| I'm talking about the color palette. Just recently I saw the official color release for the manga and I think the color scheme used in that was really cool, stylistic and overall just fit the tone of CSM. I think MAPPA are playing it safe with a 'standard' dark/gore type of color scheme but personally I would have liked it more if they tried to do something more out there like they did with Idaten Deities instead (not to the same extreme though). Spoiler images below to demonstrate what I mean: Funnily enough the new teaser with manga panels has some scenes similar to the above with vibrant and unusual colors, but I doubt any of the animated scenes will have that. Either way I know MAPPA will do a great job, the art and animation in the first trailer looked really clean. Edit: the first few images were from the original color version from the first few chapters, here's some from the new version. It's color shift galore! |
RizaadxnJan 8, 2022 1:41 AM
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
| If it requires more job its complrtly understandable, they have so much jib like jjk, aot, csm, hells laradaise, maybe god of highschool/dorohedoro and more Rizaadxn said: I'm talking about the color palette. Just recently I saw the official color release for the manga and I think the color scheme used in that was really cool, stylistic and overall just fit the tone of CSM. I think MAPPA are playing it safe with a 'standard' dark/gore type of color scheme but personally I would have liked it more if they tried to do something more out there like they did with Idaten Deities instead (not to the same extreme though). Spoiler images below to demonstrate what I mean: Funnily enough the new teaser with manga panels has some scenes similar to the above with vibrant and unusual colors, but I doubt any of the animated scenes will have that. Either way I know MAPPA will do a great job, the art and animation in the first trailer looked really clean. |
Sasuke0 said: If it requires more job its complrtly understandable, they have so much jib like jjk, aot, csm, hells laradaise, maybe god of highschool/dorohedoro and more I know, that's one of the big issues with the anime industry right now, especially studios like MAPPA who are taking on far too many projects at the same time. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Rizaadxn said: read it in black and white and now realising that colored CSM is really cool.I'm talking about the color palette. Just recently I saw the official color release for the manga and I think the color scheme used in that was really cool, stylistic and overall just fit the tone of CSM. I think MAPPA are playing it safe with a 'standard' dark/gore type of color scheme but personally I would have liked it more if they tried to do something more out there like they did with Idaten Deities instead (not to the same extreme though). Spoiler images below to demonstrate what I mean: Funnily enough the new teaser with manga panels has some scenes similar to the above with vibrant and unusual colors, but I doubt any of the animated scenes will have that. Either way I know MAPPA will do a great job, the art and animation in the first trailer looked really clean. |
| Yeah they should, like give their employees a paid leave. |
 |
| well hell's paradise too has fare number of gore stuffs and the trailer was shit . so maybe they will not adapt the blood scenes |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
Swagernator said: Too real man, too real.Yeah they should, like give their employees a paid leave. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
The_Early_Bird said: well hell's paradise too has fare number of gore stuffs and the trailer was shit . so maybe they will not adapt the blood scenes Trailer was shit? What? The fuck? |
Noel_babu said: I actually thought of this too. I mean, jojo's bizzare adventure have done the color palette change multiple times but i still doubt Mappa would do it. Nonetheless, the adaptation will be godly I mean, in the case of Jojo, it was mostly done because it is Araki's style to not have one consistent color scheme for characters. |
| Hard disagree. CSM's atmosphere once animated is way better served with flat colors than neon and hard contrats. |
 |
| I feel like the mappa Chainsaw Man is too smooth, I liked chainsaw man because of how messy the art style was. |
| im fine with what they have right now. if they do that there employs might die |
Sasuke0 said: But they would do far better if they weren't working on so many projects at once, not to mention the fact that animators are more than likely being overworked... Rizaadxn said: I know, that's one of the big issues with the anime industry right now, especially studios like MAPPA who are taking on far too many projects at the same time. No, they deliever every time and dont dissapoint. SquidGame said: Yeah, that's one of my only dislikes about MAPPA, they continue to pick up manga with a rough sketchy style. JJK, CSM and Hell's Paradise all fit under that same type of style but their adaptation ends up being a more smooth clean style, it doesn't look bad by any means, it just doesn't give the same feel.I feel like the mappa Chainsaw Man is too smooth, I liked chainsaw man because of how messy the art style was. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Oongbuh said: what the music and the visuals got you? damn that's being a normal anime fan? read the manga. where is the sea of blood? where are the insects sucking blood honey from humans? where are the naked monsters(female) sucking male's blood. they just showed some criminals and monsters from the manga. not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm.The_Early_Bird said: well hell's paradise too has fare number of gore stuffs and the trailer was shit . so maybe they will not adapt the blood scenes Trailer was shit? What? The fuck? not sure obviously |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
