Anime on the same level or close

@ktg Damn bro you wrote an essay out of desperation :D

Wtf with whome I am even arguing here 😩😓??? everyone have different taste plus people of different age groups and gender is watching this how can you expect everyone to rate a show same. This might be one of the most brain-dead arguments I have ever heard in my life. There are people who doesn't like S2 of Vinland Saga because there is less action one the other hand there are people who consider it as a Masterpiece. Not everyone have similar taste 😅
???? You are the one who was projecting your subjective opinion not me. I was talking about collective opinions. Majority consider it to be a masterpiece that's why it's being soo highly rated. That's what I meant it's nothing to do with my opinion.

No Joker is not a bad example but OK

In case of Attack on Titan critic and majority of audiance have similar take so I don't see why this example even matters.

@ZXEAN I had to write an essay, because someone wrote a lot of bs. So it's simple math, to refute lot of bs, I had to write a lot of points.


Good job, you refuted yourself. :DDD
Your point was that the rating represents the quality, but it cannot represent the quality if people rate shows based on their taste. Quality has nothing to do with taste. Thank you for agreeing with me. :)


Well, you should read your own statements, because even if I wanted to, I wouldn't be able to make more brain-dead statements than you do. :)
Again, you don't know the difference between pretty simple definitions. Liking or disliking something is different than something being good or bad. The former is subjective, completely depends on your own taste, while the latter is objective and it has nothing to do with you.
You can dislike a masterpiece, but it's still a masterpiece, because that's an objective statement.

Btw, no, Vinland Saga S2 objectively isn't a masterpiece. But it has nothing to do with our arguments. But it doesn't matter what people say, because there are people who say that the Earth is flat, but the Earth won't change its shape because of their statement.


Actually no. From the argument POV, you are also projecting your own subjective opinion on me. Because you cannot accept that someone is smarter than you.
Btw, you also shifted the argument. I wasn't talking about how high the rating is. My point was that the rating has nothing to do with quality and you agree with that, because people have different taste and taste has nothing to do with quality.


It is. The hype needs build up. The Joker franchise where you had only a like a 2 hour long sequel a couple years ago is nowhere near close to a SnK where you waited a decade with more than 20 hours of content.
The cultural impact is really important in these cases, that's why the original Star Wars is a great example.


In what world exactly? I'm anime only, but when the manga ended even I encountered lots of, lots of topic where people talked about how bad the ending was. There was even a petition to force the creators for a new ending.
SnK is one of the rare cases where people were really divided.

Most people are AoT and Muv Luv fans.

Most people likes AoT when it first came out, calling it one of the best dark fantasy titles.

However, as time passes, Isayama felt guilty for AoT success due to ripping off Muv-Luv Alternative, he starts confessing to the public that he is a MLA fanboy and is his main source of inspiration of becoming a mangaka.

This leads to many people getting curious and picking up Muv Luv. And most of them eventually end up liking Muv Luv more than AoT mainly due to worldbuilding.

Well, I am one of minority who picks up Muv Luv before AoT so I can see what Isayama is thinking about when he wrote Eren Yeager. Isayama writes Eren Yeager to answer the question what if Takeru fail to properly develop in Muv Luv.

Most people are AoT and Muv Luv fans.

Most people likes AoT when it first came out, calling it one of the best dark fantasy titles.

However, as time passes, Isayama felt guilty for AoT success due to ripping off Muv-Luv Alternative, he starts confessing to the public that he is a MLA fanboy and is his main source of inspiration of becoming a mangaka.

This leads to many people getting curious and picking up Muv Luv. And most of them eventually end up liking Muv Luv more than AoT mainly due to worldbuilding.

Well, I am one of minority who picks up Muv Luv before AoT so I can see what Isayama is thinking about when he wrote Eren Yeager. Isayama writes Eren Yeager to answer the question what if Takeru fail to properly develop in Muv Luv.

If you loved Shingeki no Kyojin, then I think you're gonna enjoy Koutetsujou no Kabaneri. It looks stunning, has interesting premise, and it was made by Wit Studio as well as SnK.