Forum Settings
Forums
New
Oct 6, 2022 7:25 PM
#1

Offline
Dec 2021
10
This is crazy bruh. I love how insanse it got from 1-100 real quick even tho, none of it made sense. i think, the story should have been ended after naoko came back to life. the author is pretty inconsistent in chapter releases too but i do believe this beloved naoko story is nearing a perfect ending.
what are your thoughts on pumpkin night?
PS. Dont talk about how theres so much gore elements because, this story was not meant for weak hearts from the start.
here's whats going on right now in the series, if you dont wanna read but just wanna know:
Oct 10, 2022 4:47 AM
#2

Offline
Sep 2013
641
It's definitely lost it's direction hard. I mean I do enjoy seeing things from Naoko's perspective too and I can forgive the multiple asspulls because it's not much different from how big slasher film franchises write themselves. But I feel like the future of the story was reconstructed completely after the brief episode of Kazuya finishing the bully job, at the time it seemed like he was a permanent stand-in but now it took this long to even get back to him. And with the Babyface stuff and the current conflict I'm scared that Pumpkin Night is just going to become a gory battle manga over time with more and more superhumans and shit. That development will definitely be dropworthy and I already don't REALLY think it's a quality series in the first place
Oct 10, 2022 7:45 AM
#3
Offline
Apr 2011
286
artemis37 said:
It's definitely lost it's direction hard. I mean I do enjoy seeing things from Naoko's perspective too and I can forgive the multiple asspulls because it's not much different from how big slasher film franchises write themselves. But I feel like the future of the story was reconstructed completely after the brief episode of Kazuya finishing the bully job, at the time it seemed like he was a permanent stand-in but now it took this long to even get back to him. And with the Babyface stuff and the current conflict I'm scared that Pumpkin Night is just going to become a gory battle manga over time with more and more superhumans and shit. That development will definitely be dropworthy and I already don't REALLY think it's a quality series in the first place


Nah it is getting a part 3 and naoko and kazuya already escaped and sae giving up
Oct 10, 2022 8:21 AM
#4

Offline
Dec 2021
10
Toxin456 said:
artemis37 said:
It's definitely lost it's direction hard. I mean I do enjoy seeing things from Naoko's perspective too and I can forgive the multiple asspulls because it's not much different from how big slasher film franchises write themselves. But I feel like the future of the story was reconstructed completely after the brief episode of Kazuya finishing the bully job, at the time it seemed like he was a permanent stand-in but now it took this long to even get back to him. And with the Babyface stuff and the current conflict I'm scared that Pumpkin Night is just going to become a gory battle manga over time with more and more superhumans and shit. That development will definitely be dropworthy and I already don't REALLY think it's a quality series in the first place


Nah it is getting a part 3 and naoko and kazuya already escaped and sae giving up

But you know.. this story was about the revenge on bullies thing of naoko
the author could have just ended this manga and made like a sequel with a separate title or smth. now its like contradicting and no one knows where the story is heading.
it has a prequel which is publishing right now but like, theres no point in the prequel at all
tharunslistOct 10, 2022 8:26 AM
Oct 10, 2022 10:28 AM
#5
Offline
Apr 2011
286
zedallure said:
Toxin456 said:


Nah it is getting a part 3 and naoko and kazuya already escaped and sae giving up

But you know.. this story was about the revenge on bullies thing of naoko
the author could have just ended this manga and made like a sequel with a separate title or smth. now its like contradicting and no one knows where the story is heading.
it has a prequel which is publishing right now but like, theres no point in the prequel at all


Cuz things change bro and the prequel was canceled for low sales

More topics from this board

Poll: » Pumpkin Night Chapter 109 Discussion

zkl - Jun 22, 2024

4 by CQLLIST »»
Aug 28, 2024 12:00 AM

Poll: » Pumpkin Night Chapter 117 Discussion

Lancelots - Aug 15, 2024

1 by 7839647910 »»
Aug 15, 2024 10:08 AM

Poll: » Pumpkin Night Chapter 40 Discussion

Toxin456 - Oct 5, 2020

4 by asmodeustry »»
Jul 22, 2024 8:47 AM

Poll: » Pumpkin Night Chapter 108 Discussion

CQLLIST - Jun 6, 2024

3 by bladewade »»
Jun 6, 2024 8:10 AM

» What do you all think of this manga?

AboutFollower03 - Jul 29, 2023

9 by ExBreaker »»
May 3, 2024 8:17 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login