spaces it seems you need to copy/paste the URL. http://i238.photobucket.com/albums/ff2/HibikiRyouga/Sigs n Stuff/Dance.gif Petitions almost never work. But I'd like to think there's a glimmer of hope, eh? I have signed a few petitions in the past (for Viz to finish releasing the Maison Ikkoku animé and for Bandai to bring the Banner of the Stars III animé to North America) and I'd certainly sign this one. Not much I wouldn't do for my precious Akane. <3 |
| I think it would be a brilliant anime if it was remade. The story and characters were so good in the visual novel. I think if it was layed out like Kanon 2006 (24 episodes, a certain amount of episodes dedicated to a certain character) it would be a absoloute hit! I would love to see Mio in her full glory in an anime like that! ^^ |
| I really wish KyoAni would make their ONE adaptation. Non Hentai OVA was complete waste of time. I don't remember anything from it. At least H OVA followed story a bit. |
| I think visual arts should make it |
| Fuckin Hell Yes!!! (I'm late D:) They really should remake it. The OVAs was sucks, well at lease there is my favorite quote that Misaki asks Kouhei to rate the sunset, But then again Kouhei and Shun looks "so what from alike". The H OVAs was WAY better than the OVAs, but i want to see Nanase, Mio and Mayu, too, not only my most favorite characters (Misaki rules and FTW!). I wish ONE2 is translate, althou it's not from Tactics, well fuck it! ONE is ONE, Make a god damn anime of ONE already, KyoAni!!!! |
More topics from this board
» ONE VN REMAKE!!!Quintessence - Aug 7, 2022 |
0 |
by Quintessence
»»
Aug 7, 2022 6:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Favorite RouteRengemaru - May 25, 2008 |
29 |
by Norman87
»»
Dec 18, 2011 1:54 PM |