Violet42 said: Idaten Deities animated by MAPPA, it had lots of color palette shifts.I don't think there's many anime at all that use that kind of color scheme, so if you're hoping for that from ANY studio, much less MAPPA, you're in for a world of hurt. What works on the page doesn't necessarily work for an anime, for a variety of reasons. smoother, more uniform colors are much easier to draw and animate. it's the nature of anime adaptation that most will turn out smoother and less jagged than the manga. What you want is more like a motion comic, but if you actually got it, you'd complain. Can you give me any examples of where an anime actually went with this style of coloration? |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
The_Early_Bird said: The first CSM trailer had a good amount of blood in it so it should be fine, not sure how they'll choose to handle Hell's Paradise.not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm. not sure obviously |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Rizaadxn said: pretty sure rhey will skip most; they may show just some flower corpsesThe_Early_Bird said: The first CSM trailer had a good amount of blood in it so it should be fine, not sure how they'll choose to handle Hell's Paradise.not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm. not sure obviously |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
| To the people saying MAPPA is doing too many projects at once, let's not forget that they also have over 250 employees. There is no reason for them to limit their ongoing projects to only a small amount, they have to pay all of their workers somehow after all. Also, they opened an entirely new office, which they are currently using just to animate Chainsaw Man (for now). We shouldn't be too worried right now. I'm sure out of all of their projects CSM is the one who will look the best and get the best treatment. |
The_Early_Bird said: what the music and the visuals got you? damn that's being a normal anime fan? read the manga. where is the sea of blood? where are the insects sucking blood honey from humans? where are the naked monsters(female) sucking male's blood. they just showed some criminals and monsters from the manga. not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm. not sure obviously I read the manga and still don't understand why you're being so aggressive on this trailer just because it doesn't show blood, just feels like nitpicking at best. The CSM teaser didn't show blood either except for the very last scene, and this trailer already shows a bunch of the creepy stuff and semi-nudity scenes. Acting like it will censored or "the trailer is shit" just because of it feels like jumping the gun unneccessarily early. |
Oongbuh said: well with stories with blood ridden hype train, people would obviously want more vigorous blood shits and that is why i like the manga. Also i personally did not like the trailer that muchThe_Early_Bird said: what the music and the visuals got you? damn that's being a normal anime fan? read the manga. where is the sea of blood? where are the insects sucking blood honey from humans? where are the naked monsters(female) sucking male's blood. they just showed some criminals and monsters from the manga. not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm. not sure obviously I read the manga and still don't understand why you're being so aggressive on this trailer just because it doesn't show blood, just feels like nitpicking at best. The CSM teaser didn't show blood either except for the very last scene, and this trailer already shows a bunch of the creepy stuff and semi-nudity scenes. Acting like it will censored or "the trailer is shit" just because of it feels like jumping the gun unneccessarily early. As we all know MAPPA is known to adapt mostly, one storied, trash but may/may not be popular manga |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
Oongbuh said: obviously i did not like CSM trailer too. I think they will censor many scenesThe_Early_Bird said: what the music and the visuals got you? damn that's being a normal anime fan? read the manga. where is the sea of blood? where are the insects sucking blood honey from humans? where are the naked monsters(female) sucking male's blood. they just showed some criminals and monsters from the manga. not much bloodbath that is why i said they may censor or skip some parts of blood and violence in csm. not sure obviously I read the manga and still don't understand why you're being so aggressive on this trailer just because it doesn't show blood, just feels like nitpicking at best. The CSM teaser didn't show blood either except for the very last scene, and this trailer already shows a bunch of the creepy stuff and semi-nudity scenes. Acting like it will censored or "the trailer is shit" just because of it feels like jumping the gun unneccessarily early. |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
The_Early_Bird said: If Mappa censors CSM I will never expect anything from the anime industry ever again.Oongbuh said: obviously i did not like CSM trailer too. I think they will censor many scenesI read the manga and still don't understand why you're being so aggressive on this trailer just because it doesn't show blood, just feels like nitpicking at best. The CSM teaser didn't show blood either except for the very last scene, and this trailer already shows a bunch of the creepy stuff and semi-nudity scenes. Acting like it will censored or "the trailer is shit" just because of it feels like jumping the gun unneccessarily early. |
