| For the longest time this series has been my favorite, not in terms of LN but in terms of manga as I dont read the LN. After screaming for an hour I decided to look at the animation studio, and it doesnt look promising, What are your expectations for the anime? Another question worthy of noting is do you think the anime will flop? do you hope it will? for anyone who isnt aware about the series I recommend the read even with the anime coming out and for those who choose not to, I pray your time with the adaptation will be great! |
| A Wise Man Once Said: #(%!*@)+$& |
| In terms of the studio and directors, it really isn't exactly promising though the author did state on twitter that they took lot of supervision work and wrote manuscripts for the anime. I just hope the adaptation goes well. |
Blazu0Apr 17, 2021 8:00 PM
| Hopefully it goes well. The studio's animation is not bad, but the anime they have made so far aren't that good in terms of plot. Hopefully, this one changes that. Weebslayerr69 said: Wasn't it the author of TPN that made the changes in the anime's plot.Blazu0 said: In terms of the studio and directors, it really isn't exactly promising though the author did state on twitter that they took lot of supervision work and wrote manuscripts for the anime. I just hope the adaptation goes well. Yeah usually they tend to be either rushed or drastically changed like the promised neverland, but I think other studios learned for clover works mistake |
 |
Weebslayerr69 said: Yikes. That sucks.Judevin said: Hopefully it goes well. The studio's animation is not bad, but the anime they have made so far aren't that good in terms of plot. Hopefully, this one changes that. Wasn't it the author of TPN that made the changes in the anime's plot. This is from CBR "The Promised Neverland Season 2, Episode 10 has three credited directors (Ayako Kurata, RyΕ Kodama and Shigeru Fukase) but no credited screenwriter. Toshiya Ono, who wrote the first four episodes of the season, is still credited with the overall "series composition" but not as the individual episode's writer. Nanao, the writer of Episodes 5-9 this season as well as the manga's light novel adaptation, isn't credited either. Perhaps most damningly of all, the "series composition" credit for original manga creator Kaiu Shirai is gone as of this episode." So I thought other people also had a say in the way the story should go other than the author I just thought it was the author the whole time considering CloverWorks wouldn't want to fuck over their greatest hit anime. So it had to have been the author who threw CW under the bus so that his manga looks better in comparison. But that just sucks to read. Even though I didn't find the manga very good, S2 was just awful. Good to know, man. Thanks. |
|
| Why has the subject derailed to TPN2? Aren't they different studio, directors and authors? |
Blazu0Apr 17, 2021 11:09 PM
Blazu0 said: Classic discourse lmao. You know, the usual.Why has the subject derailed to TPN2? Aren't they different studio, directors and authors? Yes, nothing in common afaik. I was more so trying to point out that the author interfering is not always good, although that isn't exactly the case with TPN(?) But hopefully this wouldn't be bad. Sometimes just one anime is enough to boost a whole studio's performance. I mentioned it on the other Paladin thread, but Yuru Camp is C-Station's only 8+ rated anime. So there are chances that CPE will make this their best adaptation yet. Fingers crossed. Especially since the source material is such a good LN. |
|
Judevin said: Blazu0 said: Classic discourse lmao. You know, the usual.Why has the subject derailed to TPN2? Aren't they different studio, directors and authors? Yes, nothing in common afaik. I was more so trying to point out that the author interfering is not always good, although that isn't exactly the case with TPN(?) But hopefully this wouldn't be bad. Sometimes just one anime is enough to boost a whole studio's performance. I mentioned it on the other Paladin thread, but Yuru Camp is C-Station's only 8+ rated anime. So there are chances that CPE will make this their best adaptation yet. Fingers crossed. Especially since the source material is such a good LN. I always find it reassuring when the author is apart of the anime project. Honestly I really do hope you're right about CPE, it's their current biggest chance to make a name for their selves. |
| just saw the trailer to this and it looks pretty cool, haven't seen or even heard abt the manga but ill make sure to read it. and i agree with you the studio thats working on this isn't really promising but the trailer looks decent so i hope they do it well |
| I absolutely love the manga, it's one of my favourite. As for anime my expectations are low. so far teaser looks low budget and seiyuu cast is disappointing, William voice doesn't fit him at all, I imagined Mary to have calm voice like Endou Aya, and Menel tsundere shounen voice, I can't imagine Murase voicing him. But well, still will give it a try. |
 |
| damn. i love this manga but the art and colors in the trailer are not at all good imo. this will be very depressing if it fails... |
| i was just about to read the ln but then i saw its getting adapted. i cant decide if i should still read or just wait zzz |
 π«ππ
πΆ π
πΎππ πΆππΉ πππ πΎππππππΆππΎπππΉ π―π½ππππ½π π πππΈπππ ππππππΎπΉπ π«πππΎπ»π ππ π ππΎπππππΉ ππΎππΉ   |
| I've read the manga. It was pretty good but yeah, I need to cross my fingers on this and keep my expectations low. I really hope it's a good anime adaptation but yeah... |
| I feel my blood boiling. Not from excitement. But from fear that they are gonna screw this up. And badly at that when I saw the studio and directors. For example, Meneldor. Will's background story. And those three....please, I beg of you, don't mess this up or at least hand it over to a different studio if you're not confident enough. :( |
| Studio and Light Novel adaptation aren't good signs but I want to believe this can turn out good somehow. Will wait and see. |
  |
Hyperactivy said: For the longest time this series has been my favorite, not in terms of LN but in terms of manga as I dont read the LN. After screaming for an hour I decided to look at the animation studio, and it doesnt look promising, What are your expectations for the anime? Another question worthy of noting is do you think the anime will flop? do you hope it will? for anyone who isnt aware about the series I recommend the read even with the anime coming out and for those who choose not to, I pray your time with the adaptation will be great! How are you feeling now? Anime appears to be doing well and although I've seen nothing stellar animation wise it is at least competent. |
| Quantum ille canis est in fenestra |
borderliner said: Hyperactivy said: For the longest time this series has been my favorite, not in terms of LN but in terms of manga as I dont read the LN. After screaming for an hour I decided to look at the animation studio, and it doesnt look promising, What are your expectations for the anime? Another question worthy of noting is do you think the anime will flop? do you hope it will? for anyone who isnt aware about the series I recommend the read even with the anime coming out and for those who choose not to, I pray your time with the adaptation will be great! How are you feeling now? Anime appears to be doing well and although I've seen nothing stellar animation wise it is at least competent. My love for the series didnt drop in the slightest but I am a bit dissapointed with the anime, purely because it feels rushed even if it isnt, im still enjoying every second of it and would recommend it to anyone who is interested |
| A Wise Man Once Said: #(%!*@)+$& |
| I read and liked the manga, so I watched the anime. Honestly it was good, not great, but I'm not disappointed. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Saihate no Paladin Episode 10 DiscussionPre_Yum - Dec 18, 2021 |
48 |
by Ambeon
»»
Oct 24, 2024 6:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Saihate no Paladin Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 3, 2022 |
88 |
by WolfWood37
»»
Oct 22, 2024 12:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Saihate no Paladin Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 25, 2021 |
60 |
by WolfWood37
»»
Oct 22, 2024 12:12 AM |
|
Poll: » Saihate no Paladin Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 11, 2021 |
53 |
by WolfWood37
»»
Oct 18, 2024 1:25 AM |
|
Poll: » Saihate no Paladin Episode 8 DiscussionPre_Yum - Dec 4, 2021 |
49 |
by WolfWood37
»»
Oct 18, 2024 1:00 AM |