| As the title states let's try to create a combined toplist of anime. To have a large enough pool to start from everyone should submit a top15 list ordered from #1-#15. Anime that are named 3 times are guaranteed a spot of course. Their placing should be obvious due to indivudual list placement but should ultimately be up for us all to agree on. The same goes for all other titles. Discuss and agree. This would of course go a lot faster per skype or whatever but we can create a first base for discussion here and I don't see time pressing anyway. I'll add all titles agreed upon to the club relations. |
 |
| 1. Aria the Origination 2. Hunter x Hunter (2011) 3. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 4. Nana 5. Fate/Zero 6. Natsume Yuujinchou 7. Seirei no Moribito 8. Kara no Kyoukai 9. Seikai no Monshou 10. One Piece 11. Gankutsuou 12. Bakemonogatari 13. Shoujo Kakumei Utena 14. Ookami to Koushinryou 15. Chihayafuru 2 Gosh, 15 is awfully few... |
ZylixaeMay 19, 2013 6:23 AM
|
Ha! I bet when you start listing, 15 would feel small. But the higher the number, the less worthy they are. Also, I've taken you meant 15 personal favourites rather than "scores" in anime quality. Also, I assume there's the option to update our lists should our favorites change with time?
|
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
| Quality and favourites kinda goes hand in hand for most titles. If I'd lean more to the pure favourite/enjoyment side I'd switch out 1 or 2 titles just because of their short duration. Valid point for this kind of thing though. /edited |
|
Had to :P |
| #PrayForKyoAni |
| Ok a quick glance tells me that we don't have any anime thrice which is kind of a problem. Anyway gonna do a detailed tally later got dancing class this evening...ye we gotta do that for real. |
|
| Which dance is this? Do you have access to YouTube uploads? |
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
| Tally: 2 Votes - 10 entries: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 2 Nana 2 Fate/Zero 2 Natsume Yuujinchou 2 Kara no Kyoukai 2 One Piece 2 Bakemonogatari 2 Ookami to Koushinryou 2 Great Teach Onizuka 2 Steins;Gate 2 1 Vote - 25 Entries Aria the Origination Hunter x Hunter (2011) Seirei no Moribito Seikai no Monshou Gankutsuou Shoujo Kakumei Utena Chihayafuru 2 Slam Dunk Skip Beat! Darker Than Black Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom Claymore Code Geass Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann Binbougami ga! Ouran High Host Club Mobile Suit Gundam Kobato. Welcome to the NHK! Tiger & Bunny Mushishi Yu Yu Hakusho Gintama Hajime no Ippo Uchuu Kyoudai Total - 45 Votes - Checks out We are getting lessons for all the standard dances since the modern Airforce officer has class and knows to dance it seems. Like waltz, foxtrot, discofox, cha-cha-cha and so on... |
ZylixaeMay 22, 2013 9:04 AM
|
| Ok so what are we gonna do with that? Do we need to add more votes for everyone? Or should we confirm the 2 votes anime for now? As in, the one not submitting them approves of them, asks for discussion or disapproves as is. Which would look like this for me: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 2 Nana 2 Fate/Zero 2 Natsume Yuujinchou 2 Kara no Kyoukai 2 One Piece 2 Bakemonogatari 2 Ookami to Koushinryou 2 Great Teach Onizuka 2 - Convince me. Steins;Gate 2 - Approved. Interestingly enough 8 out of my 15 votes got a 2nd vote, yay! If we wanted a top10 this would be enough already if agreed upon all. Do you want to list more? |
|
| Looks fab. Nice work. The top 10 would be absolute since they are the most voted. I'm happy with those 10. For 11th - 15th, I suggest we pick the best overall series that all three of us have watched, scored highest, and been nominated above? Which would be in the following order: 1. Hunter x Hunter (2011) - 10+10 +no score 2. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - 10+9+8 = 27 3. Kobato. 10+9+8 = 27 4. Skip Beat! 9+9+9 =27 5. Tiger & Bunny 10+8+7 = 25 How's that? |
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
| Sounds like a good idea for 11th to 15th while I'd have to consider if TTGL and T&B are worth an entry as I see many other entries with 1 vote/1 score (for ex. Gankutsuou, Gintama) as better contenders. |
|
| Things are looking good so far. I have no complaints with the current top 10. Further discussion will be made once Zylizae's compiles the entries for #'s 11-15. Since it looks like we're following Boa's idea the following are anime shared between all of us. Kobato. - 27 Skip Beat! - 27 Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - 26 Tiger & Bunny - 25 Darker Than Black - 23 Claymore - 23 Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom 22 Hunter x Hunter (2011) - 20 Gintama - 10 How does this work out? Do we need to list out any additional favorites? Maybe an honorable mention or two. |
| #PrayForKyoAni |
| Ok so I wouldn't jump the gun on 11-15 because I find as I said some entries we share highly doubtable or I simply wouldn't put them on the favourites-level. Kobato. - No doubt.A totally legit entry among those. Would agree. Ranking discussable. Skip Beat! - Really close to falling of the high cliff of the word favourite but still good enough. I'd tolerate that with my name under it. TTGL - Totally not happening in my book. It's entertaining as fuck but just as dull and has the depth of a childs picture book. Hunter x Hunter 2011 - 100% needed entry in this list. If Boa watches a few more eps or would watch from start we'd have an easy 30 points entry as top3 contender. Claymore - Ending too bad. No Chance. Gintama - I see the potential but can't get around to watch more. Wouldn't dismiss but can't judge it. The thing you expected. Of course! Aria the Origination - Also a shared entry but BN too lazy to watch. Same story as Gintama but the other way around. A honorable mention as someone's #1 favourite or whatever would be cool with these 2 cases for example. /discuss |