| Can't see CSM getting censored heavily. Like the only thing I see being completely removed is the Quanxi sex scene, and that's just a chapter cover page... |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
| The first few images were from the original color version from the first chapter, here's some from the new version. It's color shift galore! |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
AbelDande said: so does dorohedoro too have exposed nipples and sex scenes on bed?The_Early_Bird said: ”Pretty sure they will skip most”pretty sure rhey will skip most; they may show just some flower corpses You need to watch Dorohedoro buddy. If you’ve watched it, I don’t know what make you say they’ll censor everything. i do not think so |
You all have to undrestand that Chainsaw man is impossible to adapt without CG. |
| MAPPA better bring the color palette game up how would they not if they saw the rainbow guts on the csm? |
k11chi said: The trailers make me think that they won't unfortunately. They're playing it safe and going with the gore/dark color palette, which isn't a bad thing necessarily, just a little boring and less ambitious imo.MAPPA better bring the color palette game up how would they not if they saw the rainbow guts on the csm? |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Rizaadxn said: k11chi said: The trailers make me think that they won't unfortunately. They're playing it safe and going with the gore/dark color palette, which isn't a bad thing necessarily, just a little boring and less ambitious imo.MAPPA better bring the color palette game up how would they not if they saw the rainbow guts on the csm? Assuming everything from a trailer which is pre animated and it doesn’t even consist actual series scenes except few . The best of the best freelancers and key animators are working in csm they know what they are doing . Mappa confidentially declared that CSM will be getting Ultimate adaptation . JJK 0 had 64 freelancers , all will be working in csm + there will be more . Ryu nakayama and Tatsuya yoshihara have good number of contacts to bring best animator’s so it won’t be a disappointment |
AtoferatofeJan 10, 2022 6:17 PM
 |
Beexi said: The chances that the anime will look visually different to the trailer are very very small, regardless of it being pre-animated. I don't think I've ever seen the color palette and art/animation style change once the season comes out. Assuming everything from a trailer which is pre animated and it doesn’t even consist actual series scenes except few. The trailer already shows the type of style MAPPA is going for. They aren't doing something different like they did with Idaten Deities, they're playing it safe and going with the gore color palette. Beexi said: This is entirely subject to personal opinion. IMO, the best possible adaptation for CSM would follow a similar color palette to the official manga color, I'm also not the biggest fan of MAPPA's normal style, which they are using here based on the trailer.The best of the best freelancers and key animators are working in csm they know what they are doing. Mappa confidentially declared that CSM will be getting Ultimate adaptation. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
| @Rizaadxn The chances that the anime will look visually different to the trailer are very very small, regardless of it being pre-animated. I don't think I've ever seen the color palette and art/animation style change once the season comes out. The pre animated trailer color palette idea was specially inspired from Shingo Yamashita jujutsu kaisen opening song 1 imitated by the director Director ryu nakayama and art director Yuusuke takeda both . The animation director’s for every episodes have their own storyboard’s and seeing the talented animator’s which csm anime has they will sure put their own style and color visions for every episode’s. The art style might change in between series when animation directors show their style in it like Mob psycho 2 ep 5,6 etc .. This is entirely subject to personal opinion. IMO, the best possible adaptation for CSM would follow a similar color palette to the official manga color, I'm also not the biggest fan of MAPPA's normal style, which they are using here based on the trailer. If they use the neon Color’s like in manga I won’t think it would be perfect for an anime or it would work it out well but I’m sure they will add different Color’s in manga for some sequences. Thinking that Mappa will go for normal style it’s utterly a prediction, I have seen the past works of the animation director’s who are going to work on chainsawman they will put their own flavour to make it more interesting and the devil designer and character designer are exceptionally talented in many ways and Kiyotaka oshiyama is known for flip flappers, space dandy and devilman crybaby. Wait for the actual trailer it’s gonna be little different from the Pv and the anime is sure going to have some interesting designs and color palette choices for every episode’s. |
AtoferatofeApr 14, 2022 5:35 PM
|
| Yeah, the colored version, the one I read, did look amazing. That doesn't necessarily mean it might translate well to the anime medium though I would rather wait for the anime to release. |
 |
Reply to Thururuzao
This thread aged like wine.
| @Thururuzao thanks lol. I know the majority disagree but after watching the anime for myself I stick by what I said. Funnily enough ever since the trailer for Dandadan came out I had a feeling it was going to get the adaptation I wanted to see for Chainsaw Man, I watched the premiere the other week in theaters and it was stunning, I'm so happy it's getting the adaptation I'd expect it to get but damn does it suck knowing Chainsaw Man could've had the same sort of treatment. I'm still interested to see what MAPPA plans on doing with the Reze movie regardless. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Reply to Rizaadxn
@Thururuzao thanks lol. I know the majority disagree but after watching the anime for myself I stick by what I said.
Funnily enough ever since the trailer for Dandadan came out I had a feeling it was going to get the adaptation I wanted to see for Chainsaw Man, I watched the premiere the other week in theaters and it was stunning, I'm so happy it's getting the adaptation I'd expect it to get but damn does it suck knowing Chainsaw Man could've had the same sort of treatment. I'm still interested to see what MAPPA plans on doing with the Reze movie regardless.
Funnily enough ever since the trailer for Dandadan came out I had a feeling it was going to get the adaptation I wanted to see for Chainsaw Man, I watched the premiere the other week in theaters and it was stunning, I'm so happy it's getting the adaptation I'd expect it to get but damn does it suck knowing Chainsaw Man could've had the same sort of treatment. I'm still interested to see what MAPPA plans on doing with the Reze movie regardless.
| @Rizaadxn Chainsaw Man fine the way it is. No need to look like DDD. Cinematic and realism is another Fujimoto approach. |
 |
Reply to CrazyFrogz
@Rizaadxn Chainsaw Man fine the way it is. No need to look like DDD. Cinematic and realism is another Fujimoto approach.
| @CrazyFrogz Chainsaw Man deserves more than just looking "fine". The approach taken by Science SARU with DDD is miles better than the direction taken by MAPPA with CSM. |
| "Never underestimate the stupidity of the average anime fan" |
Reply to Rizaadxn
@CrazyFrogz Chainsaw Man deserves more than just looking "fine". The approach taken by Science SARU with DDD is miles better than the direction taken by MAPPA with CSM.
| @Rizaadxn Nah. DDD looks like MOB 100 to me. Chainsaw man better with realistic style. If chainsaw man look cartoonish and vibrant like DDD i will stop watching the sequel. |
|
Reply to Rizaadxn
@CrazyFrogz Chainsaw Man deserves more than just looking "fine". The approach taken by Science SARU with DDD is miles better than the direction taken by MAPPA with CSM.
Rizaadxn said: Chainsaw Man deserves more than just looking "fine You're right, because it looked fantastic instead. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 27, 2022 |
981 |
by Soldierz17
»»
Yesterday, 8:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )YoshePlays - Oct 7, 2022 |
2659 |
by peluusaa
»»
Mar 16, 7:05 PM |
|
» Tatsuya Yoshihara will not be directing Reze movieCreepHazard - Feb 6, 2024 |
29 |
by Oongbuh
»»
Mar 2, 2:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 20, 2022 |
392 |
by YolkyGoblin
»»
Feb 20, 6:59 PM |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 6, 2022 |
583 |
by Sul_Anoji
»»
Feb 15, 12:10 AM |