|
| Agree with the honorable mentions list where our personal favorites can sit. HunterxHunter 2011 is good, I don't rate series I haven't completed but I'll go with having it on the list. Happy with Kobato and Skip Beat!. You and BN Aria highly, I got it downloaded to watch over the summer. I'm happy to accept this as well. We don't necessarily need to have 15 series, right? Zy can make it a dozen if we run out of titles. |
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
| You a word there. Could make a dirty dozen but I'd be happier with 15. With 12 we'd already kick one out between Skip Beat, Kobato and HxH. Need to hear BN's take on which shared shows to include. |
|
| I'll gladly take Hunter x Hunter 2011, Kobato., Skip Beat! and Aria for for our remaining honorable entries. For our last one how about we put Ouran Koukou Host Club. Boa and I share this favorite. While it may not be in my 15 I still hold it to high regard as one of the best reverse-harem still. My finalize take will look like this, just unordered. I grouped a few series such as all of Aria and the Monogatari series. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Nana Fate/Zero Natsume Yuujinchou Kara no Kyoukai One Piece Monogatari Series Spice & Wolf Great Teach Onizuka Steins;Gate ----------------------------- Aria Hunter x Hunter (2011) Kobato. Ouran High School Host Club Skip Beat! |
| #PrayForKyoAni |
| Happy with this |
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
| I've got a really blurry memory of Ouran HSHC. I watched this anime way too early when I barely was around 25 completed shows so most of the parody went past my head but it was kinda funny anyway.I can live it being in there as we lack many other options or I dismissed some of those already. Sadly you guys didn't watch Utena or Gankutsuou which would make this way easier. :P Now that we got our top10 + 5 we should come up with a ranking. Combined points: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 20 Nana 19 Fate/Zero 28 + 28 / 2 = 28 Natsume Yuujinchou 18 + 19 + 19 + 20 / 4 = 19 Kara no Kyoukai (using only 7 and 5 cuz lazy) 27 + 27 / 2 = 27 One Piece 19 Monogatari Series 26 + 17 + 18 / 3 = 20,3 Spice & Wolf 27 + 18 / 2 = 22,5 Great Teach Onizuka 20 Steins;Gate 28 Going strict by math we got a ordered top10 like this: 1 - Fate/Zero 1 - Steins;Gate 3 - Kara no Kyoukai 4 - Spice & Wolf 5 - Monogatari Series 6 - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 6 - Great Teach Onizuka 7 - Nana 7 - One Piece 7 - Natsume Yuujinchou However we got a huge fault here as some series are not rated by all of us even when watching. A current score would benefit the math here. For shows not even started by someone that doesn't help though. I think we should take this as a rough guideline and discuss the order. I for one would never put FMA:Brotherhood anywhere outside the top3. Steins;Gate and Fate/Zero are both great but Brotherhood just defines the perfect shounen. There's not a single flaw in this show in my eyes. High rank for Kara no Kyoukai pretty cool but inaccurate as I only went with 7 and 5 cause lazy, probably still decent enough. Spice & Wolf only falls behind because a certain someone didn't watch the second season yet. We all loved the first it seems. Boa not rating One Piece as of now gives the math trouble. A score as of now would be nice. Monogatari Series has the same prob as Spice & Wolf. The first season alone would score very high but the sequel/prequel only watched by BN and me. For all the other shows goes the same it lacks 1 person watching them. Considering all that my personal placement: 1 - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 2 - Fate/Zero 3 - Steins;Gate 4 - Kara no Kyoukai 5 - Spice & Wolf 6 - Monogatari Series 7 - Nana 8 - One Piece 9 - Natsume Yuujinchou 10 - Great Teach Onizuka Having FMA:B and Fate/zero as top favorites is pretty mainstream but they are awesome after all and thus mainstream for a reason. That could either benefit or hinder our credit in the future. We are not uber elitist with LOGH but not full blown retards with SAO on top. Cool that Natsume made it into the top10 as a SoL show however I'm equally sad as Aria over all is the better and purer SoL while Natsume has way more supernatural influences...anyway I'm rambling off somewhere else... /discuss I wrote all this in my lunch break and probably wont be in today for more. Tomorrow starts my weekend though, as it's some holiday again. Time for anime from then on if I manage to avoid League of Legends enough. |
ZylixaeMay 28, 2013 4:14 AM
|
| Happy with the top10 order. But they will change as we grow, right? Current scores for the shows watching: One Piece: 6 Happy to see this series near the bottom. Re season twos, can assume the same score as first seasons. FMA:B can assume same score as FMA (8). HxH 2011 same as HxH 90s (9). For the further 5, I personally prefer Skip Beat! over OHSHC due to fillers. Aria Hunter x Hunter (2011) Kobato. Skip Beat! Ouran High School Host Club |
| My Twitter My Tumblr - Anime Blogging on current airing season as I watch them. My deviantArt - Anime FanArts. Please leave replies on my profile page, as I am unlikely to see them otherwise. Thanks. |
More topics from this board
» [STAFF CHAT]BoaCC - May 14, 2013 |
10 |
by BoaCC
»»
Jun 24, 2013 6:13 AM |